The Grey Pilgrim came through Mirkwood's eastern borders at midday, his staff clicking against stones that had lain undisturbed for decades.
Legolas intercepted him three miles from the palace gates—close enough that other patrols would have noticed soon, far enough that they could speak without witnesses. He'd felt Gandalf's approach through senses that had sharpened over sixty years of practice, the wizard's presence registering as a warm current in the spiritual landscape.
"Mithrandir." Legolas dropped from the trees to land in the wizard's path. "We did not expect you."
Gandalf stopped, leaning on his staff with the weary patience of someone who'd traveled far and fast. His grey robes were road-worn, his beard tangled with the debris of hasty travel. But his eyes—sharp and ancient and far too perceptive—fixed on Legolas with immediate intensity.
"Legolas Greenleaf," he said slowly. "You are... not what I expected."
The words carried weight that went beyond greeting. Legolas felt the wizard's attention probing at his edges, searching for something his normal senses couldn't quite define.
"I have changed since we last met." The response was careful, measured. Gandalf had visited Mirkwood occasionally over the decades, but their interactions had been brief—the wizard focused on larger concerns, the prince busy with cleansing work that kept him away from court.
"Changed." Gandalf's tone suggested the word was inadequate. "Radagast mentioned an 'unwritten' presence in these woods. A soul with no thread in the Music he knew. I thought him confused by his birds and beasts." A pause. "I see now he was entirely accurate."
Radagast remembered. The brown wizard's observation from sixty years ago—barely a moment in Istari time—had stayed with him. And now Gandalf had come seeking confirmation.
"You've traveled far to discuss my nature, Mithrandir."
"I've traveled far to discuss Gollum." Gandalf's eyes didn't waver. "The creature was held here briefly before his escape. I need to know what he revealed during his captivity. But now that I stand before you, I find myself curious about other mysteries."
Gollum. The timeline clicked into place. Gandalf was gathering evidence, confirming that Bilbo's ring was THE Ring. The interrogation of Gollum was part of that process—learning how the creature had acquired the Ring, understanding its history.
"I can tell you what Gollum said," Legolas offered. "But that is not what you truly wish to know."
"No." Gandalf stepped closer, close enough that his presence pressed against Legolas's spiritual awareness like a warm hand. "I wish to know what you are. How you came to carry light that should not exist. Why the forest around you has healed in ways that defied Elvish efforts for centuries."
The questions were direct. More direct than Legolas had expected from a wizard known for speaking in riddles.
"I am what opposes the Shadow," Legolas said. The phrase had served him before—with Radagast, with the Valar's attention, with his own questioning conscience. "Is that not what you seek, Mithrandir? Allies against the darkness?"
"That depends on HOW you oppose it." Gandalf's voice hardened. "The Shadow can be fought with light—or with deeper shadow. Saruman speaks of understanding the Enemy's tools to turn them against him. I have watched that philosophy lead wise minds toward corruption."
He suspects I've been touched by dark magic. The concern was reasonable. Legolas's Morgul-awareness, his understanding of the corruption's structure, his knowledge of Ring-craft—all of it could suggest someone who'd ventured too far into enemy territory.
"I have studied the Enemy's methods," Legolas admitted. "I understand how the corruption spreads through our forest. I know the theory behind artifacts of power that should have died with their makers." He met Gandalf's gaze steadily. "I did not ask for this knowledge. I did not seek it out of ambition or desire. But I intend to use it against Sauron."
"Against Sauron." Gandalf repeated the name without flinching—one of few who could speak it without fear. "You speak with certainty about an enemy you should barely know."
"I know things I should not know. I have abilities I should not have. I cannot explain their origin in ways you would believe." Legolas spread his hands, the gesture of someone offering what little transparency he could. "But I can tell you my purpose: to see the Shadow defeated. Whatever else I am, that intention is genuine."
The wizard studied him in silence. Legolas felt the probe of ancient perception—not intrusive, but thorough. Whatever Gandalf was looking for, he searched with the patience of someone who'd spent millennia observing mortals and immortals alike.
"Radagast called you 'unwritten,'" Gandalf said finally. "A soul with no thread in the Music. I did not understand what he meant until now." He leaned back, some of the tension leaving his shoulders. "You exist outside the patterns I know. That makes you dangerous—but also potentially useful."
"Useful how?"
"Events are moving toward a crisis. The Ring has surfaced. The Enemy knows where to look. Representatives of every free people will gather at Rivendell to decide what must be done." Gandalf's eyes held something that might have been calculation or invitation. "Mirkwood should be represented. You have healed more of this forest than any other Elf in centuries. Your father respects your work, whatever his other doubts."
The Council of Elrond. Legolas's heart quickened despite decades of preparation. The gathering he'd known was coming—the moment when the Fellowship would form and the quest would begin.
"You're inviting me."
"I'm suggesting your presence would be valuable." Gandalf's tone was careful. "And I will not pretend my motivation is purely tactical. You are strange, Legolas Greenleaf. You feel wrong in ways that concern me. But I have learned, over long years, that wrong can sometimes be RIGHT—just from an angle I haven't yet understood."
He doesn't trust me, Legolas realized. But he wants to watch me closer.
It was more than he'd expected. Gandalf could have denounced him to Thranduil, could have demanded explanations that would unravel everything. Instead, the wizard was offering proximity—the chance to prove himself through action rather than words.
"I will come to Rivendell," Legolas said. "Whatever you decide about my nature, my sword and bow will serve against the Enemy."
"We shall see." Gandalf turned, preparing to continue toward the palace. "Tell me about Gollum as we walk. What did the creature reveal during his captivity?"
Legolas fell into step beside him, providing the information Gandalf needed while his mind raced with implications. The wizard knew he was strange. Suspected he carried dangerous knowledge. But was willing to give him a chance anyway.
Perhaps that's all anyone can ask, Legolas thought. The chance to prove themselves through action.
The palace gates appeared through the trees. Gandalf would speak with Thranduil, gather what intelligence he could, then continue his preparations for the gathering storm. And Legolas would prepare for a journey he'd anticipated for sixty years.
Rivendell awaited. The Council. The Fellowship.
And a Ring that would speak to him as an expert, offering partnership instead of domination.
Note:
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.