Cherreads

Chapter 42 - Chapter 42: SAY IT TO HER FACE — Part 1

Lamonsoff Apartment Hallway — 2007, Two Weeks After Bean's Birth

The apartment smelled like baby powder and exhaustion. Both scents occupied the same molecular space in the way only new-parent households could achieve — the sweetness of an infant's existence layered over the accumulated fatigue of two adults who hadn't slept more than three consecutive hours since the delivery room.

The deployment dropped me into a hallway I recognized from structure if not from decoration — the same building layout as Rob's apartment in Hartford, the same beige carpet, the same buzzing overhead light. But this was the Lamonsoff building, and the differences were immediate: a welcome mat that said THE LAMONSOFFS in stenciled letters, a mezuzah on the doorframe, and the muffled soundtrack of a household operating in the specific key of new parenthood — soft crying, softer soothing, and the occasional thump of an adult walking into furniture in the dark.

My presence anchor: building maintenance. The system had graduated from janitor to maintenance worker, which constituted either a promotion or a lateral move depending on your perspective on custodial career hierarchies. Badge, tool belt, clipboard. The clipboard was a nice touch — it gave me a reason to stand in a hallway reading things.

[Time Remaining: 30:18]

[Target: Eric Lamonsoff, age ~28]

[Current Location: Inside apartment. Bean is 2 weeks old. Donna is 7.]

[Pivot Point: Communication gap between Eric and Sally regarding parenting roles. Eric's silence during early feeding decisions established the pattern that persists for 4 years.]

[Note: This intervention window is narrow. The communication pattern crystallizes within the first month. After that, changing it requires the kind of marital conversation that Eric's avoidance instinct won't allow.]

The apartment's thin walls provided a live feed. Sally's voice — calm, competent, the specific tone of a woman who'd read fourteen parenting books during pregnancy and was now executing the plan with the focus of a project manager whose project happened to cry — filtered through the drywall.

"He's latching fine. Temperature's normal. Donna, can you bring me the burp cloth from — no, the green one. Thanks, honey."

Donna's voice — seven years old, high-pitched, the tone of an older sister who'd been promoted to assistant manager and was taking the role seriously. "Is he done? Can I hold him?"

"In a minute. Eric? Can you — Eric?"

No response. The specific absence of a man's voice in a space where his voice should be.

Through the wall, the sound of footsteps — heavy, adult male, moving away from the bedroom toward the front door. The apartment door opened. Closed. Footsteps in the hallway.

Eric Lamonsoff, 2007 edition, stood in the corridor.

He was younger by three years and heavier by what looked like twenty pounds of stress-eating, wearing sweatpants and a t-shirt with a formula stain on the shoulder that he either hadn't noticed or had stopped noticing. His eyes had the specific focus of a man who was looking at everything and seeing nothing — the hallway's beige carpet, the fluorescent light, the maintenance worker with a clipboard who occupied the periphery of a vision that was turned entirely inward.

He walked past me without acknowledgment. Headed for the stairwell door at the end of the corridor. Pushed through it. The door closed behind him, and through the small window I watched him descend two flights and emerge into the building's parking lot.

He stood beside his car. Not getting in. Just standing. The posture was identical to the hallway posture present-day Eric had shown me three hours and three years from now — vertical collapse, shoulders carrying weight, the specific stance of a man whose body had become a storage facility for sentences he couldn't deliver.

He went outside. In the movie, Eric's silence during Bean's early years is played as embarrassment — the comedy of a man who can't handle breastfeeding in public. But standing here, watching twenty-eight-year-old Eric Lamonsoff in a parking lot at eleven PM with formula on his shirt and nothing in his vocabulary, the comedy disappears and what's left is a father who doesn't know how to say "I'm Bean's parent too."

My plan had been elegant. Strategic. The system had taught me to engineer conditions rather than deliver solutions, and the condition I'd designed was precise: find the chatty neighbor on the third floor — Mrs. Petrosky, based on the mailbox labels — and steer a hallway conversation toward the topic of parenting communication. Eric would overhear. The external reference point would normalize the conversation. The seed would plant.

Mrs. Petrosky was on the third floor. Her door was ajar — the universal signal of a neighbor who wanted company and was willing to accept it from building maintenance. She was exactly what the hallway acoustics promised: gregarious, opinionated, and equipped with the specific unsolicited advice apparatus that comes standard with thirty years of child-rearing experience.

"My wife weaned at six months," the voice I steered into the conversation belonged to Mr. Petrosky, who'd been recruited by his wife's gravitational field and who delivered parenting opinions with the authority of a man who'd been told his opinions were correct by a woman who told everyone their opinions were correct. "Anything past six months is — well, it's UNUSUAL. My brother-in-law's kid was breastfeeding at two and the whole family talked about it. You know? Behind their backs, but still."

The conversation was audible from the second-floor landing. Eric was coming back up the stairs. His footsteps slowed as the words reached him — unusual, talked about it, behind their backs — and the slowing was visible in his body through the stairwell window. His shoulders pulled in. His jaw set. The parking lot vulnerability vanished, replaced by the armored smile of a man who'd just heard the world's verdict on his family's private practice and was locking the door against it.

Eric climbed the remaining stairs with the deliberate pace of a man who'd been given ammunition and was using it to reinforce the bunker instead of the attack. He reached his apartment door. Opened it. From inside, Sally's voice: "Eric? Can you hold him for a second? I need to—"

"Sure. Absolutely. Whatever you need."

The "whatever you need" was the tell. Not partnership — surrender. The specific linguistic construction of a man who'd just heard strangers call his wife's choice "unusual" and had decided that the safest response was to never, ever, under any circumstances, question it himself. The external reference point I'd engineered hadn't planted a seed. It had built a wall.

The system's assessment arrived before the realization did:

[MISSION FAILED: SAY IT TO HER FACE — Attempt 1 of 2]

[Analysis: External reference point reinforced avoidance pattern. Subject interpreted overheard conversation as social condemnation of breastfeeding, triggering protective instinct for spouse. Result: Communication avoidance STRENGTHENED, not weakened. Eric Lamonsoff will now associate speaking up about breastfeeding with being the kind of person who talks behind someone's back.]

[This is the opposite of the desired outcome.]

[Cooldown: 6 hours]

[Debug Glitch Applied — Target: Eric Lamonsoff — Severity: Minor — Effect: Agreement Compulsion. Subject will compulsively agree with all statements regardless of personal opinion. Duration: Until mission success.]

[Reminder: The correct approach is to create conditions for the TARGET to find their own courage. Not conditions that make the target's environment hostile to their vulnerability.]

The forced recall initiated. The apartment hallway dissolved — the beige carpet, the formula smell, the sound of Sally's voice asking Eric to hold their son, the muffled agreement of a man who'd just decided to never disagree again. The last thing I processed before the present materialized was the expression on twenty-eight-year-old Eric Lamonsoff's face as he picked up his two-week-old son: love so complete it terrified him, and terror so complete it silenced him.

The lake house mudroom. The cot. The window showing a lake going bright with afternoon.

I made it worse. Again. The same mistake from a different angle — I tried to create an environment that would push Eric toward speaking, and instead I created an environment that taught him silence was the only safe response. The chatty neighbor confirmed what Eric already feared: that speaking up meant being the person who judges, and Eric would rather be the person who says nothing than the person who hurts Sally.

The temporal jet lag was mild — 2007 was close enough to the present that the era-specific cravings were limited to a vague desire for Lean Pockets. The headache from skill integration fatigue, however, compounded with the deployment's cognitive load and produced a throbbing behind my right eye that felt personal.

I walked into the main house. The kitchen was between meals — the afternoon lull where the lake house's population distributed itself across outdoor activities and indoor naps. Through the window, kids were on the dock. Sally was reading on the porch. Mama Ronzoni was asleep in the good chair, which she'd claimed through the ancient right of being the first person awake every morning.

Eric was in the living room. Marcus had suggested putting hot sauce on everything at dinner. Eric's response:

"Absolutely. Great idea. The more the better."

Marcus squinted. "I was joking."

"No, it sounds perfect. Let's do it."

"Eric, I was being sarcastic."

"And I'm being enthusiastic. Those aren't contradictory."

The glitch. Agreement Compulsion. Eric is saying yes to everything because I broke the mechanism that let him say no.

Sally walked in from the porch, book under her arm. "Eric, I was thinking about dinner — should we do fish tonight?"

"Absolutely. Fish. Perfect."

"Or pasta?"

"Also perfect. Fish AND pasta. Why choose?"

Sally's head tilted. The cataloguing expression — the same one she'd worn when asking about my phone, when probing my cover story, when noting that nobody could place me at the funeral. Sally Lamonsoff's analytical engine was running, and Eric's sudden, complete agreeability was a data point that didn't match his baseline.

"Are you okay?" she asked.

"I'm GREAT. Everything's great. Isn't it great?"

"Eric."

"What."

"You're agreeing with everything."

"I agree with that assessment."

Marcus, from the couch, without looking up from his phone: "He agreed to put hot sauce on everything. That's either courage or a medical condition."

Mama Ronzoni, not actually asleep, from the good chair: "The boy needs vegetables, not hot sauce."

"AGREED," Eric said, and the word came out with a force that made Sally's book slip from under her arm.

The evening would get worse. Eric agreed to a pre-dinner hike he didn't want to take, a card game he didn't understand, and — the moment that confirmed the glitch's severity — Mama Ronzoni's raw egg smoothie. The smoothie was an old-country recipe that Mama Ronzoni prepared for "vitality" and that nobody in three generations of the Ronzoni family had voluntarily consumed. Eric drank the entire glass with a pained smile that suggested his body was staging an internal protest his mouth was constitutionally forbidden from joining.

"Delicious," Eric said, and set the glass down with the careful precision of a man preventing his gag reflex from staging a coup.

Kurt watched the smoothie incident from the kitchen doorway. His eyes moved from Eric's forced smile to Holden, standing by the window, and the look was the specific Kurt look of a man who'd observed an anomaly and was connecting it to a pattern he couldn't yet name.

I sat on the porch after dinner. The phone's cooldown timer read 4:22:18. Four hours and change. Inside, Eric was enthusiastically agreeing to help Roxanne reorganize the linen closet, which was an activity nobody had requested and which Eric's genuine personality would have avoided with the same vigor he applied to dental appointments and conversations about feelings.

The mission needs a passive catalyst. Not an engineered conversation, not a hostile environment, not an overheard opinion. Something Eric finds on his own. Something that gives him the language without giving him the pressure. A book. A parenting communication book, left somewhere Eric would find it — his car, the bathroom, the porch where he reads in the morning. Let him open it, and discover that the conversation he's been avoiding has a structure. That other fathers have the same silence. That speaking up isn't judgment — it's partnership.

The lake house had a bookshelf. Sally's influence, probably — a curated collection of novels, nonfiction, and parenting guides that reflected the reading habits of five families who'd been storing summer books in this house for decades. I scanned the spines. Three parenting books, two of them about infant sleep and one —

"When Partners Parent: Communication Tools for New Fathers."

The book was thin, dog-eared, and had been read by someone (Sally, almost certainly) with the attention visible in underlined passages and margin notes. The arcs headings were practical: "Finding Your Voice in the First Year." "The Silence Trap: Why New Dads Stop Talking." "From Deferring to Partnering."

I pulled it from the shelf. Set it on the porch table beside Eric's morning coffee spot. Not hidden, not spotlighted. Just... present. The way a book sits when someone set it down mid-arc and forgot to bring it inside.

The cooldown timer counted down. The book sat on the table. Inside, Eric enthusiastically agreed to watch a movie he didn't want to watch, and Sally's analytical engine added another entry to a log that was becoming too long to ignore.

Four hours. One book. And the hope that Eric Lamonsoff could find courage between the pages of a arcs someone else had already underlined.

To supporting Me in Pateron .

 with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus  new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month  helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes.

By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!

👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!

More Chapters