CHAPTER 26: BURIED TRUTH
Property records told stories the living refused to speak.
I'd spent two days digging—not literally, not yet—through county assessor databases, church financial records, and real estate transactions dating back decades. The mundane bureaucracy of ownership and taxation. Most people found this work tedious. I found it calming. Numbers didn't lie. Deeds didn't deflect. Paper trails led somewhere.
Roger Hicks owned his modest home in Coral Gables. Expected. Unremarkable. A respectable address for a respectable man—three bedrooms, updated kitchen, the kind of place that said comfortable without screaming wealth.
But he also held title to twelve acres of undeveloped land forty miles outside the city. "Church retreat property," according to the deed. A gift from a grateful parishioner in 1994—the same year Marcus Chen joined the youth choir.
The same year he disappeared.
The coincidence was too perfect to be coincidence.
I pulled satellite images. The property was dense scrubland, a single access road cutting through palmetto and pine. No buildings visible from above except a weathered structure that might have been a barn. No signs of development or improvement. No evidence that anyone had ever held a "retreat" there.
No cabins. No fire pits. No cleared areas for tents or gatherings.
Just wilderness. Private. Isolated. Perfect for things that needed hiding.
"Retreat property that's never held a retreat," Harry's voice observed in my mind. "That's not negligence, Dexter. That's purpose."
I knew what I'd find there. The question was whether I'd find enough to satisfy the Code.
[MIAMI METRO — 6:47 PM]
The workday had ended, but I wasn't going home.
I checked the kit bag I kept in my trunk. Flashlight—fresh batteries. Collapsible spade—sharp edge, sturdy handle. Camera—digital, high resolution, no flash needed with modern sensors. Latex gloves—two pairs, different colors in case one tore.
Everything a curious blood spatter analyst might need for an impromptu field investigation.
Everything the Code required for proper verification.
The drive took an hour and twenty minutes in evening traffic. I watched the city fall away in my rearview mirror—glass towers giving way to strip malls, then suburbs, then agricultural land, then nothing at all.
The turn-off for Hicks' property was unmarked. A break in the fence line that could be missed if you weren't looking. I'd memorized the coordinates, and still almost drove past.
Perfect isolation.
I parked my car off the access road, behind a stand of palmettos that would hide it from casual observation. Not that anyone was likely to pass by—the nearest neighbor was three miles away, and the road dead-ended at Hicks' property line.
The last light of sunset bled across the western sky. I had maybe thirty minutes before full dark.
I grabbed my kit and started walking.
[RURAL PROPERTY — 8:12 PM]
The access road was barely more than a dirt track, overgrown with weeds that grabbed at my ankles. Tire ruts showed occasional use—someone had driven here recently, within the last few weeks—but the vegetation suggested infrequent visits.
A few times a year, maybe. When he had business to attend to.
When he had bodies to bury.
The property opened into a clearing after fifteen minutes of careful hiking. The barn I'd seen in satellite images sat at the center—weathered wood, collapsed roof section, the kind of structure that could be explained away as "historical preservation" on tax forms.
It was old. Probably original to the land, built decades before Hicks acquired the title. The perfect cover for regular visits that would otherwise raise questions.
What's Roger doing out at his property again?
Oh, he's maintaining that old barn. Historical preservation, you know. He's very dedicated.
I approached the structure carefully. Checked for signs of security—cameras, motion sensors, alarm systems.
Nothing.
Of course not. Security would draw attention. Would make people wonder what was worth protecting in the middle of nowhere. Hicks' protection was anonymity. Isolation. The simple fact that nobody had any reason to look.
Until now.
Behind the barn: disturbed earth.
Not obvious to untrained eyes. The vegetation had regrown, years of seasonal growth obscuring the scars. Wild grass and scrub had filled in the depressions. To anyone else, it might look like normal terrain variation.
But I wasn't anyone else.
The pattern was wrong—slight depressions in the soil, rectangular shapes that didn't match the natural contours. Too regular. Too geometric. Too human.
Graves.
[INSIGHT CHECK: SOIL DISTURBANCE ANALYSIS] [MULTIPLE ANOMALOUS PATTERNS DETECTED] [ESTIMATED COUNT: 3-5 BURIAL SITES] [TIME SINCE MOST RECENT DISTURBANCE: 18-24 MONTHS]
More than three victims, then. Hicks had been doing this longer than the cold cases suggested. The most recent burial was almost two years old—he'd been dormant since then, or had found another disposal site.
Either way, the evidence I needed was here.
I set down my kit. Pulled out the collapsible spade.
The ground was harder than I'd expected—dry season, compacted soil—but the spade bit deep with each thrust. I dug carefully, methodically, watching for the color change that would indicate disturbed versus undisturbed earth.
Six inches down. Eight inches. Ten.
My blade struck something hard.
I brushed away the loose dirt with gloved fingers. Exposed the find.
Bone. Small. Curved. A phalanx—finger bone, probably, based on the size and shape. Human, definitely. I'd analyzed enough remains in my professional career to recognize the difference between animal and human at a glance.
The original investigators would say this needed DNA testing, chain of custody documentation, proper forensic protocol.
But I wasn't an investigator tonight.
I was something else entirely.
I photographed the find from multiple angles. GPS coordinates logged in my phone—latitude and longitude accurate to within three meters. Evidence documented.
Then I covered it back up.
Carefully. The same way I'd found it. Smoothing the dirt, scattering dead grass over the surface. When I was done, the disturbance was invisible again.
The bodies had waited years for justice. They could wait a few more days while I prepared for Roger Hicks.
I walked the perimeter of the clearing, counting depressions. Five distinct sites, scattered behind the barn in a rough semicircle. Five young men—at minimum—who'd trusted the wrong grandfather figure. Five families who'd never known what happened to their sons.
Each depression was roughly the same size. Adult male, based on the dimensions. Consistent with the victim profile.
Marcus Chen. Devon Williams. Alejandro Ruiz. And two more I hadn't identified yet—victims whose cases had never been connected, whose names had never appeared in the same investigation.
How many more were there? Other properties? Other methods? How long had Roger Hicks been doing this?
The weight of it pressed against my chest. Not guilt—the Dark Passenger didn't understand guilt—but something adjacent. A recognition of waste. Of potential extinguished for one man's pleasure. Of lives unlived, dreams unrealized, futures stolen.
"You feel it, don't you?" Harry's voice, quiet in the darkness. "The wrongness of it. That's why you do what you do. Not because you enjoy the killing—though we both know there's that too—but because you see the imbalance. And you need to correct it."
"Is that what I am?" I asked the empty air. "A correction?"
"You're what happens when the system fails. When monsters slip through. Someone has to stop them, son. Might as well be someone who understands what they are."
The moon had risen while I worked. Fat and silver, casting the clearing in pale light. Stars emerged overhead—more visible here than in the city, away from the light pollution that made Miami's night sky a dim orange haze.
I lay down on the dirt, staring up at the cosmos. Somewhere beneath me, bones waited for discovery. Young men who'd loved music, who'd trusted their mentor, who'd died alone and afraid because one monster wore a kind man's smile.
Tomorrow, they'd have justice.
Tonight, they had only me.
[DEXTER'S APARTMENT — 2:34 AM]
The shower ran scalding hot, washing away dirt and sweat and the phantom chill of grave soil. I stood under the spray until my skin turned pink, letting the water pound against muscles tight from digging.
My hands still felt dirty. They always did, after touching evidence of what monsters left behind.
I toweled off and dressed in clean clothes. Soft pants, worn t-shirt. The uniform of a man with nothing on his conscience.
My laptop glowed on the kitchen counter. I'd already begun drafting the anonymous tip—the one that would lead police to Hicks' property after he disappeared. The Code required that victims be found. Bodies discovered. Families given closure.
Harry had taught me that. The System reinforced it. A kill without discovery was incomplete—it left wounds that never healed, questions that never got answers.
Roger Hicks would vanish from the earth. But his victims wouldn't. Not anymore.
[TARGET VERIFICATION: COMPLETE] [PHYSICAL EVIDENCE: A-RANK (BURIAL SITE CONFIRMED)] [PATTERN EVIDENCE: A-RANK (MULTIPLE VICTIMS, COMMON PROFILE)] [KILL AUTHORIZATION: GRANTED] [CODE COMPLIANCE: FULL]
The Dark Passenger surged. Hungry. Ready.
Soon.
I checked my kill kit. M99 doses—twelve remaining after tonight's reconnaissance. Plastic wrap—full roll. Knives—sharp, clean, oiled. The ritual would be perfect.
It had to be.
This wasn't just about satisfying the Urge. This was about proving I could do this right. Every kill before had carried complications—the disorientation of my first night in this body, the desperate chaos of Brian's death. This one would be different.
Methodical. Controlled. Mine.
The first real kill that belonged entirely to me—not inherited, not desperate, not forced by circumstance.
I set my alarm for 6 AM. Three hours of sleep before the final preparations began.
Tomorrow night, the choir director would sing his last hymn.
Reviews and Power Stones keep the heat on!
Want to see what happens before the "heroes" do?
Secure your spot in the inner circle on Patreon. Skip the weekly wait and read ahead:
💵 Hustler [$7]: 15 Chapters ahead.
⚖️ Enforcer [$11]: 20 Chapters ahead.
👑 Kingpin [$16]: 25 Chapters ahead.
Periodic drops. Check on Patreon for the full release list.
👉 Join the Syndicate: patreon.com/Anti_hero_fanfic