"It was so painful back then. Being pierced in such a sensitive spot... I felt like I was dying. And he had to do it while I was 'excited' to get the aim right."
"Thinking back, it really was agonizing. But it's the token he gave me. He said that with this, he could identify me among the five of us even while blindfolded. Imagine that... wanting to find me so badly he'd do that. He really loves me~"
Nino cupped her pierced breast, showing it off to her sisters while "complaining." Her face was the picture of smugness. Miku felt a surge of jealousy. I was here first! Why does she have a token and I don't?!
"I... I want one too!"
It wasn't Miku who spoke, but the glasses-wearing Itsuki. Now completely naked, Itsuki's body was identical to her sisters'—creamy skin, perky breasts, and the twin mounds of her ass. Only her glasses and long hair set her apart. Blushing furiously, she stared at Rin.
Nino panicked. "It hurts! Like you're dying! Especially there... don't do it..."
"I don't care about the pain! I want one!" Itsuki pushed Nino aside. Miku and Yotsuba, emboldened, also crowded around Rin, their naked bodies pressing against him.
"No problem," Rin said. "I actually prepared sets for all of you when I got Nino's. I brought them today."
"Huh?! You pervert! They don't have the same tastes as me! An earring would be enough for them!" Nino snapped, her exclusivity threatened.
"It's okay... even if it hurts."
"Yeah!"
"Don't listen to Nino. I have anesthetic, it doesn't hurt at all." Rin patted Nino's head. "I just didn't know if you'd like them."
Rin looked at Ichika and Yotsuba. "Do you want them?"
"Um... I'll try. I'm worried it might affect my sports... but even if I can't wear it during practice, I'll treasure it," Yotsuba said.
"Hehe... if my little sisters aren't afraid, how can the big sister back down?" Ichika arched her back. Because of her recent "solo play" in the closet, her nipples were more prominent than her sisters'. She was worried about them showing through thin clothes, but since Nino had hidden hers so well, she figured it was fine.
Rin pulled out four small gift boxes. They were identical to Nino's, only the gemstone colors differed. He also brought out some "anesthetic wipes" (which were just wet wipes).
"Sit down, I'll apply the 'numbing' agent."
The five identical girls sat in a row on the bed, their soft bodies pressed together.
"Itsuki asked first, so she goes first." Rin wiped her nipple and then pressed the ring into place. Itsuki squeezed her eyes shut, her knuckles white as she gripped Yotsuba's hand.
"Three... two... one..."
"IT HURTS!!!!"
"I'm the one getting it, why are you screaming?" Itsuki deadpanned at Nino. Nino had screamed just to scare them.
"But... it really doesn't hurt. And there's no blood," Itsuki noted, flicking the jewel just like Nino had.
Rin proceeded down the line. Miku got blue, Yotsuba got green, and Ichika got a pale cream-colored stone. Now, all five sisters were "branded." Rin squeezed the red stone on Itsuki's breast; the texture was a perfect mix of soft flesh and cold metal.
SLAP!
Rin delivered a sharp slap to Nino's ass, the sound echoing. "Now that everyone has their tokens, we can start the part Nino is most looking forward to."
"Ptooie! Who's looking forward to it! And why hit me?!"
"Because your ass has the best hand-feel, Nino," Rin smiled.
"Well... hmph..." Nino blushed and looked away, her "tsun" completely replaced by "dere."
Rin had the five sisters kneel on the bed in a row, chests pressed against pillows, rumps thrust into the air in the 'OR2' position. From this angle, he couldn't see their faces, but the view was magnificent: five pairs of round, perky butt cheeks, with their "flower gardens" and puckered "rosebuds" fully exposed.
It was a sight to behold. Five identical sets of treasures, laid out for him. Rin noticed that only Nino's ass had a red handprint on it; the others were pristine. He delivered a light slap to each, watching the meat ripple from their hips to their waists.
The girls buried their faces in the pillows, their toes curling in shame.
"Truly identical," Rin whispered, trailing his fingers over the five pairs of soft cheeks like he was playing a piano. "But... who goes first? Ichika? Nino? Miku? Yotsuba? Itsuki?"
They were too shy to speak.
"Fine. Whoever wants it first, speak up."
Ichika wanted to be the "generous" sister; Nino was still acting coy; Yotsuba was too polite. Finally, the usually shy Miku lifted her head.
"I... I'll go first."
"Hmph... so eager. Fine, you take the first turn," Nino said, propping her chin up. "I'll be second."
"Then Ichika is third?" Yotsuba suggested.
"I'll go last," Ichika said, her voice sounding composed. "I am the big sister, after all."
"Hmph," Nino snorted. "She just wants to satisfy her 'Netori' fetish. She wants to see us 'taken' before her. Just say it, Ichika! Yotsuba is third, Itsuki is fourth, Ichika is last."
"Don't be so blunt," Ichika giggled, fully embracing her "perverted sister" role. "Watching a lover take a sister's purity right in front of me is very stimulating~"
"Pervert!" Nino huffed.
"If there are no objections, then the order is—"
"Wait."
Itsuki, who had been silent, interrupted. She didn't look up, keeping her face buried in the pillow. Her ears were crimson. She let out a few muffled sounds before finally screaming into the pillow:
"D-Daddy! Your... your daughter's pussy is so itchy! I can't wait to give it to Daddy! Please start with me!!!! PLEASE, DADDY!!!!"
""""?????""""