Chapter 15 : THE WRONG PREDICTION
The spice merchant wasn't the one Aldric had expected.
He stood at the southern checkpoint in the spring afternoon, watching a trading caravan approach along the Cintran road, and felt the first stirring of something that might be doubt. The lore knowledge—the accumulated information from games, books, the wiki articles he'd memorized in another life—had specified a particular merchant who ran spice shipments through this route, whose schedule Aldric had flagged as useful for tracking Nilfgaardian economic pressure on Cintran trade.
The man dismounting from the lead wagon was not that merchant.
"Tobias," the trader introduced himself, extending a hand that Aldric didn't take. "Spices from the eastern provinces. Looking to establish a route through your territory, if your lordship permits."
"The regular trader on this route," Aldric said carefully. "A man named Henryk. Where is he?"
Tobias's expression flickered—surprise, followed by the careful neutrality of someone who'd learned that honest answers sometimes caused more trouble than they were worth. "Henryk retired, my lord. Two winters past. His son took over the business, sold the southern routes, and I purchased them at auction."
Two winters past. The lore knowledge had been wrong by at least two years. Not the structural information—the trade route existed, the economic patterns were accurate—but the specific detail had been outdated before Aldric even arrived in this world.
"I see." He stepped back from the checkpoint, gesturing for the border guards to process the caravan normally. "Welcome to Varnhagen's Reach. The market is through the eastern gate."
Tobias nodded, remounting his wagon, and the caravan rolled through the checkpoint without further incident.
Aldric watched it pass, the dread sense pulsing steadily behind his ribs, and began calculating what the error meant.
---
[Keep Study — Evening, Day 275]
The page had three columns now.
The left column was labeled CONFIRMED ACCURATE. It contained structural information: the Fall of Cintra's approximate timing, Nilfgaard's expansion pattern, the location of key figures like Geralt and Yennefer, the existence of Ciri and her significance. These were the broad strokes, the framework on which everything else was built.
The right column was labeled WRONG OR OFF-SCHEDULE. It contained four entries now: Henryk's retirement (two years early), a patrol timing error that had disrupted schedules for weeks, a minor noble's death (occurred three months before the games suggested), and a merchant guild dispute that had resolved differently than expected.
The center column—the one he'd added this evening—was labeled UNCERTAIN. He filled it first, before either of the others.
The lore is not a map, he wrote at the bottom of the page. It is a rough sketch with blank spaces where I assumed there was detail. The structure is reliable. The specifics require verification.
The realization should have been obvious from the beginning. He wasn't dealing with a video game's deterministic world—he was dealing with a living Continent where small details shifted, where butterfly effects accumulated, where his own presence was already creating divergences from the timeline he remembered.
Henryk retired, he thought. Did something I did cause that? Or was the lore always wrong about him, and I'm only discovering it now?
The question was unanswerable. But the methodology it implied was clear.
He reached for a fresh sheet of parchment and began writing names: Rolan, the border farmer who'd first reported Nilfgaardian merchant traffic. Tobias, the new spice trader who might prove useful. Three merchants he'd cultivated with small favors over the past months. A village headman whose gossip network consistently outperformed formal intelligence channels.
I need an intelligence coordinator, he wrote. Someone to manage the network, verify information, track discrepancies between prediction and observation.
The barony didn't have anyone qualified. Brennan was a steward, not a spymaster. Edvard was a soldier. The village contacts were useful sources but not managers.
Add to the list, he thought. Things the barony needs that it doesn't have yet.
---
[Southern Checkpoint — Day 276]
Tobias was preparing to depart when Aldric found him at the market square.
The merchant's wagon was loaded with goods acquired during his two-day stay—local wool, preserved meats, small tools from Gavric's old forge that would fetch premium prices in the eastern provinces. He looked up from securing his cargo as Aldric approached, his expression carrying the same careful neutrality as the day before.
"Lord Varnhagen. I wasn't expecting another conversation."
"I have questions. You may have answers. If so, I'll compensate you for the information."
Tobias's eyes sharpened. Whatever else he was, the man recognized an opportunity when one presented itself. "I'm listening."
"Cintran trade patterns. What's changed in the past six months? Not the obvious things—the economic shifts, the merchant guild politics. I want to know what the regular traders are noticing. Changes in road quality. Unusual inspections. New faces at established checkpoints."
The merchant was quiet for a long moment, studying Aldric with the evaluation of someone reassessing a potential business partner.
"You're not asking about trade," he said finally. "You're asking about military preparation."
"I'm asking about patterns that might indicate military preparation. The distinction matters."
"It does to some." Tobias finished securing his cargo and leaned against the wagon's side. "I'll tell you what I've seen, and you can decide what it means. The southern roads through Cintra are better maintained than they were two years ago. Not dramatically—but the potholes get filled faster, the bridges get repaired more promptly. The kind of improvement that suggests someone is planning to move heavy traffic through those routes."
"Nilfgaardian traffic?"
"I don't know. The merchants who use those roads don't all carry imperial papers. Some of them..." He paused. "Some of them ask questions that don't make sense for traders. How many soldiers garrison the border posts. Which local lords might be persuaded to cooperation. The kind of questions a merchant wouldn't ask unless someone was paying them to ask."
The same pattern Rolan had reported months ago, at the southern boundary marker. Intelligence gathering disguised as commerce. Nilfgaard mapping the approach routes, identifying potential collaborators, preparing the ground for what was coming.
"Anything else?"
"One thing." Tobias's voice dropped. "A Wolf School Witcher has been seen working contracts in the northeast forest. Second time I've heard that mentioned this month, from two different sources. Young man, apparently. Competent, but new to the region."
Aldric's mind filed the information automatically. The games had mentioned a Witcher named Coën—younger than Geralt, trained at Kaer Morhen, killed at the Thanedd Coup. If he was in the region now, years before the canonical timeline placed him at the coup...
Another verification opportunity, he thought. And potentially something more useful.
"Thank you," he said to Tobias. "I'll have payment delivered before you leave the territory."
---
[Keep Study — Night, Day 276]
The three-column page had grown into three separate sheets.
Aldric spread them across his desk, studying the pattern of confirmed facts, errors, and uncertainties. The structural predictions remained solid—the broad strokes of the Witcher timeline, the major events and their approximate timing. But the specific details were unreliable, and relying on them had already cost him weeks of misdirected effort.
The solution isn't better lore knowledge, he realized. The solution is building an intelligence network that doesn't require lore knowledge.
Human contacts. Verified information. Multiple sources confirming the same data before it was treated as actionable. The methodology was standard for any serious intelligence operation—but implementing it required resources the barony didn't have and expertise no one here possessed.
Rolan for southern border observation. Tobias for trade route intelligence. The village headman for local gossip. Three merchants for economic indicators. He wrote the names in a new column. Five sources. Not enough for comprehensive coverage, but a foundation.
The Witcher contact was a different category. Coën—if that was who the sources were describing—wasn't an intelligence asset. He was a potential ally, or a potential complication, depending on how the approach was handled.
Don't approach directly, Aldric decided. Set up a natural encounter. Let him observe the barony, form his own conclusions. Witchers are professional monster hunters—create a contract that brings him here legitimately.
The rotfiend nest was cleared, but the territory sense registered other threats in the barony's wilder regions. Drowners near the eastern creek. Something larger—possibly a water hag—in the swamp northwest of the mill. Enough monster activity to justify posting a contract, enough danger to require professional intervention.
He began drafting the contract terms, already calculating how to position the encounter for maximum information extraction without appearing to be extracting information at all.
Learn from the failure, he reminded himself. The lore is a rough sketch. Everything else requires verification.
The third column—the uncertain column—still had more entries than the other two combined. But it was shrinking, one verification at a time.
He added a final note at the bottom of the page: Wolf School Witcher in region. Two-source confirmation. Identity probable: Coën. Approach via standard contract. Timeline: before summer.
Then he set down his quill and reached for the next document, because the work never stopped and eight hundred and twenty days wasn't nearly enough time.
Author's Note / Promotion:
Your Reviews and Power Stones are the best way to show support. They help me know what you're enjoying and bring in new readers!
You don't have to. Get instant access to more content by supporting me on Patreon. I have three options so you can pick how far ahead you want to be:
Silver Tier ($6): Read 10 chapters ahead of the public site.
Gold Tier ($9): Get 15-20 chapters ahead of the public site.
Platinum Tier ($15): The ultimate experience. Get new chapters the second I finish them. No waiting for weekly drops, just pure, instant access.
Your support helps me write more. Find it all at patreon.com/fanficwriter1