Chapter 8: The Crebain and the Choice
The black birds came screaming out of the south.
Cedric saw them first — a dark cloud on the horizon that moved wrong, wheeling and reforming with the coordinated precision of soldiers rather than wildlife. His meta-knowledge snapped the identification into place before his Ranger instincts could complete their assessment: Crebain from Dunland, Saruman's spies, exactly as he remembered from films watched in another life.
"Cover!"
His voice cracked across the Fellowship like a whip. The others didn't hesitate — days of hard travel had built trust in quick commands — and within seconds the company had scattered into the hollows between rocks and the shadows beneath gorse bushes.
Cedric pressed himself against cold stone, Pippin squashed beside him with Merry on the other side. The Crebain swept overhead in a screaming mass, their calls echoing off the hills of Hollin, and for a long moment the world was nothing but black wings and ancient malice.
Then they passed, reforming into their dark cloud and continuing east toward the mountains.
[HEROIC ACTION: WARNING ISSUED]
[CONSEQUENCE: TIER 1 DISCOMFORT — MINOR]
The rune-burn flickered across Cedric's forearms, mild but present. The Pact noted his choice to protect the Fellowship and registered its disapproval without pressing hard.
Because it knows what's coming. It knows I'm about to give it something better.
"Spies of Saruman," Gandalf said grimly, emerging from his hiding place. "The passage south is being watched. We cannot go that way."
"Then we have three choices." Aragorn rose and brushed stone-dust from his cloak. "The Gap of Rohan, where Saruman's forces gather. The Redhorn Gate over Caradhras, where the mountain itself may defeat us. Or—"
"Moria."
Gimli's voice carried more weight than the single word deserved. The Dwarf's eyes gleamed with something caught between hope and grief.
"The Mines of Moria. My cousin Balin established a colony there years ago. If we could reach him—"
"Moria." Gandalf's face darkened. "I would not take that road save in great need. There are older and fouler things than Orcs in the deep places of the world."
The Balrog, Cedric thought. Durin's Bane, waiting in the dark. You don't want to go there because you know what waits. And you're right not to want it.
But you're going to go anyway. Because Caradhras will defeat you, and there won't be any other choice.
The Fellowship debated. Boromir argued for the Gap of Rohan — Gondor lay that direction, and he knew those lands better than mountain passes or Dwarven ruins. Legolas spoke for Caradhras with Elven confidence in his ability to walk on snow. Gimli pressed for Moria with the stubbornness of a Dwarf longing for his people's works.
And Cedric said nothing.
I could speak. I could tell them that Saruman's sorcery will turn Caradhras against them. I could argue for Moria directly, spare them three days of freezing on a mountainside. I could—
But how would I explain knowing? How would I justify certainty about a road I've never walked?
The Pact tightened in his chest, warm for the first time since Rivendell. It recognized what he was doing — or rather, what he wasn't doing. The silence was a choice. The silence was an omission. And omission, in the Pact's cold mathematics, counted as complicity.
[BETRAYAL-BY-OMISSION DETECTED]
[FELLOWSHIP ENDANGERED BY WITHHELD KNOWLEDGE]
[ESSENCE REWARD: MINIMAL — FIRST FEEDING]
Cold trickled into Cedric's chest. Not ice, not pain, but something worse — a faint presence where there had been emptiness before. The Pact's first harvest from his hands, earned by his silence.
And the Ring of Barahir burned.
The cold bit into his finger like frozen metal pressed against flesh. Cedric yanked his hand beneath his cloak, but not before Aragorn noticed the flinch.
"The wind is bitter," his kinsman said. "We should decide before nightfall."
Cedric nodded, not trusting his voice. The Ring of Barahir was the heirloom of his heritage — the serpents representing oath and counter-oath, the ancient symbol of the line of Barahir and the Houses of Men who served the Light. It was reacting to his betrayal of that heritage, burning cold where the Pact burned warm.
Even the ring knows. Even the metal knows what I just did.
Gandalf made the decision. "We will attempt Caradhras. The mountain is cruel, but it is not Saruman's creature. If the weather holds, we can cross in three days."
It won't hold. The weather is Saruman's weapon, and you're walking straight into his trap.
And I'm letting you.
They marched toward Caradhras as the sun began to set, and Boromir fell into step beside Cedric.
"You did not speak during the debate."
The observation carried no accusation, only curiosity. Boromir's Morgul-mark pulsed steady and bright, the warrior-bond between them solid despite everything.
"I trust Gandalf's judgment," Cedric said. "He knows these lands better than I do."
"Do you?" Boromir's smile was crooked. "I'm not certain I trust anyone's judgment where ancient evil is concerned. But I am grateful — more than I can say — to have another Man's counsel in this company."
His voice dropped, taking on a weight that surprised Cedric.
"Aragorn is... Aragorn. The Heir of Isildur, the Ranger who will be King. The Elves and the wizard defer to him, and the Hobbits look at him like he's something out of legend. But you and I — we are mortal Men, Cedric. We see the world through mortal eyes. We understand what it is to serve kingdoms that may not survive to see our grandchildren."
He's lonely, Cedric realized. Lonely and afraid and reaching out for connection with someone who shares his mortality.
"Gondor will survive," Cedric said. The words came out before he could stop them, carrying the certainty of meta-knowledge he couldn't explain. "And so will the men who serve her."
Boromir's mark flared brighter. The trust between them deepened, built on words that were true but incomplete.
I could tell him what waits at Amon Hen. I could warn him about the Ring's corruption, help him fight it before it breaks him.
But then I'd have to explain how I know. And the Pact is listening.
The cold essence inside his chest pulsed once, patient and satisfied, and Cedric walked toward the mountain that would defeat them with the taste of silence heavy on his tongue.
Reviews and Power Stones keep the heat on!
Want to see what happens before the "heroes" do?
Secure your spot in the inner circle on Patreon. Skip the weekly wait and read ahead:
Hustler [$7]: 15 Chapters ahead.
Enforcer [$11]: 20 Chapters ahead.
Kingpin [$16]: 25 Chapters ahead.
Periodic drops. Check on Patreon for the full release list.
Join the Syndicate: patreon.com/Anti_hero_fanfic