CHAPTER 25: THE CHOIR DIRECTOR
Gloria Messing's file sat open on my desk. Arsenic poisoning. Clear financial motive. High probability of guilt.
But something didn't sit right.
I scrolled through the evidence again. The toxicology reports. The inheritance records. The timeline that pointed so clearly at the caretaker who'd administered medication to a dying woman.
Too clean. Too obvious.
The System had flagged her as a candidate, but the deeper I dug, the more the case felt like something the police should handle. Given time—given a prosecutor with enough ambition—Gloria Messing would face justice through conventional channels. The wheels of law ground slowly, but they were already turning.
That wasn't what the Code was for.
Harry's voice, quiet in my memory: We hunt the ones who slip through. The ones the system can't catch. The ones who would never face justice without us.
I closed Messing's file. Opened the unsolved homicide database instead.
Three hours later, my coffee had gone cold and my eyes burned from screen glare. But I'd found something.
Three young men. All from the same neighborhood. All killed over a five-year span. All cases stone cold—no suspects, no witnesses, no forensic evidence worth mentioning.
But there was a connection the original investigators had missed.
All three victims had been members of the same church choir.
[MIAMI METRO — FORENSICS LAB — 11:47 AM]
"You're working cold cases now?"
I looked up. Masuka stood in my doorway, holding a sandwich that smelled aggressively of pastrami.
"Just reviewing some old files. Pattern analysis."
"Dude, you're supposed to be recovering from trauma, not solving mysteries that have been dead longer than the victims." He took a massive bite. Chewed with his mouth open. "LaGuerta's already impressed enough. You don't need to go above and beyond."
"It helps me focus."
"You know what helps me focus? Strippers and video games." He grinned, sauce on his chin. "But whatever works for you, I guess."
He wandered off, leaving the smell of deli meat behind him.
I turned back to my screen.
The choir connection wasn't in the official case files—I'd had to piece it together from victim profiles and church records I'd accessed through less-than-official channels. Detective work that should have been done years ago, if anyone had thought to look.
Common denominator: Saint Augustine's Catholic Church. Specifically, its youth choir program.
And at the center of that program, listed in every annual report for the past fifteen years: Roger Hicks. Choir Director. Pillar of the Community. Beloved by congregation and clergy alike.
I pulled up his background.
No criminal record. Not even a parking ticket. Sixty-three years old. Widower. Retired music teacher who'd dedicated his golden years to "nurturing young talent."
Clean as fresh snow.
But the victims—Marcus Chen, twenty-two. Devon Williams, nineteen. Alejandro Ruiz, twenty-one—had all worked closely with Hicks before they vanished. All had been his "special projects." All had been killed within six months of leaving the choir program.
[SYSTEM ANALYSIS: PATTERN RECOGNITION CONFIRMED] [PROBABILITY OF CORRELATION: 87%] [RECOMMENDED ACTION: DIRECT OBSERVATION]
The Dark Passenger stirred. Interested. Patient.
Not yet, I told it. First, we make sure.
[SAINT AUGUSTINE'S CATHOLIC CHURCH — 7:00 PM]
The church smelled like incense and furniture polish. Wooden pews gleamed under soft lighting. A massive crucifix hung above the altar, Christ's expression frozen somewhere between agony and peace.
I'd never been religious—this body's memories confirmed the same for the original Dexter—but there was something about churches that commanded a certain reverence. The weight of belief. The collective hope of thousands who'd knelt in these same spaces, praying for salvation.
Tonight, I wasn't here to pray.
The choir practice room was in the basement. I'd timed my arrival to coincide with the weekly Wednesday session—an interested community member considering joining the adult choir. That was my cover. The truth was considerably darker.
Stairs descended into fluorescent light and the sound of warming vocal exercises. A dozen people stood in rows, sheet music in hand, following the conductor at the front of the room.
Roger Hicks.
He was smaller than I'd expected. Five-six, maybe five-seven. Silver hair combed neatly back from a high forehead. Wire-rimmed glasses perched on a patrician nose. He wore a cream-colored cardigan over a button-down shirt—the uniform of a kindly grandfather.
But his eyes...
I watched from the doorway as he moved among the singers. Correcting posture. Adjusting hand positions. Making small jokes that earned warm laughter. Charming. Grandfatherly. Everything a beloved community leader should be.
Then his hand landed on a young tenor's shoulder. Lingered there. Squeezed once, twice, before releasing.
The tenor—barely out of his teens, bright-eyed, trusting—leaned into the touch.
Hicks smiled.
Something cold slithered through my chest.
[INSIGHT CHECK: PREDATORY GROOMING BEHAVIOR DETECTED] [PHYSICAL CONTACT: EXCEEDED APPROPRIATE DURATION BY 3.2 SECONDS] [TARGET ASSESSMENT: PROBABLE]
Probable wasn't proof. Not yet. But I'd seen enough to know I was looking at a monster wearing human skin.
It takes one to know one.
The practice ended at eight-thirty. I'd joined the back row, mouthed along to hymns I didn't know, and observed.
Hicks noticed me immediately. Of course he did. New face. Potential target demographic. He'd approached during the break with a cup of weak church coffee and a smile that didn't quite reach his eyes.
"Welcome! I don't believe we've met. I'm Roger."
"Dexter." I shook his hand. Dry palm. Firm grip. "I'm new to the neighborhood. Thought I'd check out the choir."
"Wonderful! We're always looking for new voices." His gaze swept over me—assessing, categorizing. I was too old to be his preferred prey. That much was clear from the way his interest dimmed slightly. "What's your range?"
"Honestly? I'm tone-deaf. My sister keeps telling me I should find hobbies, and this seemed..." I gestured vaguely at the room. "Wholesome."
Hicks laughed. A practiced, avuncular sound. "Well, we can work with enthusiasm even if the pitch isn't perfect. Stay for the rest of practice. See if it suits you."
"I'd like that."
He clapped my shoulder—brief, appropriate, nothing like the lingering touches he reserved for his younger singers—and returned to the front of the room.
I sipped my coffee. Bitter, watery, barely above room temperature.
An elderly woman in the row beside me leaned over. "Isn't Roger wonderful? He's been with the church since before Father Martinez arrived. The youth program would fall apart without him."
"He seems dedicated."
"Oh, he is. Some of those boys—they come from difficult homes, you know. Roger takes them under his wing. Gives them structure. Purpose." She beamed with the certainty of the willfully blind. "He's practically a saint."
"I can imagine."
The word saint curdled in my mouth.
I stayed for the rest of the practice. Watched Hicks conduct his choir—hands moving through the air like a maestro, coaxing beauty from ordinary voices. He was good at this. Talented. The kind of person who inspired genuine devotion in his followers.
That was the worst part, really. The skill. The charm. The way he'd built an entire community that would defend him against any accusation because Roger would never, he couldn't possibly, he's done so much for the church.
Monsters like Hicks didn't survive by being obvious.
They survived by being indispensable.
Practice ended. People filed out in clusters, chatting about weekend plans and upcoming service schedules. I hung back, watching Hicks say goodbye to his singers.
The young tenor—I'd caught his name during practice, Danny—was the last to leave. Hicks walked him to the door, one hand resting on the small of his back.
"Remember what we discussed, Daniel. The solo is yours if you want it. But you'll need to put in extra practice time. Maybe come by my house this weekend? We can work on your breath control."
Danny's face lit up. Eager. Trusting. "Really? That would be amazing, Mr. Hicks. Thank you!"
"Of course, son. That's what I'm here for."
They parted at the door. Danny practically bounced toward his car—young, hopeful, utterly unaware of the danger he'd just narrowly avoided.
I watched him drive away safely.
This time.
Hicks turned back to the empty practice room. For a moment, his mask slipped. Something cold and calculating flickered across his features—a predator denied its prey, already planning the next opportunity.
Then he noticed me still standing there.
The mask snapped back into place. Warm smile. Twinkling eyes.
"Dexter! I didn't realize you were still here. Thoughts on joining us?"
"I think I might," I said. "You've built something special here."
"That's kind of you to say." He gathered his sheet music, slipped it into a worn leather satchel. "Music has power, you know. It can heal wounds. Build bridges. Sometimes, for these young men from troubled backgrounds, it's the only positive influence in their lives."
And you use that influence to destroy them.
"That's admirable," I said aloud.
"I try." He headed for the stairs, and I followed. We emerged into the nave, footsteps echoing in the empty space. "Same time next week, if you're interested. We can always use more baritones."
"I'll be here."
We shook hands again at the door. His grip lingered a fraction too long.
"I have a good feeling about you, Dexter. Welcome to Saint Augustine's."
He walked to his car—a sensible sedan, beige, utterly forgettable—and drove away into the Miami night.
I stood in the parking lot, watching his taillights disappear.
Forty slides in my collection. Forty monsters who would never hurt anyone again.
Roger Hicks would be forty-one.
But first—I needed proof.
Reviews and Power Stones keep the heat on!
Want to see what happens before the "heroes" do?
Secure your spot in the inner circle on Patreon. Skip the weekly wait and read ahead:
💵 Hustler [$7]: 15 Chapters ahead.
⚖️ Enforcer [$11]: 20 Chapters ahead.
👑 Kingpin [$16]: 25 Chapters ahead.
Periodic drops. Check on Patreon for the full release list.
👉 Join the Syndicate: patreon.com/Anti_hero_fanfic