Chapter 9: Nine Lives and One Good Nose
"I'm not touching it."
Gus stood in the doorway of the Hendricks residence, arms crossed, staring at the cat like it had personally insulted his grandmother. The cat — a massive orange tabby named Mr. Whiskers — stared back with the particular contempt that felines reserved for humans who refused to worship them properly.
"It's a witness, Gus."
"It's a cat. Cats can't be witnesses. They lack the cognitive capacity for—"
"Mrs. Hendricks says the cat was in the room when her jewelry was stolen. The cat saw everything. Therefore, the cat is a witness."
"The cat saw a person break in and steal jewelry, and your plan is to interview the cat?"
"My plan is to investigate the crime scene while you hold the cat and look professional."
Mr. Whiskers yawned, displaying teeth that could probably do real damage if properly motivated.
The Hendricks case had come in that morning — one of three messages on the Psych answering machine, selected because it seemed low-stakes enough to build experience without meta-knowledge interference. I didn't remember this episode from the show. Either it was from a season I'd missed, or the universe was providing original content to work with.
Either way, a genuine mystery. No cheating possible.
[CASE INITIATED: HENDRICKS JEWELRY THEFT][DIFFICULTY: C (LOW). XP POTENTIAL: 45-60.]
The crime scene was a home office on the second floor of a Victorian house that had been lovingly maintained and aggressively decorated with cat-themed artwork. The window had been forced — amateur work, crowbar marks visible on the frame — and the safe had been opened using what looked like a professional drill.
Contradictory evidence. Amateur entry, professional safe-cracking. Either two people with different skill sets, or one person who was good at some things and terrible at others.
[SHAWN VISION ACTIVATING — MANUAL TRIGGER]
Three highlights. The windowsill, where something shimmered near the forced lock. A carpet fiber near the safe that didn't match the room's color scheme. And Mr. Whiskers himself, who the system had flagged for reasons I couldn't immediately determine.
I approached the windowsill while Gus maintained his standoff with the cat.
"There's something here." I leaned close without touching. "Some kind of residue. Smells like..."
"Industrial adhesive." Gus's voice came from directly behind me, startling me enough that I nearly lost my balance. He'd moved closer while I was focused, his pharmaceutical sales instincts apparently stronger than his cat aversion. "That's methyl cyanoacrylate compound. It's used in art restoration for bonding canvas to backing materials."
I stared at him. "You got that from smell?"
"Super Sniffer." He tapped his nose. "It's a blessing and a curse. Mostly a curse in public bathrooms."
The system pinged something — BCM increase, probably, for the unexpected contribution — but I was too impressed to check.
"Art restoration. So our thief works with artwork."
"Or has access to art restoration supplies." Gus crouched by the windowsill, careful not to touch the evidence. "This stuff isn't retail. You can't buy it at a hardware store. It's specialty equipment for professional conservators."
Two hours ahead of schedule. In whatever version of this case existed in my meta-knowledge database, the art restoration angle had come from visual observation of paint flecks on the window frame. Gus's nose had found the same lead faster and more definitively.
"The show underestimated him."
"Okay." I stood back, recalibrating. "Art restoration suppliers in Santa Barbara. Can't be many."
"Three." Gus was already pulling out his phone. "I sold pharmaceutical samples to a clinic near one of them last month. The owner mentioned their neighbor was some kind of specialty art supply place."
"You remember your sales route that precisely?"
"I remember everything about my sales route. It's called professionalism, Shawn. You should try it sometime."
[BCM UPDATE: 25/100. +3 FROM ALLY COMPETENCE ACKNOWLEDGMENT.][APPROACHING DUO ABILITY THRESHOLD — 1 POINT REMAINING.]
Twenty-five. One point from unlocking whatever partnership abilities the system had been holding back. And Gus had earned it through genuine skill, not through me manipulating situations to make him feel useful.
Mr. Whiskers chose this moment to rub against Gus's leg.
"NO." Gus jumped backward with more speed than I'd seen him display in any crisis situation. "Get it away. It touched me."
"It's showing affection."
"It's showing predatory behavior. Cats rub against things to mark territory. It's claiming me as property."
"Gus. Hold the cat."
"Absolutely not."
"The cat is evidence. You're my partner. Hold the evidence."
Gus glared at me with the particular intensity of a man weighing friendship against feline contact. Then, with the resignation of someone accepting their fate, he reached down and picked up Mr. Whiskers.
The cat immediately settled against his chest, purring like a small engine.
"This is not friendship," Gus informed the cat. "This is professional necessity."
Mr. Whiskers purred louder.
I turned back to the crime scene to hide my smile. The carpet fiber near the safe was interesting — deep burgundy, wool blend, the kind of material used in high-end oriental rugs. The Hendricks house had beige carpeting throughout. The fiber had come from somewhere else.
Somewhere the thief had been before arriving here.
The art supply store was called "Canvas and Conservation" and occupied a small storefront between a dry cleaner and a Vietnamese restaurant. The owner — a woman in her sixties with paint-stained fingers and the distracted expression of someone whose mind was always half-elsewhere — looked up when we entered.
"Help you gentlemen?"
"We're investigating a theft." I flashed the SBPD consultant badge, which technically authorized approximately nothing but looked impressive enough to smooth social situations. "Someone used industrial adhesive to force entry into a residence last night. Methyl cyanoacrylate compound."
The owner's expression sharpened. "That's specialty material. We're one of three suppliers in the county."
"We know. That's why we're here."
"I can check my sales records." She was already moving toward a computer behind the counter. "Methyl cyanoacrylate isn't something we move a lot of. High-end conservators only. Maybe two or three regular customers."
While she pulled up records, I let my eyes wander the shop. Art supplies arranged in meticulous categories. Restoration equipment under glass cases. And on the back wall, a display of finished conservation work — before and after photographs of paintings brought back from decay.
[SHAWN VISION ACTIVATING — PASSIVE TRIGGER]
One highlight. A photograph at the edge of the display showing a conservator at work. The carpet underneath his worktable was deep burgundy.
"Who's in this photo?"
The owner glanced up. "That's Marcus Reyes. One of our best customers. He does private conservation work for estate sales and collectors."
"Address?"
She hesitated. Customer privacy concerns, probably.
"There's a twelve-year-old girl whose grandmother's jewelry was stolen," Gus said quietly. "The jewelry includes her grandmother's wedding ring from 1952. The family had it appraised last month — it's worth maybe two hundred dollars to a fence, but it's priceless to them."
The owner's resistance crumbled. She wrote down an address.
Lassiter was waiting at the art dealer's property before we arrived.
"Spencer." He leaned against his unmarked car with the particular posture of someone who'd been beaten to the punch and wasn't happy about it. "This is my case."
"It's our case." I held up my hands in a gesture of peace. "We found the same lead independently. Art restoration supplies. I figured you'd be here eventually."
"How did you find the lead?"
"Psychic vision."
"Gus smelled it," Lassiter said flatly.
Gus straightened. "How did you—"
"The forensics team found adhesive residue on the windowsill two hours ago. When I called the first art supply store on my list, they said two men had already been asking questions — one claiming to be psychic, the other correcting his partner about chemical compounds."
I glanced at Gus. "You corrected me?"
"You called it 'glue stuff.' I had to maintain professional standards."
Lassiter pushed off from his car. "Marcus Reyes has a prior record. Art fraud, ten years ago. Did eighteen months, got out, supposedly went straight." He studied me with the particular skepticism of a man who refused to be impressed. "You actually found a legitimate lead."
"We found a legitimate lead," I corrected. "Gus's nose, my investigation, your arrest authority. Team effort."
The word "team" seemed to cause Lassiter physical discomfort. But he didn't argue.
"I'm taking point on the interview."
"We wouldn't dream of interfering."
We interfered almost immediately. Lassiter knocked on Marcus Reyes's door and received no answer. I spotted movement through a side window and mentioned it loudly enough for Lassiter to hear. Gus found an unlocked side entrance and didn't quite prevent himself from walking through it.
The inside of the conservation studio was exactly what the photograph had promised — worktables covered in paintings in various states of restoration, specialty chemicals lined up on shelves, and a deep burgundy carpet that matched the fiber from the Hendricks crime scene perfectly.
And Marcus Reyes, standing frozen near a back exit with a briefcase in his hand and the expression of someone who'd just realized his escape route was blocked.
"Marcus Reyes." Lassiter's hand moved to his weapon. "Stop right there."
"I want a lawyer."
"You'll get one. After we search that briefcase."
The briefcase contained Mrs. Hendricks' jewelry, including a wedding ring from 1952 that would mean everything to a twelve-year-old girl.
[CASE COMPLETE: HENDRICKS JEWELRY THEFT][XP EARNED: 52. NO META-KNOWLEDGE DETECTED.][BCM UPDATE: 26/100. DUO ABILITY THRESHOLD REACHED.][NEW FEATURE UNLOCKED: COMBO CHAIN EXTENSION (PARTNER ASSIST)]
The notifications cascaded while Lassiter read Marcus Reyes his rights. Level 2 holding steady. BCM at the threshold. And a new ability I'd have to test later — something about extending combo chains when Gus contributed to an observation sequence.
"Nice work, Spencer." The words came out of Lassiter's mouth like he was swallowing glass. "You too, Guster."
"We try," Gus said, and I caught the slight straightening of his spine.
Buzz McNab arrived to process the scene. He caught my eye and offered a small nod — the informal informant relationship we'd been building since the spelling bee case. Another thread in the web of connections that was slowly replacing my isolation.
"Hey, Buzz. Random question — does Marcus Reyes have any known associates? The entry work on the Hendricks house was amateur, but the safe-cracking was professional. Either he's got a partner or he's very inconsistent."
Buzz pulled out a notebook. "Actually, yeah. His brother did time for burglary about five years back. Different skill set — muscle, not finesse. Want me to run him?"
"If you've got time."
"For you guys? Always."
Lassiter watched this exchange with an expression suggesting he was reassessing his assumptions about departmental loyalty.
The Psych office was quiet when I returned that evening. Gus had driven home to treat his cat scratch — Mr. Whiskers had gotten one good swipe in during the arrest chaos — and I had the space to myself for the first time since the case started.
I sat at the desk with a napkin and a pen, tallying something I'd been tracking mentally all day.
Nostalgia Points.
The system had pinged me three times during the case for pop culture references I'd dropped without thinking. A Ghostbusters line during the first interview ("Back off, man — I'm a scientist" when the shop owner questioned my credentials). A Real Genius deep cut while examining the conservation equipment. And a Ferris Bueller's Day Off reference that had made Marcus Reyes laugh despite himself.
[NP TOTAL: 14/100][BREAKDOWN: GHOSTBUSTERS (COMMON) +1, REAL GENIUS (DEEP CUT) +8, FERRIS BUELLER (COMMON) +2, MISC REFERENCES +3]
Fourteen points. Not enough to unlock the Nostalgia Bank's actual features — that was locked behind Level 4 — but proof that the system rewarded the '80s references that made Shawn Spencer who he was.
I wrote down the numbers on the napkin, then added the other stats I'd been tracking mentally.
BCM: 26. Duo abilities unlocked.
XP: 139/300 toward Level 3. Roughly halfway there.
Shawn Vision accuracy: Improving. Fewer false positives per scan.
Juliet O'Hara's notebook: Unknown number of pages. Concerning.
The last item wasn't a system stat, but it felt like one. She'd been watching me since the spelling bee case. Taking notes. Building a profile of the "psychic consultant" who seemed to know things he shouldn't.
I didn't know what was in that notebook. I didn't know how long I had before her observations accumulated into actual suspicion.
But I knew she was smart. And I knew that ignoring the threat wouldn't make it go away.
[SYSTEM NOTE: STOP WORRYING ABOUT THE DETECTIVE. YOU CAN'T CONTROL HER INVESTIGATION. FOCUS ON CONTROLLABLES.]
The system's sarcasm had a point. I couldn't stop Juliet from taking notes. I could only make sure those notes reflected genuine competence — real cases solved through real detection, regardless of the mystical window dressing.
My phone buzzed. A new voicemail from a number I didn't recognize.
"Mr. Spencer? This is Thomas Hendricks. Mrs. Hendricks' grandson. I wanted to thank you for finding my grandmother's ring. She... she passed away last year, and that ring was the last thing we had of hers. The police said you were the one who figured out where to look."
The message continued, but I stopped listening.
"This is why."
Not the XP. Not the level-ups. Not the system features or the BCM milestones.
This. A twelve-year-old boy thanking a stranger for returning something that mattered.
I saved the voicemail and checked the rest of my messages. Two new potential cases — one involving a suspicious death at a winery, the other concerning a Civil War reenactment group with internal drama.
The Civil War reenactment case was Lassiter's spotlight episode from Season 1. The one where his historical society obsession got screen time. The one where I'd have to work alongside a man who still barely tolerated my existence.
I wrote down the case details anyway.
The art dealer's storage unit had been searched during the arrest. Inside, the police found something Marcus Reyes couldn't explain — a collection of paintings that didn't match any of his known conservation clients. Paintings that might be stolen, might be forgeries, might be something else entirely.
The system hadn't flagged any of it as familiar. Whatever was in that storage unit, it wasn't from any episode I remembered.
"The universe is providing original content," I thought. "Mysteries I'll have to solve the old-fashioned way."
For some reason, the thought made me smile.
Get Early Access to New Chapters
Thank you for reading. For those who want to skip the wait, my Patreon is currently 21 chapters ahead of the public sites.
Schedule: 7 new chapters released every 10 days.
Benefit: Gain a significant lead of 7 to 21 chapters depending on your tier.
Support the project and start reading the next arc now: Patreon.com/IsekaiStories