Chapter 2: THE MASK
Charlie Pace hovered too close.
"You alright, mate? You've been standing there for ages. Staring at nothing."
I turned. The musician looked worse than his mugshot—pupils blown, skin waxy, that junkie tremor in his fingers. He'd be jonesing for a fix within twelve hours, if he wasn't already. Heroic arc or not, Charlie Pace was a liability wrapped in optimism.
"Fine." The word came out sharper than intended. Wrong accent. I softened it, found the drawl hiding in Sawyer's throat. "Just fine, Mick Jagger. Why don't you go tune your guitar somewhere else?"
Charlie blinked. Hurt flickered across his face before he masked it with defensive pride. "I was just trying to—"
"Yeah, well, don't."
He retreated. I let him go.
That's it. That's the voice. Hostile, deflecting, alone by choice.
Sawyer's personality lived in this body like muscle memory. The sarcasm bubbled up naturally. The drawl smoothed over genuine emotion. The distance between self and others felt comfortable, familiar, like sliding into a well-worn groove.
The mask fit better than it should have.
Hurley approached next, moving with the careful momentum of someone who'd learned that big bodies attracted attention. He held out a candy bar—Milky Way, wrapper half-crushed.
"Dude, you should eat something. Blood sugar, you know?"
I almost refused. My stomach was still churning from the crash, from the impossibility, from the wet sound the turbine had made before exploding. But Sawyer would take it. Sawyer would take anything offered without a thank-you, because gratitude implied debt, and debt was leverage.
"Much obliged, Stay-Puft."
Hurley's face did something complicated—half offended, half amused. "Did you just call me—"
"Got somewhere to be?"
He didn't. Nobody did. They just circled each other in the firelight, strangers thrown together by disaster, trying to figure out who could be trusted.
I tore open the candy bar and ate it in three bites. The sweetness hit my empty stomach like a fist.
---
Kate found me an hour later.
She moved through the camp like a ghost—quiet, watchful, cataloging everyone's weaknesses without seeming to. The fugitive instincts were already running hot. I caught her checking escape routes, noting who had weapons, positioning herself near the tree line for a quick exit.
Smart woman. Dangerous woman.
"We should organize the supplies," she said. No preamble. Just tactical reality. "People are grabbing whatever they can find. If we don't centralize things, someone's going to start a fight over a blanket."
"Someone's gonna start a fight regardless." I leaned against a piece of wing debris, arms crossed. "Might as well let natural selection take its course."
Her eyes narrowed. Freckles. Green irises. That calculating sharpness that the show's camera had never quite captured. On television, Kate Austen was beautiful and mysterious. In person, she was something else entirely—a coiled spring of competence and paranoia, always five seconds from violence or flight.
"You could help," she said. "Or you could keep being useless."
"Useless works for me, Freckles."
The nickname landed. I watched her file it away—another data point, another piece of the Sawyer puzzle. She didn't know yet that he'd spent years perfecting the asshole persona. She didn't know about the parents or the con man or the letter he carried everywhere.
She would learn. Everyone would learn. That was the problem with knowledge—it flowed both ways.
"Fine." Kate turned to leave. "Just stay out of the way."
"I'll try to contain myself."
She walked off. I exhaled slowly.
That's one conversation down. Only about six hundred to go.
---
The Monster returned at midnight.
I heard it coming before the first scream—that grinding, mechanical howl echoing through the jungle. The trees swayed like dancers in a hurricane. Birds exploded from the canopy in black clouds. And forty-seven survivors woke from fitful sleep to confront their first collective nightmare.
Panic spread faster than fire.
People ran. Tripped. Collided with each other in the dark. Someone knocked over a pile of salvaged luggage, scattering possessions across the sand. A woman sobbed into her hands. A man tried to build a barricade from airplane seats.
Jack Shephard stood at the camp's edge, staring into the darkness, hands clenched at his sides. He wanted to fight it. I could see the impulse written across his shoulders. The good doctor needed to fix things, and this was something he couldn't fix.
"What the hell is that?" Charlie's voice cracked on the question. He'd positioned himself near Claire, unconsciously protective, already falling into the role the show had written for him.
"Don't know." I hadn't moved from my spot near the wing debris. "Don't care. It's not coming here."
Hurley's head whipped toward me. "How do you know that?"
Because I've seen this episode.
"Just a feeling."
The Monster roared again—closer now, or maybe just louder. The ground shook. Palm fronds rained down like confetti. Someone started praying in a language I didn't recognize.
I watched the tree line and waited.
The sound peaked. Held. Then slowly, impossibly, began to fade. Whatever the Monster had been doing—hunting, patrolling, sending a message—it was finished. The mechanical thunder retreated into distance, taking the chaos with it.
Survivors collapsed where they stood. Some cried. Some laughed. Most just stared at each other with the hollow eyes of people who'd realized their world had changed forever.
Jack turned to me. His gaze was suspicious, measuring, full of questions he couldn't yet articulate. "You didn't react."
"Should I have?"
"Everyone else did."
"Everyone else hasn't survived much."
It was a dangerous line to walk—revealing Sawyer's competence before he'd earned it. But the alternative was faking panic, and I couldn't sell that. Not with the Monster's timeline running exactly to schedule. Not with the pilot's death ticking closer by the hour.
"We need to get the transceiver," Jack said. "From the cockpit."
"I know."
"In the morning. First light." He studied my face. "You're coming."
It wasn't a question. The good doctor had decided I was useful, and useful people got drafted into danger.
"Wouldn't miss it," I said.
Kate appeared at Jack's shoulder. Charlie lingered nearby, trying to look brave. The pilot rescue team was forming, and I was part of it.
First test. Can I change a death?
Tomorrow, I'd find out.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.