Chapter 7 : THE DUNCAN PRINCIPLE
[Psychology Lab — October 5, 2009, 2:00 PM]
Eight chairs. One waiting room. No instructions.
Ethan sat with the rest of the study group in a space that looked like it had been decorated by someone whose understanding of "comfortable" came entirely from textbooks. Beige walls. Fluorescent lighting. A table with magazines from 2006. A clock that ticked loud enough to hear.
Professor Duncan had brought them here fifteen minutes ago, said "Please wait," and left without further explanation.
This was the episode. The psychological experiment where groups of students sat in a room with no instructions, and Duncan measured how long before they broke — how long before anxiety or boredom or social pressure overwhelmed their willingness to follow implied rules. In the show, the study group had waited the longest. A point of pride that Jeff would use to motivate them in future episodes.
Ethan knew how it ended. He knew exactly how long they would wait.
He'd also brought brownies.
"Is anyone else confused?" Annie had her pen out, tapping against her knee in a rhythm that suggested barely contained energy. "He just said wait. Wait for what? How long? There should be parameters."
"Maybe that's the test." Troy looked at the door like it might explode. "Seeing how we handle not knowing stuff."
"That's not how psychological experiments work. There are ethics. Informed consent. Clear—"
"Annie." Jeff's voice was bored. Deliberately bored. "We're in a community college psychology class taught by a British man who drinks before noon. Ethics might not be the priority here."
Britta crossed her arms. "And you would know about ethics because...?"
"Because I have functioning eyes and can read a room. Duncan's not running a rigorous study. He's just curious what happens when you put people in a box."
"So we're his guinea pigs?"
"More like his entertainment. But yes, essentially."
The clock ticked. Fifteen minutes became twenty. Twenty became thirty.
Ethan pulled the tupperware from his bag.
"Brownie?"
The container opened to reveal neat squares of chocolate, still warm from his oven that morning. The smell hit the room immediately — cocoa, butter, a hint of something spiced that Ethan had added on instinct.
"You brought brownies to a psychology experiment." Shirley's tone carried layers. Amusement. Assessment. A trace of competition.
"I bring food most places."
"I've noticed."
He passed the container around. Pierce took two immediately. Troy grabbed three. Annie hesitated, then accepted one with the careful precision of someone counting calories. Jeff declined, then changed his mind when Abed took a bite and made a sound that was almost a word.
"These are good," Abed said. "The texture suggests a higher cocoa percentage than standard brownies. The spice is unexpected but complementary."
"Cayenne," Ethan said. "Small amount. Just enough to add depth."
"Cayenne in brownies." Shirley shook her head, but she was smiling. "You're not afraid to take risks."
The mood in the room shifted. The anxiety that had been building — Annie's pen-tapping, Troy's door-watching, Britta's escalating conflict with Jeff — all of it softened. The brownies moved around the table twice. People talked about nothing important. Pierce told a story that was only slightly offensive. The clock kept ticking, but nobody seemed to mind.
Ethan felt something in the back of his skull. Not the narrative hum — this was different. Warmer. More personal. The sense of connection forming, of a group becoming a unit, of food doing what food was supposed to do.
This is new.
He filed it away for later examination.
The break came at 3:27 PM.
Jeff stood up first. "This is ridiculous. We've been here almost ninety minutes. I have places to be."
"Do you, though?" Britta's challenge was automatic, but her heart wasn't in it. "Because it kind of seems like your whole thing is not having places to be."
"My thing is not wasting time on pointless exercises designed by a man who peaked in 1997."
"How do you know when he peaked?"
"I don't. I'm guessing. The point is—" Jeff gestured at the door. "We're leaving. Anyone who wants to join me in exercising basic human dignity is welcome."
The group exchanged glances. Annie looked conflicted — leaving felt like breaking rules, and Annie didn't break rules. But Troy was already standing, and Britta was grabbing her bag, and the momentum was building.
They left.
All eight of them, walking out of the psychology lab at 3:27 PM on a Thursday afternoon, ninety minutes into an experiment that should have lasted longer.
Ethan's confidence cracked.
That was wrong.
He checked his mental timeline. The episode had shown them waiting longer. Much longer. The study group was supposed to be the holdouts, the ones whose dysfunction ironically produced patience, the ones who stayed because nobody wanted to be the first to admit defeat.
But they'd left twenty minutes early. Maybe more.
And the variable was him.
His presence. His brownies. His careful, quiet work to make the group comfortable with each other. He'd reduced their collective anxiety, made them feel secure enough to challenge the situation, given them the psychological slack to break the rules.
He'd changed the outcome by being there.
The future isn't a script.
The thought landed like ice water down his spine.
Professor Duncan caught up with them in the hallway.
"Interesting," he said. His accent made the word sound like a medical diagnosis. "Very interesting."
"Are we in trouble?" Annie's voice carried genuine concern. "Because we didn't know how long we were supposed to wait, and there was no clear instruction about—"
"You're not in trouble." Duncan held up a clipboard. "You're data. All of you. And your data is..." He consulted his notes. "Anomalous."
"Anomalous how?" Jeff's guard was up. Anything involving his performance metrics made Jeff defensive.
"Your group showed significantly lower stress indicators than any other group I've tested. Heart rate variations, fidget frequency, vocal pitch changes — all well below baseline. The brownies helped, obviously."
Eight sets of eyes turned to Ethan.
"The brownies helped," Duncan repeated. "Comfort food reduces cortisol. Basic psychology. But the effect was more pronounced than I'd expect from simple chocolate consumption. You've got a knack for this, Mr. Dalton."
Ethan smiled and said nothing.
But inside, his brain was racing. The food wasn't just good. It was having measurable effects on stress indicators. Effects that Duncan — a trained psychologist, however alcoholic — had noticed and documented.
The cooking isn't normal.
He'd suspected as much since Chang's classroom, when the hum in his skull had first suggested that Greendale operated on different rules. Now he had confirmation. The food he made did something beyond nutrition. Something beyond taste. Something that registered on psychological measurement tools.
Another power. Another variable. Another thing he didn't understand but would have to learn.
Shirley appeared at his elbow.
"Those brownies," she said quietly. "Where'd you learn to make them?"
"Trial and error."
"Uh-huh." Her eyes narrowed — not hostile, but evaluating. "Next session, I'm bringing banana bread. My grandmother's recipe. We'll see if your trial and error can match three generations of family tradition."
It was a challenge. A competition. And also, somehow, an invitation.
"Looking forward to it," Ethan said.
Troy was still eating his fourth brownie. "I feel like everything is going to be okay," he announced to nobody in particular. "Like, actually okay. Is that weird?"
"That's the chocolate," Annie said.
"No, it's different. It's like..." Troy struggled for words. "Like the brownie knows what I need."
Jeff looked at Troy with an expression that combined amusement and concern. "You're having a spiritual experience with baked goods."
"Maybe I am. Maybe that's fine."
The group dispersed. Ethan walked to the parking lot alone, the empty tupperware in his bag, the hum in his skull quiet but present.
Twenty minutes.
That's how much he'd changed the timeline. Twenty minutes in a psychology experiment. A small thing. A trivial thing.
But twenty minutes meant his presence wasn't invisible. Twenty minutes meant the future was responding to him. Twenty minutes meant he couldn't just watch the show play out — he was part of it now, and every action he took sent ripples into events he thought he knew.
The 90% confidence he'd been carrying since arrival dropped to 88.
Probably lower, if he was honest.
Support the Story on Patreon
If you are enjoying the series and would like to read ahead, I offer an early access schedule on Patreon. I upload 7 new chapters every 10 days.
Tiers are available that provide a 7, 14, or 21-chapter head start over the public release. Your support helps me maintain this consistent update pace.
Patreon.com/TransmigratingwithWishes