Chapter 83: Biomass Economics
"Calgar wants to see me?"
On the wind-scoured left-flank salient, Duvette lowered the vox unit he had just closed and allowed himself a single moment of genuine confusion. What would a Chapter Master want with one mortal Commissar at this particular juncture?
He raised his head into the ice-flecked wind and looked outward. The diseased green of the toxic cloud had advanced to very nearly the far side of the great glacial ice bridges.
Through the rolling mist, Termagants and Hormagaunts were charging the line on top of their own dead, the kind of expendable pressure that served no purpose except consumption on both sides.
The heavy Tyranid organisms had vanished from the line again. He did not know why, but everything he understood about how the Tyranids operated told him the swarm was not giving them time to breathe. A Hive Tyrant was a Synapse organism of exceptional capability, possessed of tactical processing that exceeded anything mortal command could match in raw speed. It would not abandon a target with the strategic significance of Marneus Calgar. The swarm was drawing back to strike.
But an order was an order. He would go.
He had already run through the logic. The line was going to fall. There was no version of continued grinding attrition that ended with the defense holding against what was being prepared for them. The correct course was withdrawal, preservation of fighting strength, and a deliberate strategy to exhaust the swarm's resources over time from a position that could actually be defended. That was the only rational option left to them.
Calgar was Astartes. His tactical instincts were beyond question. But against a threat as recently encountered as the Tyranids, it was possible that the Chapter Master's strategic framework had limits the situation was about to expose. Duvette felt he had something to say.
He handed the salient's temporary command to Major Dylan and Sergeant Titus. He climbed into an armored transport and drove hard toward the underground fortress.
---
The silence in the council chamber pressed down like additional weight.
Several tall Ultramarines and a cluster of heavily augmented tech-priests stood around a massive stone conference table. When the guard brought Duvette in, he was immediately and obviously the wrong scale for the room. He was approximately level with the table's edge. He was aware of precise, appraising attention from several of the Astartes around him, the kind of scrutiny that contained assessment, curiosity, and the restrained edge of something that was not quite welcome.
Duvette scanned the faces at the table. He recognized none of these Astartes.
Heavy footsteps came from the far end of the chamber. A Space Marine in Terminator armour filled the doorway and crossed the threshold. The armour was proportioned on a scale that made the power-armoured warriors already in the room seem slightly less enormous by comparison. The face above the armour's collar was carved hard, the features giving the impression of something that had been put under sustained pressure for a very long time and had not yielded. The eyes were the eyes of someone who had been making decisions about vast numbers of lives for decades.
When Duvette's gaze reached the enormous power fists locked to both gauntlets, he knew who this was without needing anyone to confirm it. The Gauntlets of Ultramar. Chapter Master Marneus Calgar.
Duvette straightened immediately and brought his right fist to his chest in the Aquila alongside the Astartes around him, giving it without any hesitation.
Calgar moved to the head of the table, declined the formality with a brief gesture, and stepped directly to the matter at hand. He activated the hololithic projection and laid out the full current picture without softening any of it: casualty figures across every defensive sector, ammunition depletion rates, the toxic cloud's rate of advance. All of it displayed in the same cold light.
"This is our situation." Calgar's voice moved through the chamber. "On the question of what comes next, I want to hear every perspective available to us. Speak."
The Ultramarines around the table began presenting their assessments. Most of what they offered fell within the classical tactical catalogue. Redeployment of heavy weapons platforms. Thunderhawk-assisted mobile defense doctrines. Organized counterassault operations to disrupt the swarm's assault cohesion and buy time.
Then Duvette's attention was drawn to a young Astartes standing near the far end of the table. The helmet he wore was decorated with an extravagant crest, and his bearing communicated a complete absence of doubt in his own judgment. He stepped forward with a confidence that the room's atmosphere had done nothing to diminish and put his case in forceful terms: give him authorization, give him a strike force built from the finest veterans in the Chapter, and he would drive directly into the swarm to find and eliminate the command node that was directing the assault.
Duvette looked at this warrior for a moment. He wondered, privately, if that was Sicarius.
Calgar listened to all of it without committing to any of it, hands flat on the stone table, his gaze moving across the hololithic display without settling.
Duvette was still working through the question of when to speak without sounding like he was interrupting something that had a higher institutional priority than his opinion, when Calgar's voice came across the chamber directly, and precisely, to him.
"Colonel-Commissar Duvette." Calgar raised his eyes and fixed them on the mortal at the table. "As the most outstanding mortal commander in this engagement. What is your assessment?"
The question landed on Duvette with the quality of something he had not expected in quite this form, and the full weight of every Astartes gaze in the room shifted to him simultaneously, like a set of lights all tracking the same point.
Duvette did not hesitate. He stood straight, cleared his throat once, and spoke in a voice that was level and carried the full room.
"I recommend withdrawal, my lord. Complete abandonment of the Cold Steel Ridge defensive line. Preserve all fighting strength."
The statement landed in the room like a dropped weight hitting still water.
"Absurd."
"This is an outrage. Mortal, you dishonor the name of the Ultramarines."
Several Astartes stepped forward with the controlled fury of beings who had spent a century understanding that Cold Steel Ridge was the last barrier before the polar fortress complexes, and who were now hearing that position described as expendable. To the Ultramarines in that room, Duvette's recommendation carried the same moral weight as deserting a post in the face of the enemy.
"Silence."
Calgar's right arm came up, and the Gauntlet of Ultramar came down onto the stone table with a single blow that produced a sound like a small detonation and sent a fracture line through the stone surface. Every voice in the room stopped. Every Astartes held their position and forced the fury back.
Calgar's gaze was cold and level as it returned to Duvette. "Continue. If you cannot give me an absolute reason for what you are recommending, I will have no choice but to conclude that what I am hearing is mortal cowardice. Commissar Duvette."
Duvette gave a nod. The rage surrounding him landed on him like weather and passed the same way. He held Calgar's eyes and pressed forward.
"My lord, I have examined the behavioral pattern of the Tyranid swarm across multiple engagements in this star system and arrived at a conclusion that the situation requires us to confront. The swarm does not attack Macragge out of hatred. It is not capable of hatred in the way we understand it. Every action the hive mind takes is oriented toward a single objective: the acquisition of biomass."
He extended one finger toward the hololithic display and its dense field of red contacts.
"Consider the following analogy. A pack of wolves of exceptional intelligence and coordination drives out of its territory because it is starving. It has identified prey. But as the hunt progresses, the prey's resistance costs the pack far more than anticipated. The fighting has burned reserves the pack needed. Losses among the pack itself are severe and growing. At that point, any pack that is not operating on pure instinct will stop. It will calculate the balance. If the cost of this hunt is higher than what the prey is worth, the pack abandons it and finds something easier."
He held the room.
"The Great Devourer operates on this same logic. If the biomass the swarm must expend to break a planet's defenses exceeds the biomass it can harvest after breaking those defenses, the engagement becomes a losing transaction. And when an engagement becomes a losing transaction, the hive mind will redirect its resources to a more profitable target."
Duvette let that settle, then completed the argument.
"Cold Steel Ridge is going to fall. The toxic cloud and the swarm between them will take it regardless of what we do with the forces currently here. Given that, the most important thing we can accomplish right now is an ordered withdrawal of every fighting unit to the heavy fortress complexes, where we can conduct a sustained war of attrition against the swarm. We must survive long enough for the next Imperial fleet to arrive and relieve us. That is when the counterattack becomes possible. If we lose the army here, Macragge falls. There is no variant on this that ends differently."
The chamber was silent.
Calgar's brow had drawn down into deep thought. After a long moment he raised his head.
"Duvette." The voice was careful. "You must understand what we are doing here. We stand on this ground to halt the invasion of Macragge entirely and to protect the heart of Ultramar from being violated."
"The reality does not bend to that intent, my lord." Duvette kept his voice level and respectful. "Our orbital engagement is failing. The fleet is progressively losing control of close orbit. That means we have already lost the strategic foundation for fighting this swarm on equal terms. We also did not anticipate that the swarm's Shadow in the Warp would sever our communications with Holy Terra entirely. At this point, the only viable strategic action is to preserve our strength and outlast the swarm's patience until relief arrives. If the army dies here, Macragge is finished regardless of how long the fortress walls stand."
Calgar was silent again. Long enough that the silence had weight to it.
When he spoke, his voice had changed register. It carried the gravity of someone stating something that cannot be walked back.
"A full withdrawal requires a rearguard force. Someone must hold this position while the rest of the army moves. Against what is coming, in the middle of that toxic cloud, with the swarm driving through it, a rearguard assignment means certain death. Without any possibility of survival. None."
Calgar held Duvette with an attention that felt like something physical. "Your theory is correct, Commissar. Your strategy is sound. But someone must execute this part of it. Who does it fall to?"
Duvette let out a quiet breath that he had been holding since before Calgar finished the question. He had known this was where the argument went when he started making it. He had walked himself into this.
"Give the assignment to the 112th Armoured Infantry Regiment, my lord. We carry the heaviest armour and the most durable vehicles in this force. We will serve as the army's final steel rearguard and we will fight until the last man and the last round are spent."
He paused.
"I ask one thing in exchange. Leave us a formation of transport shuttles. Even with odds of one in ten million, I want the chance to bring whoever survives out."
The Astartes who had been eyeing the mortal at their table with scrutiny and veiled hostility had nothing of either in their expressions now. What was there was something with a different name entirely.
Calgar looked at Duvette for a long moment from across the table. And on that face that had been set in the same hard composure since the moment he walked into the room, something appeared briefly and then was gone: the ghost of a smile.
"Relax, Commissar." Calgar rose from the head of the table. The scale of the Terminator armour and the presence inside it filled the chamber. "This supreme honor of facing death without flinching. That is something the Ultramarines have never been willing to yield to anyone else. The army withdraws. We remain on Cold Steel Ridge. We fight alongside the 112th."
****
50+advance chapters at patreon.com/Eatinpieces