Chapter 18 — Unexpected Gains
Martin left the office at five-thirty, which at Pearson Hardman felt approximately like leaving at noon.
He'd spent the last two days inside vehicle homicide case law — every precedent he could pull involving cars used as weapons, every angle the defense bar had tried in the last twenty years, every theory that had landed and every one that hadn't. The common law tradition meant that each new case was built on the accumulated weight of everything that came before it, which was either a feature or a liability depending on whether the precedents were working for you.
Right now, they weren't working for him.
He got back to the apartment expecting quiet and found instead that Mary Cooper had already left — departed at noon, Leonard told him, back to Texas.
Sheldon had his job back.
And there had apparently been a development between Mary and the new department chair, Dr. Weinstein, which Leonard conveyed with the expression of someone trying to report a situation factually while simultaneously processing his own feelings about it.
Sheldon was sitting on his spot with the particular expression of someone who had received good news and complicated news simultaneously and hadn't fully resolved which one was louder.
"Are you okay?" Martin said.
"I retained my position," Sheldon said. "The work continues. The situation is otherwise..." He paused. "Sub-optimal in ways I choose not to enumerate."
"Fair enough." Martin set down his briefcase. "I'm glad you kept the job."
Sheldon looked at him. "Thank you for coming to the meeting."
From Sheldon, unprompted, this was significant.
"Of course," Martin said, and left it at that.
The next morning at the office, Martin was back in the Amanda Somme file with fresh eyes that produced the same wall he'd been hitting for a week.
He closed the folder. Pressed the intercom.
"Rachel. Ice water, please."
"Ice water," Rachel confirmed. "And it's payday. Check your account and let me know if the numbers are wrong before I leave for the day."
Martin opened his browser.
Citibank. Account number, password, security question. The balance loaded.
He looked at it.
Seventy-two thousand, six hundred and fifty-two dollars and eighty cents.
In his previous life, his annual salary had been forty-three thousand dollars and he'd considered himself solidly comfortable. His first month at Pearson Hardman, after taxes and the firm's standard deductions, had produced seventy-two thousand dollars.
He allowed himself exactly ten seconds to feel good about this.
Rachel came in with the ice water, set it on his desk, and looked at his expression.
"Good numbers?" she said.
"Good numbers." He drank half the glass. "What did you do with your first real paycheck? Not bills — after the bills."
Rachel sat down across from him with the expression of someone deciding whether to answer honestly. "After rent, utilities, student loans, and my phone plan?" She tilted her head. "I bought one pair of shoes that cost more than was strictly sensible and then felt guilty about it for three weeks."
"Were they good shoes?"
"Exceptional shoes."
"No regrets then." Martin leaned back. "I'm taking you to dinner tonight. You pick — somewhere worth the occasion, not somewhere reimburse-able."
Rachel raised an eyebrow. "Occasion being?"
"First real paycheck. Yours was months ago and I missed it. Consider this retroactive." He paused. "Also I need to buy a car first."
"Again?"
"The Camaro is a collector's piece and I should treat it like one. I need something I can actually drive to work without arriving with forearm cramps."
Rachel was already reaching for her jacket. "Please not another Red Hook garage situation."
"Proper dealership this time. Manhattan."
"And you need me there because—"
"Because the last time I bought a car without a second opinion I ended up with a vehicle that requires a spotter."
Rachel stood, smoothed her blazer, and looked at him with the expression she'd developed for moments when her job description expanded in directions she hadn't anticipated but had stopped being surprised by.
"Let me tell Priya what she's managing this afternoon," she said. "Then we go."
The dealership was on the West Side, one of those comprehensive luxury operations that occupied most of a city block and treated the showroom floor like a gallery. The inventory ran from serious-money-but-attainable — BMW, Mercedes, Audi — up through the genuine occasion-purchase tier: Ferrari, Porsche, Lamborghini, all lit with the specific reverence of objects that had been designed to make people want to spend money they'd been saving.
Martin and Rachel walked the floor with the different orientations of two people whose aesthetics had been formed by different priorities.
Rachel drifted toward the Ferrari section and stood in front of a Californian in rosso corsa with the expression of someone appreciating something beautiful without particularly wanting to own it.
"The lines are extraordinary," she said.
"They are," Martin agreed. "Also everyone who drives one is announcing something about themselves that I don't necessarily want to announce."
Rachel looked at him. "Which is?"
"Look at me." He moved past the Ferrari toward the BMW section. "I need a car that says I take this meeting seriously without saying anything else."
"What about the Porsche?"
"Possibly." He stopped in front of a BMW M2 Competition in black. Looked at it the way he'd looked at the Camaro — not with the performance of appreciation but with genuine consideration. "The M2 is the car that BMW pretends is a normal car while engineers cry into their coffee making sure it isn't. Four-hundred and five horsepower, rear-wheel drive, manual or DCT—"
"You're doing the thing again," Rachel said.
"What thing."
"The thing where you know significantly more about a subject than you're letting on and it comes out anyway."
"I read a lot," Martin said, which was true in a complicated way he chose not to elaborate on.
He sat in the M2. Felt the seat. Gripped the wheel. The ergonomics were precise in the way of something engineered rather than styled.
Rachel was looking at a Porsche 911 two cars over. Cayman blue, which was a color that managed to be distinctive without being loud — the automotive equivalent of a good suit.
"This one," she said.
Martin got out of the BMW and came over.
The 911 was in the configuration he'd have chosen anyway — Carrera S, the mid-tier that was genuinely fast rather than performatively fast, with the PDK transmission that meant he wouldn't be doing the half-clutch ballet in Midtown traffic.
He sat in it.
"This is the right car," he said.
"I know," Rachel said. "It says exactly what you need it to say and nothing it shouldn't."
"I've been told there are people who think the 911 isn't prestigious enough."
"Those people have never driven one or have too much money and not enough taste," Rachel said. "The 911 is what people who actually understand cars drive. The clients you want will know that."
Martin looked at her. "I'm going to say something complimentary now."
"I'll prepare myself."
"You would make an excellent attorney."
Rachel's expression did the thing it did when this subject came up — a brief passage through something that was neither simple pride nor simple pain, and then the professional composure back in place. "I know," she said, and meant it in the way that people mean things they've made their peace with.
"The LSAT," Martin said.
"Martin—"
"I'm not pushing. I'm saying that when you're ready, I'll work with you on it. The anxiety component is addressable. It's a known preparation problem with a known preparation solution." He held her gaze for a moment. "That's all."
Rachel looked at the 911 for a moment. Then: "The blue."
"The blue," Martin confirmed.
He went to find the salesperson.
While Rachel handled the paperwork with the F&I manager — with the focused efficiency of someone who had processed enough legal contracts to make a car purchase feel routine — Martin walked the floor, not looking at anything in particular, letting his brain do the unfocused movement that sometimes produced useful ideas.
He passed through the BMW section again.
The salesperson nearby was walking a couple through a 2007 X5. Mid-forties, well-dressed, the particular dynamic of two people making a considered purchase together. The salesperson was explaining the interior features — the navigation system, the panoramic roof, the gear selector.
"—BMW's new electronic gear shift control, launched last year. The X5 was the first model in the lineup to use it. Different from the traditional gate-style automatic—"
Martin slowed.
"—push toward you for reverse, push away for drive. Some customers find the logic takes a little getting used to compared to conventional automatics, but once you adjust—"
He stopped.
"Different from conventional automatics."
"Push toward you for reverse, push away for drive."
He stood in the middle of the BMW showroom floor and did the thing that occasionally happened when pieces of a problem that had been sitting in separate parts of his mind suddenly found each other — the quiet internal click of something connecting.
Amanda Somme had bought her X5 four months before the incident.
Four months.
In her account of what happened in the parking lot, she'd said she got in the car and drove forward. Into Sorkya, who was standing in front of the vehicle.
She'd said she was trying to leave.
But what if she thought she was putting it in reverse?
Martin's hand moved to his chin. His eyes went somewhere inward.
The BMW X5's electronic gear selector — launched the previous year, first deployment in the X5, different operational logic from every automatic transmission most drivers had ever used. Push one direction for reverse, push the other for drive. Counterintuitive to anyone trained on a conventional gate selector, where the physical position of the lever told you exactly what gear you were in.
Four months of ownership. An argument. High emotional state. Muscle memory reaching for the escape route and activating a gear selector that didn't work the way every previous car she'd ever driven had worked.
He turned around and walked back toward the F&I office at a pace that made two different salespeople step aside instinctively.
Rachel was signing the final delivery paperwork. She looked up at his expression.
"You found something," she said.
"The gear selector," Martin said. "The BMW X5 uses an electronic gear shift system that launched the previous year. Different control logic from conventional automatics. If you're used to a regular automatic, under stress, you could push it the wrong direction and not realize it immediately."
Rachel set down her pen. Her expression moved through the same rapid calculation he'd just done. "She thought she was backing up."
"She thought she was backing up," Martin confirmed. "Which means the question isn't whether she intended to hit him. The question is whether she knew which gear she was in."
Rachel looked at the salesperson. "Can we have a minute?"
The salesperson read the room and stepped out.
"You need the vehicle's data recorder," Rachel said immediately. "The X5 has an onboard event data recorder — it logs gear position, throttle, speed, and braking in the seconds before and after a significant impact. If the EDR shows the transmission was in drive while the control was pushed in the reverse direction—"
"That's a manufacturing documentation problem and a driver confusion defense." Martin was already pulling out his phone. "I need Priya on this right now."
He dialed.
Priya picked up on the second ring.
"The Amanda Somme file," Martin said, without preamble. "Pull everything on the BMW X5's 2007 electronic gear shift system — NHTSA complaints, manufacturer documentation, owner manuals, any reported incidents of operator confusion. And I need to know the procedure for subpoenaing the vehicle's EDR data — the car was impounded as evidence, which means the data should still be accessible."
A brief pause. "The event data recorder."
"If the EDR shows the transmission in drive when Amanda's spatial memory told her she was in reverse, we have a different case than what the prosecution is building."
Another brief pause, shorter this time.
"I'll have it on your phone in an hour," Priya said.
Martin hung up.
Rachel was looking at him with the expression that had been developing over the past month — not surprise exactly, more like confirmed expectation.
"Not a standard procedure crime after all," she said.
"Might not be." Martin pocketed his phone. He glanced at the BMW X5 on the showroom floor. "I'm going to need a few minutes with that car before we leave."
The salesperson reappeared in the doorway with the careful energy of someone re-entering a situation they didn't fully understand. Martin looked at him.
"The BMW X5 with the electronic gear selector," Martin said. "I'd like to sit in it. Specifically I want to operate the gear shift with my eyes closed."
The salesperson looked at Rachel.
Rachel handed him the signed paperwork with a smile. "The Porsche is paid for. He just needs five minutes with the X5."
The salesperson decided not to ask further questions.
Martin sat in the X5, closed his eyes, and reached for the gear selector.
Push away: drive.
Push toward: reverse.
He did it three times with his eyes open, then three times with his eyes closed. The third time, his hand moved in the direction that every automatic transmission he'd ever operated in his life would have put him in reverse.
It put him in drive.
"There it is," he said quietly, to no one in particular.
Outside, through the dealership's glass frontage, Manhattan was doing what Manhattan always did — moving, producing, demanding attention. The blue Porsche was being brought around from the back lot by a lot attendant.
Martin got out of the BMW, straightened his jacket, and walked toward the front door.
"Dinner," Rachel said, falling into step beside him.
"Dinner," Martin agreed. "You pick. Somewhere that doesn't know anything about gear selectors."
"That's a surprisingly high bar in this city," Rachel said.
Martin pushed the door open and held it.
Behind them, in the showroom, the BMW X5 sat under the gallery lighting, its gear selector exactly where it had always been, exactly as counterintuitive as it had always been, waiting for someone to notice.
Someone finally had.
[Milestone: 500 Power Stones = +1 Chapter]
[Milestone: 10 Reviews = +1 Chapter]
Enjoyed this chapter? Leave a review.
20+advanced chapters on P1treon Soulforger