Chapter 14: THE AUCTION HOUSE
[Christie's New York, Rockefeller Center — Five Days Later, 7:22 PM]
The evening preview was a performance. Champagne served at precise temperature, lighting calibrated to make every piece glow with the quiet authority of serious money, and a guest list curated to ensure that everyone present was either wealthy enough to bid or beautiful enough to justify the catering budget.
I circulated with an auction catalogue and a glass I hadn't sipped. The Canadian passport's cover identity — Michael Brennan, independent art consultant — held its own in a room where anonymity was a courtesy extended to anyone wearing the right shoes. I'd borrowed a suit from a consignment shop on Madison, chosen for fit rather than label, and it did its job.
The catalogue listed seventy-eight lots spanning three centuries. I was interested in one.
Lot 34: Amedeo Modigliani, Tête de femme, pencil on paper, circa 1911. Estimated value: $150,000 to $200,000. Seller anonymous. Provenance traced through a Swiss gallery that had changed hands twice since the 1980s — clean enough for the catalogue, murky enough that a disappearance during transport wouldn't generate the investigative hurricane that followed higher-profile thefts.
The drawing hung on the far wall of Gallery B, flanked by a pair of Giacometti sketches that drew more attention. I stood before it for ninety seconds — long enough for my criminal memory to record every detail of its presentation: frame type, hanging hardware, gallery layout, sight lines to the nearest security camera, distance from the emergency exit.
"You've been staring at that piece for quite a while."
The voice came from my left. Sharp, professional, carrying the specific tone of someone who asked questions for a living and enjoyed it.
I turned. The woman was tall, auburn-haired, wearing a charcoal dress that split the difference between gallery-appropriate and court-ready. She held a catalogue open to Lot 34, a pen tucked behind her ear, and her eyes were doing the same thing mine had been doing to the Modigliani — cataloguing everything, storing details, building a profile.
Sara Ellis. Insurance investigator. Sterling Bosch.
In Season 2, she'd walk into the FBI's White Collar division and match Neal Caffrey move for move. She'd investigate a stolen Raphael, nearly catch Neal red-handed, and eventually become his girlfriend — one of the few people who could challenge him intellectually and call him on his charm. She was smart, tenacious, and professionally suspicious of everyone who stood too close to expensive artwork.
She was also standing two feet from me, waiting for an answer, roughly six months before she was supposed to enter the story.
"Professional interest," I said. "The provenance chain is... unusual."
Her eyebrows rose a millimeter. "Unusual how?"
"The Swiss gallery — Galerie Mercure — was a known conduit for repatriated pieces during the nineties. Three of their sales between 1992 and 1998 were later flagged by the Art Loss Register." I let the information land. Criminal memory, pulling archived data from research I'd done on Adler's files that happened to cross-reference with auction house histories. "This piece passed through Mercure in 1996. The catalogue doesn't mention that."
Sara's pen came from behind her ear. She wrote something in the margin of her catalogue without looking down. "That's a very specific observation for a casual preview attendee."
"I never claimed to be casual."
"No." She extended her hand. "Sara Ellis. Sterling Bosch Insurance."
I shook it. Firm, brief, deliberate — a handshake between professionals measuring each other. "Michael Brennan. Independent consultant."
"Consultant." She repeated the word the way Alex had repeated Monaco at Haversham's — tasting it, testing its weight. "In my experience, people who call themselves consultants at auction previews are either advising collectors or planning acquisitions they'd prefer to keep quiet."
"And which do you investigate?"
"Both." She smiled. It arrived and departed with professional precision — warm enough to be genuine, brief enough to be a warning. "Though lately I've been finding that the most interesting acquisitions are the ones that happen between the preview and the auction floor."
Transport theft. She was flagging the exact window I'd been scouting — the interval between when a piece left storage and arrived at the secure auction facility. Sara Ellis wasn't just attending the preview. She was working it, assessing which lots were vulnerable, which would attract the wrong kind of attention.
She was protecting the Modigliani. Or at minimum, she was aware that it was the kind of piece that attracted protection-worthy interest.
"That does sound interesting." I kept my voice level. The Monaco panic — that first night, blood on marble, body not mine — felt like another lifetime. Keller's social reflexes had integrated enough that I could match Sara's verbal fencing without the performance feeling like performance. "Though I imagine most thefts at this level are disappointingly straightforward."
"They are." She tucked the pen back behind her ear. "Until they're not. Nice meeting you, Mr. Brennan."
She moved toward the Giacometti sketches. I watched her go — the confident stride, the way she carried the catalogue like evidence rather than reading material. Halfway across the gallery, she paused, turned back, and gave me a look that wasn't professional at all. Something between amusement and assessment, the way you'd look at a puzzle whose shape was unexpected.
Then she was gone into the crowd.
I stood before the Modigliani and recalculated. Sara Ellis at Christie's meant Sterling Bosch was monitoring high-value transports. The insurance angle complicated the heist — not impossibly, but enough to tighten the margins from comfortable to precise.
The transport schedule was posted on the logistics board in the receiving area. I'd photographed it during my first pass through the building. The Modigliani moved tomorrow night, 9 PM, from the West 49th Street storage facility to Christie's secure gallery. Standard armored van, two-person crew, GPS-tracked.
One window. One night. And an insurance investigator who'd remember my face if anything went missing.
I set the champagne glass on a tray, buttoned my jacket, and left through the side entrance. The night air hit like cold water after the gallery's controlled warmth.
Six days until auction. The transport was tomorrow. Sara Ellis was a complication I hadn't mapped — the show hadn't introduced her until Season 2, and my meta-knowledge didn't cover what she was doing in the months before her first appearance. A gap in the script. A reminder that the world was bigger than six seasons of television.
I pulled out the burner and dialed Jimmy Chen.
"It's Keller. I've got a transport job. Tomorrow night, Chelsea, single-vehicle. Payout north of a hundred and fifty thousand, split sixty-forty your favor. You interested?"
A pause. The click of a lighter. "What's the piece?"
"Modigliani. Paper, not canvas. Transport weight is minimal. Window is four minutes between signal stops."
Another pause. Smoke exhaled. "I'm in. Send me the route."
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.