Cherreads

Chapter 5 - Not Eligible

It wasn't just the grades.

Numbers alone didn't hold a room the way he did.

Kaiden didn't try—he didn't need to. Answers came before questions finished forming. Problems that left others staring too long earned him nothing more than a brief glance, a line of ink, and silence. Even his presence seemed calculated—controlled, precise, untouched by the noise around him.

Conversations bent in his direction anyway.

Laughter dimmed when he passed. Eyes lingered a second too long. Whispers followed, poorly hidden behind hands and books.

Some of them turned it into jokes.

"Perfect husband."

The phrase floated often enough to stick—but Kaiden never reacted. Not a pause, not a glance. The words slid off him like they hadn't been spoken at all.

Right behind him—

Colton.

Where Kaiden stilled a room, Colton filled it.

Smiles came easily, stayed longer. His voice carried warmth that drew people in before they realized it. Staff greeted him by name. Students leaned into his presence without hesitation.

Together, they didn't balance.

They contrasted.

Ice and air.

Stillness and motion.

Someone, somewhere, had named them once—dual elements—and it stayed.

Far from the shifting lists and quiet rivalries, one name never appeared.

Kacy didn't need it to.

She stood at a distance, as she always did, her gaze finding him without effort. Two months had carved a routine out of it—glances stolen between classes, moments measured in seconds.

Enough to notice.

Enough to change things.

A month ago, it had settled into something clearer.

Not curiosity.

Not interest.

Something heavier.

She exhaled slowly, her lips curving without permission.

So this is what it feels like.

He didn't soften.

Didn't warm.

If anything, the closer she watched, the colder he seemed—sharp edges, distant eyes, words that ended conversations instead of starting them.

And still—

Her fingers curled slightly against her sleeve.

I want him.

The thought came without hesitation.

Ridiculous, maybe.

But steady.

Like something she'd been circling without realizing.

Because somewhere between the silence and the distance, something inside her had shifted. The noise she used to carry—loud, restless, clawing at her thoughts—had quieted.

Not gone.

Just… quieter.

And he hadn't even tried.

Her smile faded.

Would he even look at me?

Her gaze dropped briefly.

No rank. No position. Nothing that placed her anywhere near his world—not on paper, at least.

There were reasons.

Complicated ones.

But explanations meant nothing if he never gave her the chance to speak.

Her thoughts tangled, tightening the more she followed them.

Kacy…

Kim's voice cut through, firm enough to anchor.

"…don't lose yourself."

Kacy nodded, though the motion felt automatic.

Her eyes drifted back, unfocused. "Do you think he'd accept it… if I told him?"

Kim didn't answer immediately.

Her book closed with a soft thud as she turned fully toward her. "I don't—"

"Hey, ladies."

The voice slid in smoothly.

Familiar.

Too familiar.

Kim's expression tightened almost instantly. She didn't need to look twice.

Of all people.

The refusal sat ready on her tongue—but it stalled.

Because Kacy wasn't looking at her anymore.

And neither of them were waiting.

Chairs shifted.

Presence settled.

"Hey…" Kacy started, but the word thinned under his gaze. Her throat worked slightly before the rest followed.

She wasn't used to that.

Not from anyone.

Colton leaned back, easy as ever. "Feels like it's been a while since we've all sat together."

Kim said nothing, but she didn't send them away either.

Not when Kacy sat like that—too still, too aware.

Not when this might be the only chance she'd get.

Colton glanced between them, then leaned forward slightly. "How'd your last test go, Kim?"

The shift was deliberate.

Kim caught it.

Her brow lifted, just a fraction. So he knows.

"First," she said simply.

Colton blinked. His gaze flicked to Kaiden, then back again. "But—"

"Honors list," Kacy cut in, her voice steadier now. "Final years are split into four classes."

A pause.

Then Colton's grin returned. "Right. That makes sense."

He turned. "What about you, Kacy?"

The air shifted again.

Subtle.

But there.

Kacy's lips pressed together before she answered. "I didn't take it."

Colton stilled. "Didn't—?"

"I'm not eligible."

Silence followed.

Brief.

Sharp.

A faint scoff broke it.

Kaiden didn't look at her.

Didn't need to.

The dismissal sat plainly in the space he left behind.

Kim's fingers tightened slightly against the edge of the table.

"Don't overthink it," she said, tone light but edged. "It's not a big deal."

Kacy nodded quickly, picking it up before it could sink deeper. "I'll still write the college finals," she added, a small smile returning.

Her eyes shifted—

Back to him.

He hadn't moved.

Not even a little.

More Chapters