Chapter 9: Caradhras
The mountain broke them on the second day.
Cedric had expected the cold. He'd braced himself for the wind, the snow, the bitter exhaustion of climbing through drifts that reached his chest. But meta-knowledge couldn't prepare him for the malice of Caradhras — the sense that the mountain itself was alive and angry and determined to crush them into frozen corpses.
Saruman's voice rode the wind.
The wizard's words were lost in the howling, but the meaning was clear enough. Ice drove horizontally across the cliff path, finding gaps in cloaks and hoods, settling against skin with a cold that burned. Snow fell in walls rather than flakes, burying the Fellowship's tracks within minutes of each step.
"We must turn back!" Boromir's voice cut through the storm. "The Hobbits cannot survive this!"
He was right. Frodo had gone grey as ash, his small form shaking despite the layers wrapped around him. Sam pressed against his side, teeth chattering, his own face pale beneath wind-burned cheeks. Merry and Pippin huddled together at the path's edge, too cold even to complain.
"We cannot turn back now!" Gandalf raised his staff, and a tongue of flame bloomed at its tip. "We are too far up — the descent would kill us as surely as the ascent!"
He's wrong, Cedric thought. They make it down in the story. They make it down and they go to Moria and—
And you could have prevented all of this. Three days ago, you could have spoken, and they would have chosen differently.
The Pact pulsed warm in his chest, satisfied with its investment. The essence he'd gained from his silence sat beside it like a small, cold coin — the first payment in a transaction he hadn't agreed to but couldn't refuse.
[HEROISM OPPORTUNITY DETECTED]
[ACTION: PROTECT HOBBITS FROM EXPOSURE]
[PROJECTED CONSEQUENCE: TIER 1 PUNISHMENT — SUSTAINED]
Cedric didn't hesitate.
He stripped his cloak from his shoulders and wrapped it around Pippin and Merry, pulling both Hobbits against his chest and using his body as a windbreak. The cold struck his exposed back like a hammer, driving the breath from his lungs, and the Pact's rune-burn ignited across his forearms in immediate response.
Punishment for protection. Payment for kindness.
But he held position anyway.
"Cedric—" Pippin's teeth chattered against his shoulder. "You'll freeze—"
"I'm a Ranger," Cedric said through his own shivers. "We're made of sterner stuff than this."
It wasn't true. The cold was killing him by inches, his fingers going numb in their gloves and his face losing feeling to the wind. But the Hobbits were warmer now, sheltered by his bulk, and that was worth the price.
Across the path, Boromir had done the same — his great form hunched over Frodo and Sam, his Gondorian armor gathering ice that would have to be scraped free later. Their eyes met over the Hobbits' heads, and something passed between them that words couldn't have carried.
Two mortal Men, shielding the small folk from the mountain's wrath.
Brotherhood forged in cold rather than fire.
Boromir's Morgul-mark blazed brighter, and Cedric's runes burned hotter, and both of them held position as the storm raged around them.
The Ring fell.
It happened in a moment of chaos — Frodo stumbling in a snowdrift, the chain around his neck slipping free, the small gold band tumbling into the white like a drop of fire falling into milk.
Boromir moved fastest.
His hand closed around the Ring, lifting it from the snow, and for one terrible moment his face changed. The weariness and cold fell away, replaced by something that was and wasn't Boromir — a hunger that transformed noble features into something ancient and wrong.
"It is a strange fate," Boromir murmured, "that we should suffer so much fear and doubt for so small a thing." His eyes fixed on the Ring, and Cedric could see the corruption threading through his Morgul-mark like poison through veins. "So small a thing..."
"Boromir."
Aragorn's voice cut through the wind. The Heir of Isildur stood a few paces away, his hand resting on his sword-hilt with deliberate casualness.
"Give the Ring to Frodo."
The moment stretched. Snow drove between them. The wind screamed Saruman's wordless fury. And Boromir's face flickered between hunger and horror as he realized what he'd almost done.
"Of course."
He handed the Ring back to Frodo with a laugh that didn't quite sound genuine. "I care not."
But Cedric saw the truth. The Ring had found its opening, and Boromir had felt its first real touch. The vulnerability threads in his Morgul-mark had darkened, the corruption deeper than it had been moments before.
[BOROMIR — VULNERABILITY STATUS UPDATE]
[RING-CORRUPTION: STAGE 1 → STAGE 2]
[BETRAYAL PROJECTION: ELEVATED]
Amon Hen, Cedric thought, watching Boromir turn away with his shoulders too stiff and his face too carefully blank. That's where it ends for him. That's where the Ring breaks him.
Unless I do something.
Unless I find a way to save him without revealing what I know.
The Pact pulsed once, curious and cold. It didn't demand anything — not yet — but Cedric felt its attention sharpen. Boromir's corruption was an opportunity, and the system was already calculating how it might be used.
The Fellowship retreated down the mountain as dusk fell.
The descent was almost worse than the climb — frozen limbs struggling for purchase on ice-slick stone, the knowledge of failure bitter in every mouth. They'd challenged Caradhras and Caradhras had won, just as Cedric had known it would.
Just as I could have prevented.
He walked at the column's rear, his recovered cloak wrapped around shoulders that still shook with cold. The rune-burn from hours of protecting the Hobbits had finally faded, but the ache of it lingered in his bones. The Ring of Barahir was cold against his finger, silent now but still present — still marking his betrayals even when the Pact rewarded them.
"We must seek another path."
Gandalf's voice carried defeat for the first time since Cedric had known him. The wizard stood at a turning of the mountain trail, looking down toward the valley floor where the dark mouth of Moria waited.
"There is a door in the mountains' roots. The Doors of Durin. If we can find them, if they can be opened, we may pass through the Mines and emerge on the other side of the mountains."
"The Mines of Moria." Gimli's voice held hope despite everything. "My cousin Balin—"
"We do not know what has become of Balin's colony." Gandalf's tone gentled, but his eyes remained hard. "We do not know what waits in the dark. I would not take this road, save that all other roads have failed."
And I let them fail, Cedric thought. I knew what waited on Caradhras, and I said nothing.
The cold essence in his chest pulsed once, confirming the transaction. He'd traded the Fellowship's suffering for a taste of power, and the Pact had accepted the exchange.
"Let the Ringbearer decide," Gandalf said. "It is his burden. It should be his choice."
Frodo looked up at the dark entrance to Moria — the valley below barely visible in the failing light, but the shape of it clear enough. His face was grey with exhaustion, his eyes old beyond their years.
"We will go through the Mines."
The words fell like stones into still water. Gandalf bowed his head in acceptance. Gimli's eyes brightened despite his weariness. And Cedric felt the Pact settle deeper into his chest, satisfied with the outcome it had helped engineer.
Moria. The Balrog. Gandalf's fall.
I know what's coming. I know every step of the path ahead.
And I don't know if I can stop any of it.
The Fellowship descended toward the dark door in the mountainside, and Cedric walked among them with the weight of foreknowledge pressing against his skull. The Pact had shown him its first reward for silence. The Ring of Barahir had shown him its first rebuke for betrayal.
And somewhere in the depths of Moria, something ancient and terrible was about to wake.
Reviews and Power Stones keep the heat on!
Want to see what happens before the "heroes" do?
Secure your spot in the inner circle on Patreon. Skip the weekly wait and read ahead:
Hustler [$7]: 15 Chapters ahead.
Enforcer [$11]: 20 Chapters ahead.
Kingpin [$16]: 25 Chapters ahead.
Periodic drops. Check on Patreon for the full release list.
Join the Syndicate: patreon.com/Anti_hero_fanfic