Chapter 15: THE NUMBERS
Three days passed after Claire's rescue.
The camp settled into uneasy routines—morning water runs to the caves, afternoon foraging, evening fires where people pretended the world hadn't ended. Claire rested under Jack's careful supervision. Charlie hovered nearby, protective and traumatized in equal measure. And I kept my distance from everyone, nursing headaches that wouldn't fade and memories that weren't mine.
Hurley found me sorting through wreckage salvage, looking for anything useful the first scavengers might have missed.
"Need a hand?"
"It's tedious work."
"Perfect. I do tedious real good." He plopped down beside me and started digging through the debris. "My mom used to say I had a talent for boring tasks. Used to drive my brother crazy when I'd organize his entire room."
"Didn't know you had a brother."
"Diego. Two years older. Way cooler." Hurley grinned, but something flickered behind the expression. "We're not close anymore. Money changes things."
The lottery. The Numbers. The curse he believes destroyed everyone around him.
I kept sorting, waiting. Hurley talked when he was nervous, and nervous people eventually got to the point.
"So I was going through some of the clothes we salvaged," he continued. "Checking sizes, you know, in case people need stuff. And I found this notebook from one of the passengers. Had all these calculations in it. Mathematical stuff, way over my head."
"Yeah?"
"The weird thing is, the guy was using these numbers over and over. In the calculations, I mean. 4, 8, 15, 16, 23, 42." He glanced at me sideways. "Same numbers I used for the lottery back home."
My hands stopped moving.
He's testing you. Watching your reaction. He noticed something was off and he's checking.
"Lottery numbers," I said carefully. "That's a coincidence."
"That's what I thought at first. But then I remembered—those numbers are everywhere, dude. On the hatch Locke found. On the distress signal frequency Sayid mentioned. On, like, random stuff around camp."
"What hatch?"
"Metal thing in the jungle. Locke and Boone found it a couple days ago, didn't tell anyone except me." Hurley's expression shifted toward something more serious. "You looked weird just now. When I said the numbers."
Caught.
I could lie. Deflect. Play dumb the way I had with everyone else since the crash. But Hurley was watching me with those intelligent eyes that most people mistook for simple, and I was suddenly very tired of lying.
"They're not just lottery numbers," I said. "They're... significant. I can't explain how I know that."
"You can't explain, or you won't?"
"Both."
Hurley nodded slowly, processing. "Dude, ever since we crashed, you've been different. Like you know stuff that's going to happen before it happens. The caves. Ethan. The way you moved through the jungle when we were tracking Claire."
"You noticed that."
"Everyone noticed. They're just too scared to say anything."
Hurley Reyes. The lottery winner. The unluckiest man in the world. The future protector of the Island.
Also, apparently, more observant than anyone gave him credit for.
"What do you want me to say?"
"I want you to tell me the truth. Whatever truth you can."
The request was so simple it almost broke me. No accusations, no demands, no threats—just a man asking for honesty in a world full of lies.
"I know things I shouldn't know." The words came out before I could stop them. "I don't know why or how. I woke up on that plane with... information. About this Island. About the people on it. About what's coming."
"Like psychic stuff?"
"Maybe. I don't have a better word for it."
Hurley considered this. His face went through several expressions—surprise, confusion, acceptance—before settling on something that looked like relief.
"Okay."
"Okay?"
"Dude, we crashed on an Island with polar bears and smoke monsters. There's a French lady who's been sending distress signals for sixteen years. There's a hatch in the ground that nobody knows how to open." He shrugged. "Psychic knowledge is, like, fourth on the weirdness list."
The laugh that escaped me was genuine—the first real laugh since the crash.
"You're taking this remarkably well."
"I spent two years believing I was cursed because of lottery numbers. Trust me, weird is my comfort zone."
---
We talked until the sun dropped low enough to paint the water orange.
I told Hurley pieces—not everything, not the transmigration or the television show or the memories I'd stolen from Locke and Claire. But enough. Enough that he understood I had foreknowledge, that I'd been using it to help, that the Ethan situation was deliberate intervention rather than lucky guessing.
He asked good questions. Where did the knowledge come from? I didn't know. Was it always accurate? No, it degraded when I changed things. Could I predict when he was going to die?
"I don't think you're dying anytime soon," I said. "If anything, you're one of the safest people on this Island."
"Really?"
"Really. You've got... let's call it plot armor."
The term meant nothing to him, but he smiled anyway. "Cool. I've never had armor before."
"Metaphorical armor."
"Still cool."
The conversation wound down naturally. Hurley had accepted what I'd told him without demanding more—a grace I hadn't expected and wasn't sure I deserved.
"So what happens now?" he asked.
"Now we keep surviving. I try to use what I know to help without screwing things up worse. And you..." I hesitated. "You keep being Hugo Reyes. The camp needs someone who makes them feel safe, and that's not Jack or Locke or me. That's you."
"I just hand out food and tell jokes."
"Exactly."
He grinned, embarrassed but pleased. "I can do that."
"I know you can."
He reached into his pocket and pulled out a candy bar—Dharma Initiative branding, chocolate and caramel, the same kind they'd drop from supply planes for decades.
"Found a stash of these near the caves. Been saving them for emergencies." He handed it over. "Consider this an emergency snack."
I took the bar, studying the familiar logo. Apollo bars. The show had featured them constantly—product placement that had become part of the Island's mythology.
"You have no idea how funny this is," I said.
"Is that a psychic thing?"
"It's a... complicated thing."
We sat together as the sun set, two people who'd somehow stumbled into an alliance neither had expected. The candy bar tasted like chocolate and irony, sweetness cut with the knowledge of everything the Dharma Initiative had been and would become.
---
That night, I slept without nightmares for the first time since the crash.
Claire's memories still pressed against the inside of my skull. Jack's suspicion still hung over the camp like a storm cloud. The Others were still out there, presumably planning their response to Ethan's death.
But someone knew. Not everything, but enough. Someone had looked at the impossibility of my situation and chosen to accept rather than fear.
One ally who believes without understanding.
It wasn't much. But on an Island full of secrets and lies and ancient powers beyond comprehension, it was more than I'd dared to hope for.
Hurley Reyes. The numbers man. The future protector.
For now, just a friend.
And that was enough.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.