The council chamber was empty except for Thranduil.
No advisors. No guards. No witnesses to whatever was about to happen.
The King stood before the great windows, his silhouette framed by afternoon light that seemed too bright for the darkness gathering in the room. He didn't turn as Legolas entered. Didn't acknowledge the doors closing behind his son.
"You sent her."
The words fell like stones into still water. Legolas had prepared denials, excuses, carefully crafted explanations that might soften the blow.
He abandoned all of them.
"Yes."
Thranduil turned slowly. His face held an expression Legolas hadn't seen before—something that went beyond anger, beyond suspicion, into a territory that might have been grief.
"You undermined my authority. You released a captain from her duties without consultation. You let the Dwarves escape without raising alarm." Each accusation landed with precise weight. "Do you deny any of this?"
"No."
The single word hung in the air. Legolas felt his hands trembling slightly—not from Legolas's old fear, which had faded over months of confrontation, but from the weight of what he was about to destroy.
"I chose what was right," he continued. "The Dwarves' quest matters beyond what we can see from these halls. Tauriel needed to witness it. I made the decision that would serve our realm's future, not its pride."
Thranduil's composure cracked.
"Who are you?"
The question tore through the chamber with a force that seemed physical. The Elvenking crossed the space between them in three swift strides, stopping close enough that Legolas could see the ancient pain behind his father's eyes.
"The Legolas I raised would never defy me openly. Would never send warriors into danger on his own authority. Would never look at me with..." He gestured at Legolas's face. "With this. This certainty. This distance."
"Perhaps the son you raised could not do what must be done," Legolas said quietly. "Perhaps that is why you are failing."
Silence.
Thranduil's face cycled through emotions too fast to track—rage, shock, something that might have been recognition. His hand rose as if to strike, then fell without completing the motion.
"I have watched you for months," the King said finally. "Since you emerged from those shadow-dreams with light in your hands and secrets in your eyes. I have seen you change our forest, change our captain, change the way our people whisper when you pass. I have wondered if you were enchanted, possessed, corrupted by some subtle darkness."
He stepped back, putting distance between them.
"But this is worse than corruption. You are lucid. You are deliberate. You know exactly what you are doing, and you are doing it anyway." His voice dropped. "What ARE you?"
The question deserved an answer Legolas couldn't give. He was a transmigrator from another world. A dead software developer wearing an Elvish prince like borrowed clothing. A soul that existed outside the Music, carrying knowledge that no one in Middle-earth should possess.
"I am what Mirkwood needs," Legolas said instead. "I am what this forest has required for centuries—someone willing to act rather than wait. Someone who sees the darkness growing and refuses to simply watch it spread."
"That is not an answer."
"It is the only answer I can give."
They stood facing each other, father and son, king and prince, ancient grief meeting impossible truth. The air between them crackled with words unspoken and accusations that couldn't be withdrawn.
"You will continue your cleansing," Thranduil said at last. His voice had gone flat, controlled—the tone of a monarch issuing orders rather than a father speaking to his child. "The work serves the realm, whatever your reasons for doing it. You will NOT interfere further in the Dwarves' matter. You will not send warriors where I have not authorized them. And when this is over—when the mountain has fallen silent and the eastern chaos has resolved—we will discuss what you have become."
Dismissal. Clear and cold.
Legolas bowed—the formal gesture of a subject acknowledging a command. He turned toward the doors, each step carrying him further from the relationship that had defined this body's existence for three thousand years.
"Legolas."
He stopped, not turning back.
"Whatever you are... I remember the child you were. The elfling who laughed in these halls before the shadow came. The prince who loved his people and his forest and his father, even when that love was difficult to express." A pause, weighted with centuries. "I hope that child still exists somewhere within you. I hope he is not entirely lost."
Legolas closed his eyes. For a moment, memories that weren't his flooded through—Legolas's memories, the original consciousness that had shaped this body and this life. Childhood in Mirkwood's golden age. Training with warriors who were now legends. The first time he'd seen his father weep, after a battle that had cost them dearly.
I'm not him, Legolas thought. I can never be him. But I can try to honor what he was.
"He is not lost," Legolas said without turning. "He has simply grown into someone who can do what must be done."
He walked through the doors before Thranduil could respond.
The corridor stretched before him, empty and echoing. Servants had cleared the area—perhaps sensing that privacy was required for whatever had happened in the council chamber. Legolas walked without direction, his feet carrying him toward no particular destination.
His hands were shaking.
Not from Legolas's inherited fear—that ancient terror of his father's displeasure had faded months ago, replaced by something more complex. This trembling came from his own realization, his own grief.
He had just lost his father.
The relationship wasn't dead—Thranduil would still command, Legolas would still obey where it mattered—but the familial bond that had connected them was severed. The King no longer saw a son when he looked at his prince. He saw a stranger. A mystery. A potential threat wearing familiar features.
This is what change costs, Legolas thought. Not just power and knowledge, but the connections that made this life worth living.
He found himself in the corrupted zone before he realized where his feet were taking him. The twisted trees felt honest in a way the palace didn't—they didn't pretend to be anything other than what the darkness had made them.
Legolas sank to his knees in the poisoned soil, surrounded by shadows that had tried to tempt him weeks ago.
You are unwritten, the darkness had whispered then. You are outside the pattern. You could learn such things...
He'd fled from that temptation. But tonight, the shadows didn't speak. They simply waited, patient and eternal, while an impossible prince grieved for a relationship he'd destroyed.
The Ring-craft knowledge sat in his mind like a splinter. The Valar's attention pressed down from above. The court's suspicion circled like vultures. And somewhere in the east, Tauriel was running toward a future that would break her heart.
Months will pass, Legolas thought. A dragon will die. The world will shift. And I will still be here, carrying knowledge I never asked for, mourning connections I cannot repair.
He rose to his feet, brushing corrupted soil from his knees. The forest stretched around him, damaged but not defeated. His cleansing had made a difference—scattered glades where light touched clean earth, patches of recovery in the endless dark.
Small progress, he thought. But progress.
He walked deeper into the corruption, letting the twisted trees swallow him. The palace could wait. The court's whispers could continue without him. Tonight, honesty served better than comfort.
The Shadow's presence pulsed at the edge of his awareness—the network of Morgul-sorcery that connected Dol Guldur to every infected tree in Mirkwood. It knew he was here. It always knew.
But tonight, it didn't attack. Didn't whisper. Simply watched, as if curious about what the strange prince would do next.
Legolas found a clearing where corruption had begun to heal—one of his earlier cleansing sites, slowly recovering. He sat in the center of the recovering ground and looked up at stars that Varda had kindled before the world was young.
I don't belong here, he thought. I never will. But I'm here anyway, and there's work to be done.
The Ring-craft archives couldn't be forgotten. The father-son bond couldn't be repaired. The court's suspicion couldn't be silenced.
But the forest could be healed. The timeline could be protected. The War that was coming could be won.
That has to be enough, Legolas told himself. That has to be worth what I've lost.
Somewhere beyond the eastern borders, Thorin's company raced toward a mountain with a dragon. Somewhere in the south, Sauron rebuilt his power while the White Council debated. Somewhere in the Shire, a hobbit named Bilbo carried a ring that would one day determine Middle-earth's fate.
And in a corrupted forest, an impossible prince sat beneath Varda's stars and made peace with what he'd become.
The months ahead would bring fire and death. The Battle of Five Armies would reshape the north. Thorin would fall, and Fíli and Kíli with him. Tauriel would watch Kíli die and carry that grief forever.
But tonight, the stars were beautiful. The air was clear. And the corrupted ground beneath him held the faint promise of recovery.
Sixty years, Legolas thought. Sixty years until the Ring surfaces and the real war begins. I'll be ready.
He rose to his feet and walked back toward the palace. There was work to be done.
Note:
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.