Chapter 14 — Why He Doesn't Fall in Love
Martin pushed the burger away after two bites.
This was not a reflection on the burger itself, which had looked entirely reasonable. It was a reflection on what he'd observed through the kitchen pass-through window approximately six minutes earlier, which involved Oleg — the cook, a man whose entire presentation suggested a complicated relationship with professional boundaries — doing something with his hands that Martin had decided he didn't need to investigate further.
He drank his Diet Coke and considered this a complete meal.
The diner closed at two. Max ran the register closeout with the brisk efficiency of someone who'd done it a hundred times and had opinions about the fastest way; Caroline counted the tip jar at a separate table with the focused concentration of someone for whom sixty-three dollars represented something real now in a way it never had before.
They split it down the middle without discussion. Martin watched this and noted that whatever the arrangement was between them, it had been arrived at cleanly.
"You're coming back with us," Max informed him, rather than asked, while untying her apron. "Caroline said you live in Queens, which at this hour is a commitment, and we have a couch."
"The couch has seen better days," Caroline added, not looking up from the bills.
"All the couches in Brooklyn have seen better days. It's a borough-wide condition." Max looked at Martin. "You're coming."
Martin looked at his watch. Looked at the door. Looked at the window where the Williamsburg street was doing its late-night thing.
"Alright," he said.
The apartment was three blocks away, on the second floor of a building that had the particular character of a place that had been a lot of things over the years and was currently a home through sheer persistence. The stairwell smelled like someone's cooking from three floors up. The door had a lock that required a specific sequence of jiggle-and-lift to open.
Inside: small, genuinely lived-in, with the productive chaos of two people figuring out how to exist in limited square footage. A baking setup occupied one corner of the kitchen with the organized ambition of a serious project — mixing bowls nested, bags of flour and sugar stacked, a stand mixer that was clearly the nicest thing in the room.
Caroline moved quickly through the living room, gathering items of clothing from the couch and chair with the practiced embarrassment of someone who'd stopped being able to maintain their previous standards and hadn't fully made peace with it.
Martin put his hands in his pockets and looked around with genuine, unhurried interest.
"It's good," he said.
Caroline looked at him.
"I mean it. It's warm. It's someone's actual home." He nodded at the baking corner. "That's a serious setup."
Max, who was already changed out of her uniform into cutoffs and a worn t-shirt that appeared to date from a concert in the nineties, looked at the mixer with the specific pride of an artist regarding their tools. "The mixer cost more than my rent deposit. My landlord thinks I'm insane."
"He's not wrong, but he's also not right," Martin said. "What do you make?"
"Cupcakes, mostly. Working on the recipe." She pulled down a mixing bowl without ceremony. "You're getting a sample whether you want one or not, so you might as well want one."
"Two dozen," Martin said. "I'll pay."
"You won't," Max said. "Sit down."
Martin sat.
He watched her work — the efficiency of someone who knew exactly what she was doing, measuring without fuss, movements practiced and economical. Max Black was, he'd established in approximately ninety minutes, one of those people whose surface was all sharp edges and dry humor but whose actual character was considerably warmer than the presentation suggested. She'd been watching out for Caroline since the moment Caroline walked into that diner, and she did it without making it seem like a favor, which was the sophisticated version.
"I was a little worried," Martin said, to the room, "after the hotel checkout. I had this image of Caroline trying to negotiate terms with someone over a park bench."
"I can hear you," Caroline said, from the bedroom.
"You're supposed to."
"She showed up at the diner looking like she'd stepped out of a magazine," Max said, folding dry ingredients, "which in Williamsburg is basically a costume. Han hired her immediately, which I think was approximately forty percent about the job and sixty percent about the visual impact."
"That tracks," Martin said.
"She's figuring it out." Max said it matter-of-factly, not as a compliment exactly but as an observation with respect in it. "She complains about the shoes and the uniform and the customers, but she shows up. And she's better at the job than she thinks she is."
"Don't tell her that," Martin said. "She'll stop trying so hard."
"I know." Max glanced over her shoulder. "You're not as much of an idiot as the suit implies."
"That's the nicest thing anyone's said to me this week."
"It's Tuesday."
"Still counts."
Caroline reappeared in a white dress that she'd clearly had in the suitcase from the beginning and had been saving for something, though perhaps hadn't known what. She looked like herself — the version of herself she'd been before, filtered through something new.
Martin stood, and the greeting was easy and unperformed — an arm around her shoulders, a kiss on the top of her head, the physical language of two people who knew each other well enough to have gotten past the self-conscious parts.
"You look like yourself," he said.
Caroline looked at the floor for a moment. "That's the first time anyone's said that in two weeks."
"Sit down," Max said. "Both of you. The first batch is twenty minutes."
They sat on the couch — Martin on one end, Caroline in the middle, Max dropping onto the other end once the batter was in the oven, pulling one knee up to her chest. The apartment was quiet in the way that late-night apartments are quiet, the city doing its thing outside the window, the oven ticking.
"Can I ask you something?" Max said to Martin.
"Sure."
She looked at him with the direct appraisal she'd been applying to him since he walked in, something that wasn't quite a challenge but required an honest answer. "You and Caroline. You clearly like each other. You've known each other for — what, years?"
"A few years," Martin said.
"So why aren't you together?"
Caroline looked at the ceiling.
Martin considered the question. Max was asking it seriously, which meant it deserved a serious answer.
"Do you want the honest version or the diplomatic version?" he said.
"I've never used the diplomatic version in my life," Max said. "What do you think."
Martin looked at his hands for a moment. "I've spent a lot of time watching people get married. Good people, smart people, people who meant every word of it on the day." He paused. "And then I've spent time watching some of those same people in a conference room three years later, going through each other like demolition work, fighting over things they didn't even care about before — because the thing they're really fighting about is that they loved each other once and now they don't and neither of them can make sense of how that happened." He looked up. "Wedding vows are genuinely beautiful. The problem is that they're asked to cover too much distance. Nobody knows who they'll be in ten years."
Max was quiet for a moment. "So you just — don't?"
"I'm honest about what I can offer. Which right now is this." He gestured at the room — the late hour, the easy company, the oven doing its work. "And I think that's worth something."
"That's a very elegant rationalization," Max said, "for not wanting to be vulnerable."
Martin looked at her. "You're not wrong."
Max seemed slightly surprised that he'd agreed. "Most people argue when I say that."
"Most people haven't thought about it enough to know you're right." He leaned back. "Doesn't change the conclusion, but you're not wrong."
Caroline, who had been studying the ceiling through this entire exchange, said: "Can we talk about something that isn't my love life or Martin's emotional unavailability?"
"The cupcake business," Martin said immediately.
Max pointed at him. "There you go. Now you're useful."
They talked about the cupcake business until the oven timer went off.
The cupcakes were, without exaggeration or politeness, extraordinary.
Martin had one, then a second, and then looked at the remaining ten on the cooling rack with the expression of someone revising their priorities.
"Max," he said.
"I know," she said.
"This is a real thing."
"I know."
"I mean — this is a business. This is genuinely a business."
"We're working on it," Caroline said, with the specific energy of someone who'd found a project that was helping her stay focused. "We need startup capital, a proper kitchen setup, some kind of—"
"Don't do anything legally until you talk to me," Martin said. "Business structure, contracts, any agreements — run it by me first. No charge."
Max looked at him. "Why?"
"Because I ate your cupcakes and I'd like to keep eating them. Self-interest, honestly."
"That's the first thing you've said tonight that I completely believe," Max said.
Martin boxed up the remaining cupcakes. Left fifty dollars on the counter that he knew Max would argue about in the morning. Shook Max's hand with the gravity of someone concluding a business meeting, which made her laugh — genuinely, surprised out of her — for the first time.
Hugged Caroline at the door in the easy way of two people who had settled into something honest and sustainable.
"You're going to be okay," he said.
"I know," she said. And for the first time since her father's arrest, she meant it.
The cupcakes were gone by the time Martin reached the office the next morning. Rachel had eaten one, which she'd described as genuinely impressive. Three associates from the thirty-eighth floor had materialized within minutes, which suggested the office had a cupcake detection system he hadn't previously been aware of.
Donna had taken two without asking and given him a look that said she'd done him a favor he'd understand later.
Five days later, Martin and Harvey were in a conference suite on the twentieth floor of the same Midtown hotel that had hosted the Mutual Aid dinner, conducting first-round interviews for the firm's new paralegal cohort.
Rachel sat at the exterior desk, organized and unhurried. Donna sat at the desk beside her, which in the firm's informal hierarchy was the equivalent of two generals sharing a command post — professionally courteous, each fully aware of the other's capabilities, each keeping one eye on what the other was doing.
The interviews were not going well.
Harvey had developed a specific expression for this — not quite contempt, not quite boredom, the face of a man watching something that fell short of what he knew was possible. He'd been wearing it since the fourth candidate.
"Harvard Law," Harvey said, after the seventh candidate left, "produces the finest legal education in the country. So why does it keep sending us people who think confidence is the same as competence?"
"Because confidence is easier to demonstrate in an interview than competence," Martin said, not looking up from the files. "You could also argue you're partially responsible. Your win record sets an expectation that attracts people who want to be associated with winning rather than people who want to do the work."
Harvey considered this. "That's probably true and I don't care."
"I know." Martin set down a file. "Next."
Donna picked up the next registration form. Started to stand.
The stairwell door at the far end of the corridor opened — not the elevator, the stairs — and a young man came through it at something between a walk and a jog, slightly disheveled, carrying a briefcase with the grip of someone who'd been running with it. He looked up, down the corridor, registered the interview table, and changed course.
He was mid-twenties, maybe. Clean-cut in a way that suggested the suit was a recent and deliberate decision. Smart eyes doing quick work on the room.
Also: breathing harder than a flight of stairs should produce.
Donna looked at the form. "Are you Mike?"
"Mike Ross, yes." He straightened his jacket, recovered himself. "I know I'm late — five minutes, I saw the sign-in sheet — and I completely understand if that's disqualifying, but if there's any room to—"
"What I want to know," Donna said, with the precision of a lawyer who'd absorbed a decade of Harvey's interview technique through proximity, "is why you're late and why you came up the stairs instead of the elevator."
Mike Ross glanced down the corridor. Then back.
"I was — there was a situation in the lobby. I needed to take the stairs."
Harvey's expression shifted from the boredom setting to something more alert. He looked at Martin.
Martin had already set down his pen and was looking at the corridor door with the specific attention of someone who'd heard something in an answer that warranted further examination.
Harvey made a small gesture to Donna.
"Mr. Specter will see you," Donna said.
Mike Ross looked mildly surprised. He picked up his briefcase, pushed through the suite door, and extended his hand to Harvey.
"Harvey Specter." Harvey shook it.
"Mike Ross." He turned. Registered Martin — slightly younger than expected, settled into his chair with the ease of someone entirely comfortable with the authority the room had allocated him. "And you are—"
"Get through Harvey's half first," Martin said pleasantly, "then we'll do introductions."
Mike accepted this with the slight recalibration of someone adjusting to a room that wasn't quite what they'd mapped.
He set his briefcase on the corner of the desk. Then, whether from nerves or momentum or the particular physics of a latch that had been through a lot that morning, the briefcase tipped.
The latch gave.
Several clear plastic bags hit the floor.
The room processed this in approximately two seconds of complete silence.
Harvey looked at the bags. Looked at Mike Ross. His expression had moved somewhere entirely new — not anger, not amusement exactly, but the particular alertness of someone who'd just been surprised, which didn't happen to Harvey Specter often enough for him to have a routine response to it.
Mike Ross looked at the bags, at Harvey, at Martin, and back at Harvey, with the expression of a man watching the last available exit close.
Martin let out a slow breath through his nose. Then, almost against his will, a quiet laugh.
Harvey looked at him.
"The plot of Suits," Martin said, under his breath, to no one in particular.
Harvey raised an eyebrow.
"Sorry," Martin said. "Private thought." He looked at Mike Ross with genuine interest. "Pick those up. Then sit down." He leaned forward slightly. "And then tell us why someone with what I'm guessing is a near-perfect memory and zero law degree is interviewing at the best firm in New York."
Mike Ross looked at him for a long moment.
"How did you—"
"The briefcase thing told me you're nervous, which means you care about this. The stairs told me you're quick on your feet. The fact that you walked into the room anyway told me you calculate risk in real time and you're comfortable betting on yourself." Martin tilted his head. "The rest is inference." He paused. "Sit down, Mike."
Harvey was looking at Martin now with the specific expression he reserved for things he was quietly filing away.
Mike Ross sat down.
Outside in the corridor, Rachel and Donna exchanged the briefest of glances over their respective desks — the kind of glance that contained a complete conversation.
Then they both went back to work.
The game, Martin thought, settling back into his chair, has just gotten considerably more interesting.
[500 PS unlocks 1 Extra Chapter]
[10 Reviews unlock 1 Extra Chapter]
Thanks for reading—reviews are appreciated.
P1treon Soulforger has 20+advance chapters