Chapter 10: The Gates of Moria
The Doors of Durin caught the last light of dusk like silver bones rising from the stone.
Cedric stood with the Fellowship at the water's edge, watching Gandalf trace the moonletters that had emerged across the ancient rock. The Elvish script gleamed with pale fire, beautiful and frustrating in equal measure — a riddle that had locked these gates since the days when Dwarves and Elves traded as friends.
"Speak friend and enter," his meta-knowledge supplied. The password is Mellon. Friend in Sindarin. Gandalf will figure it out, but not before—
The dark water of the lake stirred.
Cedric's hand found his sword-hilt. He shifted position without conscious thought, placing himself between the Hobbits and the water's edge. The movement was subtle — a Ranger adjusting his footing — but Aragorn's eyes tracked it with the quiet attention of a man who noticed such things.
"The water," Cedric said quietly. "Something moves beneath it."
Aragorn followed his gaze to the lake. The surface rippled in patterns that had nothing to do with wind.
"I see nothing."
"Not yet."
The Pact stirred in his chest, warm with approval. It wanted him to stay silent, to let the Watcher attack while the doors remained sealed, to let chaos compound into disaster. But Cedric's body was already positioned for defense, his stance communicating danger to anyone watching.
A compromise, he told himself. I'm not revealing foreknowledge. I'm just being a cautious Ranger.
The distinction felt thinner than it should have.
Gandalf cursed in a language older than Sindarin and threw down his staff.
"I've tried every spell, every command, every word of power in twenty tongues. The doors do not answer."
"Perhaps the riddle is simpler than you think," Frodo said. The young Hobbit sat on a boulder near the water, his face pale with exhaustion. "It says 'speak friend and enter.' What if—"
"Mellon."
Gandalf spoke the word with sudden comprehension, and the Doors of Durin swung inward on hinges that hadn't moved in centuries. Darkness breathed outward from the gap, carrying the smell of old stone and older death.
The Fellowship surged forward. Cedric moved with them, his sword clearing its sheath, his eyes fixed on the water behind them.
The Watcher erupted from the lake.
Tentacles — pale and grasping, thick as tree trunks — burst from the surface and seized Frodo before anyone could react. The Ringbearer's scream cut through the night as he was dragged toward the water, the Ring blazing against his chest with its own cold fury.
"Frodo!"
Sam's voice. Then Boromir's blade, flashing in the moonlight as he carved into the nearest tentacle. Aragorn was a heartbeat behind, his sword biting deep into flesh that shouldn't exist in any natural world.
Cedric joined them.
The Ranger's body knew exactly how to fight — angles of attack, vulnerable joints, the rhythm of tentacle-strike and counter-stroke that came from thirty years of combat against things that shouldn't exist. But Cedric's mind knew more. He knew the Watcher's central mass lurked beneath the surface, that the tentacles were extensions of something vast and old and hungry. He knew that killing the arms would do nothing but buy time.
The weak point is the eye, his meta-knowledge whispered. But you can't reach it without swimming into the mass. So the goal is extraction, not destruction.
He drove his blade into a tentacle that was reaching for Pippin, the steel biting deep. The young Hobbit stumbled back with a yelp of terror, and Cedric caught his arm, pulling him toward the doors.
"Move! All of you — into Moria!"
Boromir had freed Frodo. The Fellowship was running, streaming through the doors while Aragorn and Cedric held the rear. The tentacles writhed after them, smashing against the doorframe, bringing down ancient stone in an avalanche that sealed the entrance behind them.
Darkness. Complete and total.
Then Gandalf's staff bloomed with pale light, and the Fellowship stood in a vast entrance hall of carved stone, their breath coming in ragged gasps, the doors buried behind them under tons of rubble.
[HEROIC ACTION: COMBAT DEFENSE]
[CONSEQUENCE: TIER 1 DISCOMFORT — MINOR]
The rune-burn flickered across Cedric's forearms, noting his choice to protect. But the Pact didn't press hard. It was satisfied.
Because Cedric had also withheld. He'd known the Watcher was coming and hadn't warned the Fellowship explicitly. He'd positioned himself defensively but let the attack happen. And when he'd fought, he'd used meta-knowledge to optimize his combat effectiveness without explaining how he knew the creature's vulnerabilities.
Another omission. Another small betrayal. Another thin trickle of essence that settled into the cold space in his chest.
The Ring of Barahir burned cold against his finger — fainter this time, as though it was growing accustomed to the sting.
"We cannot go back."
Gandalf's voice echoed in the entrance hall. The wizard's staff-light revealed columns carved with Dwarven runes, disappearing into darkness overhead. The air was dead and still, carrying no trace of the world outside.
"The only path leads forward. Three days' march, if my memory serves, before we reach the East-gate and the outer world."
Gimli's face was a mask of complicated emotion. The Dwarf stared into the darkness ahead with eyes that held hope and dread in equal measure.
"My cousin Balin came here years ago," he said. "With a company of Dwarves to reclaim the ancient home. We have had no word since."
Because they're all dead, Cedric thought. Balin lies in the Chamber of Mazarbul, and his colony was overrun by Orcs. You'll find his tomb tomorrow, and the grief will nearly break you.
He said nothing.
The Pact purred in his chest, warm and satisfied with his silence.
"Then we walk," Aragorn said. "And we walk carefully. This place has not been empty for long."
The Fellowship formed up — Gandalf in the lead with his staff-light, Legolas and Gimli close behind, the Hobbits in the protected center, Boromir and Cedric and Aragorn bringing up the rear. They moved into the darkness like a small army invading a kingdom of shadows.
Cedric's fingers ached where the Ring of Barahir pressed cold against his skin. The frostmark beneath the band had faded, but a new one was forming — a ring of discolored flesh that recorded each small betrayal.
Three days, he thought. Three days in the dark, and then the Bridge, and then—
The Pact stirred with anticipation, and Cedric walked into Moria with the weight of foreknowledge pressing against his skull like stone.
Reviews and Power Stones keep the heat on!
Want to see what happens before the "heroes" do?
Secure your spot in the inner circle on Patreon. Skip the weekly wait and read ahead:
Hustler [$7]: 15 Chapters ahead.
Enforcer [$11]: 20 Chapters ahead.
Kingpin [$16]: 25 Chapters ahead.
Periodic drops. Check on Patreon for the full release list.
Join the Syndicate: patreon.com/Anti_hero_fanfic