SF Chapter 140: Prudence III
Dani removed the box from her head, and his expression turned serious.
"Prudence, you're right about most of your assumptions."
"Of course I want you. Not just because you're hot and beautiful, but because you're the girl I had my first time with."
He went on, "And yes, I would help you. I cherish what we had. I really do. It's one of my most precious memories."
"Besides, Berta has been taking care of me for the past two years - and for Charlie too. I'd do her this favor as well."
"But there's one thing you're wrong about," Dani said, staring at her. "I can say no to you."
"I thought it was funny watching you basically kick the door in and be even more unfiltered than me. But I need to know if you're just messing around, or if you're going to screw with people I care about."
"Because if it's the second, you'll find out how easily I can kick you out," he finished, his tone carrying an unusual edge.
"Whoa, you just got even hotter, Dani," Prudence remarked.
But seeing she got no reaction out of him, she added, "Let me talk to Lexi alone. Just take off this jacket."
He nodded and unzipped the jacket. He was about to remove the zip ties, but she shook her head.
"Leave them. I can talk to her like this," the girl said.
Then she smirked. "Depending on how the conversation goes, we might just pick up right where we left off when I get back - like this. With me tied up," Prudence added provocatively.
[Dani commentary]
"There are three kinds of beautiful girls," Dani remarked.
"The first kind is like Lexi and Mischa - girls who know they're beautiful, but act normal about it."
He went on, "Then there are girls like my niece Alex. She's more the cute type, though - she's still too young."
"They downplay their own cuteness. Like my cousin Monica - she doesn't even seem to realize how gorgeous she is."
"And," he concluded, "there's the hardest type to deal with - Prudence. She knows she's a hot beauty, has zero problem using it, and knows exactly what kind of reaction she's getting."
[Commentary ends]
-------‐-----------‐-----------‐-----------‐-----------‐-----------‐---
Lexi and Prudence stepped aside to talk in a corner.
Lexi stood with her arms crossed. "So, what do you want to talk about?"
"You don't need to be so defensive, girl," Prudence said with a small smile. "I have no desire to take your place."
"And I have a feeling I couldn't, even if I wanted to," she admitted.
"We are not-" Lexi started but was cut off.
"Save it for someone else. I'd bet everything I have that you two are having sex. And like I told you before, I'm not going to tell anyone."
The two of them kept staring at each other, until Prudence started speaking again.
"I was with Dani for less than a month…"
She smirked, "…and most of that time we were in bed."
Lexi stared at her flatly.
"But we still talked a lot. It's not like we could have sex all the time, even if we tried our hardest."
"From what I remember, Dani was a horny, dumb boy," Prudence said, though there was clear affection in her voice. "But also surprisingly perceptive, funny, and easygoing."
"And he really seems like someone who cares a lot about family and friends," she finished.
Lexi gave a small smile. "That he does."
"So, my proposal is that we have a great time together," Prudence offered. "In a few days, I'll have to go back to my boarding school, so I'll only be here for a short time."
Then she looked at Lexi more seriously. "But when I finish high school, I'll come back here. And then I'll fight for real."
She explained, "I didn't lie. He was my first and only boy. One of the reasons is that studying at an all-girls school made me realize I'm bisexual."
"Not as much as with him. But I'm perfectly okay with sleeping with you," Prudence said with a wink.
"You two are so much alike," Lexi scoffed.
Prudence went on, "And Dani is the complete package: good-looking, very funny, easy to talk to, rich, famous… and the fact that he has other beautiful girls around is only a plus for me."
"Oh, oh…" Prudence added, as if remembering something, "I bet he's only gotten better in bed!"
"Maybe a bit bigger, too?" She was fishing for gossip.
Lexi kept a completely deadpan expression.
[Alexandra commentary]
Lexi looked conflicted. "God help me, there's a second Dani here!"
"And of course, the female version of Dani had to be the girl with the most sex appeal I've ever seen!" she complained.
"God forbid she were just a dumb, beautiful bombshell."
Lexi looked to the side. "I won't lie. I was a little affected by her."
[Commentary ends]
But Prudence looked at Lexi more seriously. "So, what would it take for you to let me join the fun?"
"One thing-" Lexi replied, before explaining what she wanted.
-------‐-----------‐-----------‐-----------‐-----------‐-----------‐---
The two of them came back, and Dani asked.
"Prudence, how come you didn't let me have a ménage à trois that time?" he recalled their trip.
"I was young and dumb," she joked. "Besides, you also turned down my ménage."
Lexi stared at both of them, stone-faced. "After your first time, you two asked for a threesome?"
Prudence and Dani looked at each other. "Seems normal," they answered in unison.
Then he clarified, "It wasn't totally serious. I was just trying my luck, while Prudence has always had this personality of testing boundaries."
"I do that sometimes too - testing boundaries. But I'm not like her, kicking the door wide open. Like a panzer invading Poland. I'm more… subtle. Almost imperceptible."
Prudence raised an eyebrow. "Did he get better?" She turned to Lexi. "Because he used to be like a bull in a China shop."
"I didn't know him when he was younger, but my guess is he only got worse," Lexi replied.
[Dani and Lexi commentary]
"We texted Mischa about what happened," Lexi said, sitting beside Dani. "She was like, 'You can do it, Lexi,' cheering me on," she made a face.
"Yep," Dani confirmed. "She treated it like my Christmas gift. 'Go have fun,'" he grinned.
They were friends with benefits, but their relationship was becoming more and more ambiguous.
[Commentary ends]
-----------
If you enjoy it, please leave a Review and Power Stones
You can also support me on patreon and read up to 25 chapters ahead, plus 32 chapters of Modern Family: Francis Jacob Pritchett
[email protected]/Japa_Madri