Chapter 6: THE CAVES
The water ran out on the third morning.
Boone stood guard over the remaining supply—four bottles, maybe enough for twenty people if everyone took a single swallow. The rest of the camp clustered nearby, desperation sharpening tempers into weapons.
"We need to ration better," Jack announced. "Until we find a freshwater source—"
"There's no freshwater source," someone shouted. "We're on an island. It's all salt."
"Islands have rivers, springs—"
"You've found some?"
Jack's silence was answer enough. He'd searched the immediate area, found nothing, and now faced forty-odd people who'd learned the hard way that medical expertise didn't translate to wilderness survival.
I watched the argument from the edge of the crowd. Two days since the Marshal's death. Two days of tension and heat and the slow realization that rescue wasn't coming on any convenient schedule.
The caves existed half a mile inland. I'd known their location since the transmigration—a detail from an early episode, barely mentioned, casually important. Fresh water, natural shelter, the bones of two ancient beings sleeping in the dark.
Make it look natural. Stumble across it. Play the fool who got lucky.
"I'll go." I stepped forward, drawing attention. "Inland search. Two volunteers."
Jack's eyebrows rose. "You're volunteering?"
"I'm thirsty."
Kate moved to my side without hesitation. Jack followed after a moment's consideration—he couldn't let me lead alone, not with his fragile grip on camp authority. Three people, different skill sets, reasonable odds of finding something useful.
We gathered supplies and headed for the tree line.
---
The jungle swallowed us within minutes.
Sound changed under the canopy—bird calls muffled, insect drone amplified, the crunch of vegetation underfoot uncomfortably loud. We moved in silence, Jack leading despite my offer to take point. His pride demanded it, and arguing would only waste time.
I steered us with small suggestions. "That way looks clearer." "I heard water over there." "Let's try the ridge."
Twenty minutes of subtle maneuvering, and we emerged at the cave mouth.
Jack stopped dead. "My God."
Water cascaded from a rock formation twenty feet overhead, pooling in a basin before flowing deeper into the cave system. The air was cool, damp, fragrant with mineral deposits and ancient stone. Sunlight filtered through gaps in the canopy, illuminating the interior in shades of green and gold.
"Fresh water." Kate knelt at the pool, scooped a handful, drank. Her face transformed with relief. "It's fresh. It's actually fresh."
Jack was already calculating. "We could move the camp here. Shelter, water, protection from the elements—"
"Some people won't want to leave the beach," I said. "They'll want to stay where rescue can spot them."
"Then they can make that choice. But anyone who wants to survive long-term..." He trailed off, staring into the cave's depths.
I followed his gaze. Already knew what he'd find.
The skeletons lay in a natural alcove thirty feet inside—two bodies, perfectly preserved by the cave's dry conditions, positioned side by side like sleeping lovers. Jack approached them with the cautious reverence of a man who'd seen death in clinical settings but never like this.
"How long have they been here?"
"A while," I said. Two thousand years, give or take.
"What happened to them?"
"No idea." He killed their mother. She killed his village. He threw his brother into the heart of the island and created the smoke monster. Standard family drama.
Kate examined the remains without touching them. "There's something poetic about it. Dying together. Not alone."
"Adam and Eve," Jack murmured. "That's what we should call them."
The name stuck, as I knew it would. Some things wanted to be discovered exactly as they'd been named.
I drank from the cave pool while Jack and Kate explored. The water tasted clean, cold, alive with minerals I couldn't identify. My body—Sawyer's body—responded to the hydration with something approaching gratitude. Muscles loosened. Headache receded. The constant low-grade exhaustion of dehydration lifted like fog.
Small pleasures. Remember the small pleasures.
It was the first moment since transmigration that I'd genuinely enjoyed something. Not observed it, not catalogued it, not performed an appropriate reaction—actually experienced pleasure in the present moment. Fresh water in a cave on a mysterious island, and I was alive to drink it.
The absurdity almost made me laugh.
---
Footsteps announced our visitor before he emerged from the trees.
John Locke walked into the clearing with a boar over his shoulders, carrying the dead weight like it was nothing. His clothes were stained with blood and jungle mud. His smile held the serene confidence of a man who'd found exactly what he was looking for.
"Fresh water," he observed. "Good find."
Jack straightened, immediately suspicious. "Where did you get that?"
"Hunted it." Locke set the boar down with practiced ease. "Tracked it for six hours, cornered it near a ravine, killed it with a knife. The island provides."
The island provides. The phrase carried weight Locke didn't fully understand yet. He thought he was speaking metaphorically, but the man in the wheelchair who'd walked onto this beach knew better. Something had happened to him. Something miraculous.
And that miracle will destroy him. His faith in the island's purpose, twisted into obsession, manipulated by forces he can't comprehend.
"There's enough here for everyone," Kate said. "Water and meat. We could actually survive."
"We can do more than survive." Locke's eyes found mine, held them. "We can understand."
Jack interrupted before the moment could deepen. "We need to organize transport. Get this water back to camp, move people who want to come—"
"I'll stay," I said. "Guard the cave."
"You don't want to help with—"
"Someone should watch the supplies. Make sure nothing wanders in." I gestured at Locke's boar. "Apparently, this jungle's got more wildlife than polar bears."
Jack considered it, nodded. He and Kate departed with filled containers, already planning logistics.
Locke stayed.
---
The hunter sat across from me at the cave mouth, the boar between us like an offering on an altar. Neither of us spoke for a long time. The waterfall provided ambient sound, filling silence that might have been uncomfortable.
"You know something about them."
I didn't pretend to misunderstand. Locke's gaze had drifted toward the skeletons, toward the ancient mystery sleeping in the dark.
"I know they died together."
"That's not what I mean." He leaned forward, elbows on knees. "You walked into this cave like you expected to find it. You looked at those bones like you were greeting old friends."
Careful. He's perceptive. More perceptive than anyone on this island.
"Maybe I've got good instincts."
"Maybe." Locke smiled, and the expression held depths I couldn't read. "Or maybe you know things about this place that the rest of us are still learning."
"And if I did?"
"Then I'd want to learn them too."
The sincerity in his voice was almost painful. John Locke, the man of faith, searching for meaning in a universe that had kicked him repeatedly. His wheelchair. His father. His entire tragic arc, laid out in episodes I'd watched with popcorn and judgment.
He wants to believe in something. And you could give him that belief—or use it against him.
"Let me ask you something." I stood, walked to the cave entrance, looked out at the jungle's endless green. "Four days ago, you were on a plane. Now you're hunting boar with a knife. How does that feel?"
"Like I'm finally where I'm supposed to be."
"And the wheelchair?"
Locke's expression flickered. "How do you know about—"
"You were in the aisle. I saw the airline staff help you board." The lie came easily. "Whatever happened when you landed, it changed things."
"The island healed me."
"Maybe." I turned to face him. "Or maybe you healed yourself. Maybe the crash, the trauma, the adrenaline—maybe your body did something your mind couldn't achieve on its own."
"You don't believe that."
"I don't know what I believe." True, mostly. "But I know this island is strange. I know it does things that shouldn't be possible. And I know that people who go looking for answers here tend to find more than they bargained for."
Locke studied me for a long moment. I could see the wheels turning—his instinct to evangelize fighting his curiosity about what I might know.
"You're not what you pretend to be," he said finally.
"Neither are you."
We stared at each other across the cave mouth. Two men with secrets, two men with faith in different things, two men whose paths would intersect and diverge in ways neither could predict.
"The boar needs butchering," Locke said. "Help me, and I'll teach you to track."
I almost refused. Sawyer the con man didn't learn survival skills from aging mystics. But Sawyer the con man also wouldn't have volunteered for a water search or given away the Marshal's gun.
The mask is slipping. Better to control the slip than let it happen randomly.
"Why not."
We worked in silence, cutting meat from bone, wrapping portions in leaves for transport. The labor was meditative, grounding. Blood and muscle and the honest work of survival.
When we finished, Locke cleaned his knife on a patch of grass and looked up at me with that serene smile.
"This island has a way of revealing who people really are. The man you were before the crash—that man is already dying. The man you become..." He shrugged. "That's up to you."
Kate and Jack returned before I could respond.
The camp split that night—some moving to the caves, others staying on the beach for rescue that might never come. I chose the caves, claiming a corner near the waterfall where the sound masked footsteps.
Sleep came eventually. My dreams were full of smoke and screaming, of a woman's voice iterating in French, of two ancient bodies lying in the dark, waiting to be found.
Tomorrow would bring new problems. The Others were watching. Ethan was coming. The transceiver would need repairs, and Sayid would try his triangulation trick.
But tonight, I had fresh water and shelter and the first tentative understanding with a man whose faith might save or damn us all.
That would have to be enough.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.