Chapter 32: Understanding?
———
Understanding something isn't as simple as saying it...
———
"If you don't understand, how can you think about it? Is that your question?"
'... huh?'
Not expecting Lumian to react to her question, Liu raised her head to look at the source of her surprise.
She moved her lips without uttering a sound, staying lost in her thoughts.
'... did I say that out loud? Did he read my thoughts?'
"That's good. You don't seem to be expecting an answer from me. But then, I have a question of my own too: not understanding, in the end, what does that mean?"
Still sitting on the Form, Lumian uncrossed his legs and looked up, not really answering Liu's question.
He stayed silent, visibly waiting for Liu or Milo to move the conversation forward.
'... not understanding, that means you haven't understood... right?'
The question was so vague, or rather so dumb, that Liu didn't understand it.
Without even looking up at Milo to see if he had an answer, she was about to put her thoughts into words out loud, when...
"Not understanding means that you already understand that you don't understand. A state of total incomprehension is unrealistic as soon as you become conscious, which is precisely why consciousness brings about reflection."
Relaxing against the Form, Lumian slid down while looking at the sky, until his legs stretched out into the grass and only his back remained resting against the Form.
"Incomprehension is nothing but understanding of our ignorance through the reflection that it brings us."
'... I don't see...'
Liu, while listening to Lumian, had let go of the blades of grass she was playing with. She saw Lumian, who was in a rather ridiculous position, raise his arm...
'... mmh?'
... when she felt a warm heaviness nudge her very gently. She turned her head a little.
"Sorry."
Milo whispered as he sat down next to Liu. He too was probably tired of standing.
"Consciousness..."
Lumian kept speaking, in his own world, pointing his finger at the void. One had to wonder if he was still teaching them.
A... spot? with white shades blending into the dark void of Obscurity had appeared when he spoke his word.
'... what is that?...'
"Reflection..."
Then another similar spot appeared at another place that he was pointing at, while speaking.
"Understanding."
And a third and last one, at yet another place, forming a sort of not very precise triangle when he lowered his arm.
'... is he still teaching us?'
"All things are connected."
This sentence, these words made links? appear between the three spots, truly forming a triangle, but still not very precise.
These links, impossible to count, tangled in every direction, somewhat filling the triangle in a mess of white threads.
"Consciousness creates matter, giving matter for reflection. Reflection gives meaning to matter, creating understanding. Understanding..."
Even before he had finished his sentence, the number of links had already shrunk to something visually quantifiable. Leaving only a single link between the spots of consciousness and reflection, as well as between that of reflection and understanding...
"... thus gives consciousness the opportunity to repeat the cycle."
The links between the spots of understanding and consciousness began to fade...
"Because understanding only results in incomprehension of itself."
... until only one remained, now forming a true triangle.
"That's what not understanding means. Maybe..."
'... I didn't understand a thing, why is he doing geometry?'
Without even moving his head, turned toward the only patch of sky among all these trees, Lumian pointed at Liu and Milo:
"Now it's your turn to tell me what not understanding means."
'... didn't he say he was going to stop explaining everything to us... is he really dumb or is he doing it on purpose?'
Not admitting to herself that the explanation had been captivating and fascinating, although incomprehensible, Liu preferred to complain.
"Uhm..."
And Milo gave it a try, probably wanting to put his own touch on all this and not be left out.
"... not understanding is already understanding our ignorance and being conscious of it. And so..."
But he only managed to get out that sentence before...
"And so, being conscious of our ignorance allows us to reflect on our ignorance and so to reflect on what we don't understand."
... Liu lost patience. Although she had managed to say this sentence more easily than Milo, she was in no way satisfied with Lumian's explanations.
"So yes, we can reflect on what we don't understand. Which I still don't understand."
Her gaze turned once again toward the grass in front of her.
"It's not logical, if I don't understand then I don't understand even if I understand that I don't understand, what I understand is my ignorance and not what I'm trying to understand, so how can I reflect on what I don't understand and then understand what I don't understand."
Some blades of grass were all twisted, one of them had kept a rather circular shape...
Although she had managed to say all of that without stuttering...
'... shit, what am I even saying?'
... that didn't mean she was sure of her words.
She noticed a small insect on one of the blades of grass she had twisted, when...
"Pfft."
... Milo, sitting a few centimeters from her, touched her without meaning to while holding back laughter after hearing her speak.
"Quit making fun of me, you didn't understand anything either."
Liu replied while shoving Milo so that he would stop making fun of her.
She looked at him, trying to see the smile he was hiding by turning his head out of her field of vision.
"Well, I see you're both completely off the mark."
Coming out of nowhere, well no, but surprisingly, Lumian spoke up while finally sitting back up on the Form to look in Liu and Milo's direction.
'... what do you mean?'
"I didn't ask you to understand what not understanding meant. Of course this idea is illogical to you, but we're not going to dwell on it. For starters, the first problem is that Liu wants to differentiate between her ignorance and what she doesn't understand."
Once again, Lumian knew how to choose the right words to irritate Liu, and already in a bit of a bad mood with Milo laughing at her, she took refuge in her thoughts:
'Ha... so I'm the first problem. He didn't ask us to understand, pff... he's here to teach us, and he even said...'
Frowning and shooting Lumian a nasty look. She found the situation truly frustrating, making this day one of the most frustrating and boring of her life.
'... I don't remember what he said, but he does nothing but contradict himself... he's really a charlatan!'
This day was loaded with new information, loaded with new ideas, loaded with frustrations... a mental load making her extremely touchy.
"I've already more or less given you enough material to understand all this, but you need more time to assimilate it and reuse it. It's going a bit too fast and anyway we're just drifting away from the main subject. In any case, for now I'm not asking you to understand what I'm explaining to you."
'... he's really annoying, who does he think he is?... damn stupid bastard who only knows how to talk...'
A little too touchy, and although these words truly reflected what she thought of Lumian, Liu knew she was exaggerating and she regretted her words a little...
'... did he hear?'
... especially if he could read thoughts.
But Lumian let nothing show when he added one last sentence to his boring words.
"I'm just asking you to accept it."
'... accept it? What?... where's the triangle?'
So boring that Liu had, precisely, not bothered to understand them.
———
Understanding something is as simple as saying it...
———
