Cherreads

Chapter 8 - Guilty Pleasure!!!

Jessica's POV

After that day, things between us changed again.

We became more open, more comfortable—sometimes joking in ways that felt dangerous if I thought about it too much. It was like we had crossed into a space where normal rules didn't feel as strict anymore.

But underneath all of that, I could feel something else growing in me too.

Attachment.

And fear.

One day, when he came over again, everything felt the same at first—warm, familiar, like we were falling into our usual pattern. But deep down, I knew I was not as calm as I tried to look.

At some point, the emotions became too heavy for me. My thoughts started racing, and suddenly I couldn't ignore the nervousness I had been pushing aside.

I pulled back.

"I… I don't think I can do this," I said softly.

My voice didn't sound like me.

The room went quiet.

He looked at me, and for the first time, everything slowed down completely. No teasing, no intensity—just a pause where reality finally stepped in.

I expected him to get angry, or disappointed.

But instead, it was just silence between us. Heavy, complicated silence.

Because in that moment, I realized something I hadn't admitted to myself yet—

This wasn't just about desire anymore.

It was about emotions neither of us had fully learned how to handle.

He didn't push me away.

Instead, he pulled me closer—calm, steady, like he was trying to reassure me without needing many words. And somehow, in that silence, I stopped resisting my own thoughts.

I let myself follow him.

Not because I didn't feel scared… but because I didn't know how to separate fear from want anymore.

Everything between us had become intense in a way I couldn't fully explain. Like we were too close to think clearly, too attached to step back, too caught in each other to pretend this was simple.

And afterward… I kept thinking about it.

Not just the moments themselves, but what they meant.

Because it didn't stop there.

It became something we returned to whenever we had the chance—like we had stepped into a pattern we couldn't easily break.

But the truth was, my heart wasn't as calm as I pretended.

Every time I was alone afterward, a different feeling would come in quietly.

Guilt.

Confusion.

And something even harder to admit—

I was starting to wonder where this was actually going.

Because what felt like "us" was beginning to feel less like love… and more like something I was slowly getting lost in.

We ended up getting admitted to the same coaching.

At first, it felt like something lucky—almost like life was giving us more time together on purpose.

And in a way, it did.

We spent nearly 8–9 hours a day around each other. Coaching classes, breaks, walking with friends to the park afterward… it all started blending into one routine where he was just there, constantly.

It became normal to see him everywhere.

Too normal.

But normal doesn't always mean stable.

One day, while we were talking, he said something casually—like it didn't mean much.

"If someone ever offers me a cigarette, I'll probably say yes immediately."

It stuck in my head longer than it should have.

I don't even know why.

Maybe because I wanted to do something that would matter to him in a way words couldn't.

Maybe because I wanted to be the one he reacted to.

That evening, after class, I asked him to come with me to the stairs.

He kept asking what I was doing. Over and over. But I didn't answer properly. I just told him to trust me for a second.

"Just turn around," I said.

My hands were shaking more than I expected.

And then I said it.

The words came out before I could stop them.

"I love you."

The moment it left my mouth, everything inside me dropped.

Silence.

I instantly regretted it.

Not because it wasn't true… but because I could already feel something shifting in the air between us.

I looked at his face, searching for anything—surprise, confusion, warmth, rejection.

And what I saw told me I had just crossed into something I couldn't undo easily.

Something had changed in him too.

And for the first time, I wasn't sure if I had moved closer to him…

or pushed everything we had into a place I couldn't control anymore.

The moment the words left my mouth, I already felt it—regret sitting heavy in my chest.

But I still looked at him, waiting. Hoping. Even though I didn't want to admit it.

He didn't take long to react.

He stepped closer and pulled me slightly, like he was trying to ground the situation before it spiraled.

"I already told you," he said, his voice lower now, more serious than I was used to. "I can't commit."

Those words didn't come like a surprise.

But hearing them still hit differently.

For a second, everything around us felt normal again—coaching, people, noise, routine—but inside me, it felt like something had just gone quiet.

Not peaceful.

Just… empty.

I looked at him, trying to read something softer behind his expression. Something that would make it hurt less.

But there wasn't confusion in his face.

There was clarity.

And that somehow made it worse.

I nodded slowly, even though my throat felt tight.

"Okay," I said, barely audible.

Because what else could I say?

I had stepped forward with my feelings… and he had stayed exactly where he always said he was.

Not moving closer.

Not moving away.

Just there—unchanged.

And in that moment, I realized the hardest part wasn't hearing no.

It was realizing I had been hoping for a different answer all along.

I forced a smile.

A small one. The kind that looks normal from the outside… but feels completely fake when you're the one wearing it.

Inside me, it wasn't calm at all.

It felt like a tornado—fast, loud, uncontrollable. Thoughts crashing into each other, emotions I didn't know how to place, and a strange pressure in my chest that made it hard to even breathe properly.

But I didn't let it show.

I couldn't.

Not there. Not in front of him.

He didn't speak immediately.

He just stared at me.

For a long time.

Like he was trying to understand what I was thinking, or maybe what I was about to become after hearing him.

And I stood there pretending everything was fine.

My face stayed steady. My lips still curved slightly like nothing had happened. But my eyes… I made sure they didn't give me away.

I blinked slowly, holding back everything that was trying to come out.

Not now.

Not here.

Not in front of him.

Because if I broke in that moment, I knew I wouldn't be able to fix how I looked in his eyes again.

So I stayed quiet.

And smiled.

Even while everything inside me was falling apart.

More Chapters