"For a long time, the cold war between them remained cold," Hank said, his massive blue hands resting lightly on the Quinjet's flight yoke. "Then the eighties hit. Magneto formed the Brotherhood of Mutants and started launching coordinated terrorist attacks on American soil."
Hank toggled a switch on the overhead console. "Charles didn't retaliate immediately. He had already founded the school. His priority was teaching young mutants how to control their gifts so they could integrate safely. He believed communication and coexistence were still the answers."
"But as the nineties rolled in, Erik escalated," Hank continued. "Charles realized that if the Brotherhood became the undisputed global face of mutantkind, human society would push for our extermination. So, he handpicked a response team from his senior students to intercept Erik. The X-Men."
Hank listed the original roster. Scott Summers, Jean Grey, Bobby Drake, Warren Worthington III, and himself. Then came the second generation: Logan, Ororo Munroe, Anna Marie, Peter Rasputin, and Kurt Wagner.
"We were a family back then," Hank murmured, the nostalgia heavy and thick in his throat.
Their battles expanded rapidly. They fought anti-mutant hate groups, dismantled the U.S. government's Sentinel program, survived the geneticist Nathaniel Essex, and stopped Magneto's plot to forcibly mutate the baseline human population.
"Until six years ago," Hank said, his voice dropping.
"Colonel William Stryker," Scott said from the passenger seat. The name cut through the dim cabin like a knife.
Hank nodded slowly. "Stryker ran a black-ops military division focused on mutant weaponization. He used his own son to hijack Charles's mind. He forced Charles to connect to Cerebro, turning the brainwave device into a global telepathic weapon designed to instantly kill every mutant on Earth."
Peter blinked behind his mask. He sat forward in his jump seat, his mind racing. He knew this story. This wasn't just vaguely similar—this was the exact, beat-for-beat plot of X2: X-Men United.
Hank kept talking, confirming every detail. Stryker's commandos raided the mansion in the middle of the night. Students were illegally black-bagged. Magneto broke out of his plastic prison, allied with the scattered X-Men, and launched a desperate assault on Stryker's Alkali Lake base—the Weapon X facility hidden inside a massive dam. They fought their way in and rescued the Professor.
"And then everything fell apart," Hank said, his gaze fixed on the dark clouds beyond the cockpit glass. "Erik double-crossed us. He tried to reverse Cerebro to kill the baseline humans instead. We stopped him, but the dam ruptured. Millions of gallons of water came crashing down into the spillway."
Scott was staring out the side window. He hadn't moved a muscle in ten minutes.
"Jean stepped out of the jet," Hank said quietly. "She used her telekinesis to hold back the flood so we could take off. But something happened. Her powers... they cascaded out of control."
Hank's voice cracked slightly. "She turned into a pillar of fire. A massive, burning bird hovering over the dam. And then she exploded. Charles used everything he had left to contain the blast radius, but when the smoke cleared, Jean was just... gone."
Hank gripped the yoke tighter, his knuckles turning a lighter shade of blue. "Charles refused to retreat. He ordered us to get the students to safety. Then he projected his telekinesis against the collapsing reservoir, holding back the floodwaters himself. He was already drained from Stryker's torture." Hank let out a slow, ragged breath. "The most powerful mind on the planet died of physical exhaustion. We found his body in the mud. We buried him."
Peter stared at the metal floor grating. That makes no sense. In his universe's movies, Xavier had a brain-dead twin brother. He transferred his consciousness at the last second and survived. But here? Captured, manipulated, forced to contain Jean's explosion, and then worked to death holding back a river? That was a brutal, aggressively final end.
Unless... Peter's brow furrowed. Unless Jean didn't just randomly lose control. If that fiery bird was the actual Phoenix Force manifesting, Charles hadn't just been holding back an explosion—he had been wrestling a cosmic entity. If that was true, the Phoenix wasn't just "gone." Cosmic entities didn't die in dam collapses. It could come back.
"So how did the team actually disband?" Peter asked, keeping his cosmic theories to himself for now.
"Logan was the first to leave," Hank said. "Packed his bags in the middle of the night. No note. No word."
"Then Erik changed the game entirely," Hank continued. "He dissolved the Brotherhood. He dredged a massive metal landmass out of the Atlantic Ocean and declared it the sovereign mutant nation of Genosha. He offered absolute sanctuary. Mutants flocked there by the millions. Even our own students packed up and left."
Hank adjusted a dial on the dash. "With no students, the school lost its purpose. Emma Frost and the Hellfire Club poached our remaining teaching staff. Eventually, we just... closed the doors."
Peter cataloged the roster in his head. "Where is everyone else?"
"Logan is in Madripoor ," Hank said. "Peter Rasputin bought a farm out in the Pacific Northwest. Anna Marie is somewhere in Europe. Warren went back to run the Worthington boardrooms. Bobby is living with his parents on Long Island—he calls every few months to ask if we're getting the band back together. Kurt emigrated to Genosha. Ororo went back to Africa and married King T'Challa of Wakanda."
The X-Men were gone. Shattered and scattered to the winds.
The cabin fell into a heavy, suffocating silence.
"If Logan comes back," Scott said.
Peter looked up. Scott hadn't turned his head. He was still staring out into the dark sky, the faint red glow of his visor reflecting in the glass.
"If I can convince Logan to come back," Scott repeated, his voice barely louder than the hum of the engines, "there might be hope. We could reopen the doors. We might not have a full roster, but we could restart the X-Men." He paused, his jaw tightening. "If the world needs us."
That was the anchor dragging Scott down. If the world needs us.
Peter understood the math. There were roughly twenty million mutants on Earth. Sixteen million of them currently lived in Genosha, protected by Magneto, safe from discrimination, learning to use their powers without having to fight every single day for human approval. The remaining mutants had the Hellfire Club's resources.
And baseline humanity? Humanity had the Avengers. They had the Fantastic Four. They had Iron Man, Captain America, and Spider-Man.
The X-Men had fought bleeding-edge wars for a world that hated and feared them. They had saved that world. And in return, the world had simply moved on and forgotten they existed.
Hank pulled back on the throttle. The Quinjet banked hard to the left, breaking through the thick cloud cover.
Below them, neon lights cut through the dense, humid darkness of Southeast Asia.
They had arrived at Madripoor.
PS: Logan hangs out in Madripoor wearing a white suit and an eye patch and calling himself "Patch", it's a classic piece of Marvel Comics canon! Back in his 1988 solo Wolverine series, Logan spent a lot of time operating in the criminal underworld of Madripoor. His brilliant disguise to hide from his enemies and keep his X-Men identity a secret? Exactly that: slicked-back hair, a sharp white tuxedo, and an eye patch. Somehow, despite his incredibly distinctive height, build, and hair, practically no one in the criminal underworld realized it was the famous X-Man. Comic book logic at its absolute finest!
Let's talk about Madripoor! If you're wondering about this specific location, it's one of the most infamous fictional city-states in Marvel Comics. Located in Southeast Asia, it's essentially the Mos Eisley Cantina of the Marvel Universe. The island is sharply divided by extreme wealth inequality into two main sectors: "Hightown" (where the insanely wealthy, untouchable global criminals operate) and "Lowtown" (the poverty-stricken, hyper-violent underbelly). Because it famously has no extradition treaties with the rest of the world, it's the ultimate safe haven for assassins, smugglers, and mutants looking to fall completely off the grid.
Peter pointing out the biological holes in the "mutant race" concept actually touches on a massive piece of real-world comic history! Stan Lee and Jack Kirby created the X-Men in 1963, right in the middle of the American Civil Rights Movement. For decades, fans and writers have heavily leaned into the allegory, frequently comparing Professor X's dream of peaceful integration to Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., and Magneto's "by any means necessary" mutant liberation to Malcolm X. This fanfic actually brilliantly addresses this real-world meta-context in-universe: Hank McCoy acknowledges that Peter's scientific critique of mutant speciation is totally valid, while Scott explains that Charles and Erik simply adopted the political framework of the 60s and 70s because it was the era they grew up in and the only way they knew how to fight!
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Writing takes time, coffee, and a lot of love.If you'd like to support my work, join me at [email protected]/GoldenGaruda
You'll get early access to over 50 chapters, selection on new series, and the satisfaction of knowing your support directly fuels more stories.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~