Gulp... gulp...
A terrified Itsuki swallowed hard. Both she and Ichika were covered in cold sweat. Miku's plan involved a "confrontation," which Itsuki imagined would be Ichika banging on the door screaming, "I know you're in there with my man!" before they opened it to confess. She didn't expect a perverted voyeur.
While the girls were frozen, Rin calmly walked over to the closet and helped Ichika up. Only one side of the double doors had opened. From Itsuki's angle, Kaede was still hidden behind the other door. Rin closed the closet door as he helped Ichika up.
Even if Kaede hadn't kicked her out, Rin would have dragged her out soon. Miku's plan to satisfy Ichika's "fetish" was to let the sisters be "taken" in front of her. But Rin had his own plan. Seeing the sisters taken was one thing... but it wasn't nearly exciting enough.
Hearing Itsuki's scream, Nino and the others rushed in from the living room. Seeing Ichika, they all froze. But then they noticed... Your hand! What is your hand doing?!
The stunned Ichika realized one of her hands was still tucked into her panties, while the other was glistening with Kaede's fluids. Kaede had timed the kick perfectly, right when Ichika was at her most "active."
Ichika wanted to cry. She pulled her hands out and hid them behind her back. I was only doing that to stay in character! To look like I have the fetish! Now... she would never be able to wash away the "pervert" label.
The five sisters stared at each other in an awkward silence.
"Ahem!" Rin cleared his throat, drawing all eyes to him. "Miku didn't tell you the whole plan. Ichika was hiding in the closet long before you arrived. As for why..." Rin turned his gaze to Ichika.
Miku had told the others about the "fetish" to make them feel less guilty about "stealing" Rin from the eldest sister.
"I... I... because... because I have a cuckold fetish!" Ichika blurted out.
"""???"""
Nino, Yotsuba, and Itsuki were dumbfounded. They had spent days rehearsing a tearful confession, never imagining Ichika would be into this.
"S-so you planned this together?" Nino's anger began to simmer. She glared at Rin. "You only approached us to satisfy Ichika's perversion!?"
"Exactly!" Yotsuba puffed her cheeks, glaring at Rin. Itsuki looked sternly at him as well. They could accept Rin being a philanderer because they believed he actually loved them. But they couldn't accept being used as mere "tools" for Ichika's sexual gratification. That was an insult.
"No, no, it's the first I've heard of it too," Rin said.
"Yeah, yeah," Ichika nodded frantically. "I only ever told Miku."
"Hmph... I never thought you'd be into that, Ichika. No wonder Miku got so bold." Hearing this, Nino and the others relaxed, their expressions softening.
Miku, however, looked bewildered. "I... I thought you did those things to me because you knew about Ichika's interest."
"How could that be? Miku is so cute, how could I ever give her to another man?" Rin said righteously. "And this is all so you five can stay together forever."
"Right, right. Even if he's a dog, he's a dog who wants us to stay together," Yotsuba piped up.
Itsuki added, "And... he can tell us all apart now. Mom and Grandpa said only someone who truly loves us can do that."
"A dog is a dog, ptooie!" Nino spat, though she couldn't hide her smile. "Hmph... Ichika, did you know? I set a test for him. We told him we'd only allow his harem if he could tell the four of us apart, but this bastard pretended he couldn't!"
"Eh? Really?" Ichika leaned in, curious.
Nino started complaining to Ichika about the recent events. Soon, Miku and the others joined in. The hotel room transformed from a sex party into a sisters' tea party, leaving Rin completely ignored.
However, the sisters were playing a game of their own. Through shared looks, they decided to give the "cheating" Rin a little punishment. They wanted to see how long he could hold back. Five identical beauties in a hotel room—how long could he last?
But as the minutes ticked by, they were the ones losing patience. How is he so calm?!
Rin sat there listening, showing zero signs of impatience. Please, Rin thought. I've hosted countless orgies. You think I don't have self-control?
Besides, someone among the five was more eager to get down to business than Rin was.
"Enough! What are you smiling at!" Nino finally snapped, glaring at him. "Are you just going to sit there and watch us talk? Did you come here for a chat?!"
The other sisters giggled at Nino's impatience. It wasn't that Nino was just horny; it was the "Successor's Pride." Only she had received a "token of love" from Rin. Since getting it, she hadn't undressed in front of her sisters. She was dying to show it off. And you can't show it off with clothes on!
"Shall we... continue then?" Rin looked at Nino with a smirk.
"You've already filled my mouth today, why act shy now? Take your clothes off!" Seeing his smirk, Nino knew he was teasing her. She lunged forward to strip him.
The other four joined in. With ten hands working at once, Rin was naked in less than a minute. Nino then began to frantically shed her own uniform. They were all used to being naked around Rin, except for "official girlfriend" Ichika, who had never fully exposed herself to him.
Ichika watched her sisters' shamelessness with a twitching lip. They're so practiced... Not wanting to be outdone as the "eldest sister" and "official girlfriend," she used her acting skills to appear composed as she stripped down to her white lingerie.
Nino waited until everyone was down to their underwear. Then, with a flourish, she unclipped her bra and yanked it away.
Clink~
The metal chain of her nipple ring hit the black gemstone, making a faint metallic sound. The sisters all looked over. On Nino's creamy, white left breast, a metal ring adorned with a dark jewel was strikingly visible.
"Nino... that... when did you...?" Ichika stammered. "You actually went through with it."
Miku nodded thoughtfully. "We thought you'd just get a secret tattoo. You actually got a piercing."
"Doesn't it hurt?" Yotsuba leaned in, curious, flicking the gemstone with her finger.
Itsuki touched the skin where the metal met the flesh. "It must have been painful, right?"
Faced with their awe, Nino puffed out her chest, acting indifferent. "Of course it hurt. It's a sensitive spot. Think about an ear piercing, then multiply the pain by a thousand! I thought I was going to die." She paused, her smile becoming impossible to hide. "But... he gave this to me as a token of our love!"
""""????""""