Chapter 38: The One with the Brooch
The Sunday morning had the specific quality of a day with no fixed agenda, which in Ethan's experience meant it would end up being fuller than any scheduled day. He was at Sheldon and Leonard's building by ten, carrying coffee from the place on Broadway that had gotten his order right the first time and had therefore earned his loyalty, and he found them in the state he usually found them on Sunday mornings — mid-disagreement, but the productive kind.
"The Copenhagen interpretation," Leonard was saying, from his desk, "is not a failure of imagination. It's a pragmatic framework for—"
"It's intellectual surrender dressed as pragmatism," Sheldon said, from his chair, with the calm of someone who had been making this point for several days and had not yet tired of it. "Hello, Ethan."
"Morning," Ethan said, setting the coffees on the table. "You've been on Copenhagen since Thursday."
"Leonard keeps conceding points and then re-raising them," Sheldon said. "It extends the conversation."
"I concede points when the points are valid," Leonard said. "And then I think of new ones."
"That's just arguing," Ethan said.
"That's exactly what I said," Sheldon said.
"I said it differently," Leonard said.
Ethan sat on the edge of the desk and looked at both of them with the expression of a man who had brought coffee into a room that needed it.
"Different topic," he said. "I need both of you to tell me about Paige."
The name had come up the previous evening, obliquely, from Missy.
She'd stopped by Monica's apartment with Mary for a brief visit — Mary had wanted to see the neighborhood, Missy had wanted to see Rachel's fashion buying materials, which she'd described with the specific admiration of someone who understood instinctively what they were looking at — and on the way out, Missy had said to Ethan, quietly, in the hallway: "There's a girl in Sheldon and Leonard's building. Third floor. She keeps running into them and then finding reasons to leave."
"What's her name?" Ethan had said.
"Paige," Missy had said. "Paige Swanson. She's fourteen. She's apparently also at Columbia — some kind of accelerated program. Sheldon doesn't know what to do with her and Leonard thinks she's avoiding them on purpose but can't figure out why."
"Is she?" Ethan had said.
Missy had given him the look she gave when the answer was complicated. "She's fourteen and she's the only girl in every room she's in," Missy had said. "She's not avoiding them. She's figuring out the geometry."
Ethan had thought about this on the walk home.
Now, with the coffees distributed and the Copenhagen argument temporarily tabled, Sheldon and Leonard both had the expression of people receiving a question they'd been sitting with.
"We saw her Tuesday," Leonard said. "Coming back from the library. She was in the hallway outside a room on three where it sounded like people were having some kind of gathering. She saw us, said hello, and then went inside."
"And?" Ethan said.
"And we haven't seen her since," Leonard said. "Which is unusual because she's in the building and we've been running into her regularly since she arrived."
"She's fourteen," Sheldon said, with the flat assessment of someone filing a fact. "She's enrolled in the mathematics accelerated program. Her test scores in pure mathematics are apparently exceptional. She asked me a question about string theory three weeks ago that was — not uninteresting."
"High praise," Ethan said.
"It was a good question," Sheldon said, which for Sheldon was higher.
"She's avoiding you," Ethan said. "But not because of you specifically. She's navigating something."
"What something?" Leonard said.
"She's fourteen," Ethan said. "She's exceptionally good at mathematics. She's in a building full of people who are older than her and operating in a world that wasn't designed with her in mind. She's figuring out which parts of that world she wants to be in and which parts she needs to be careful of." He paused. "The gathering on three — do you know what it was?"
"Some kind of social event," Leonard said. "Older students. She seemed to know someone there."
"She's building a life that isn't just the academic part," Ethan said. "That's healthy. It probably looks like avoidance from outside because it requires some separation from the physics-and-math lane."
Sheldon considered this with the expression he wore when he was processing something about human behavior that didn't fit his existing models. "She's compartmentalizing," he said.
"Yes," Ethan said.
"That's inefficient," Sheldon said.
"It's necessary," Ethan said. "For a fourteen-year-old girl in her situation, having parts of her life that belong only to her is not inefficiency. It's how she stays intact."
Sheldon looked at the middle distance. "I hadn't considered that framing," he said.
"I know," Ethan said. "That's why I'm telling you." He looked at Leonard. "Don't push the contact. Let her set the pace. If she wants to talk about string theory, she'll find Sheldon. If she wants to have a conversation that isn't about string theory, she'll come to you. Let both be possible without requiring either."
Leonard nodded with the expression of someone who had been given instructions that made sense and was going to follow them.
"What if she doesn't come back?" Leonard said. "To either."
"Then she made her choice and you respect it," Ethan said. "But I don't think that's what happens. I think she's testing whether the door stays open." He picked up his coffee. "Leave it open. Don't stand in it."
Sheldon pushed his glasses up with the focused expression of a man applying a new framework to existing data. "That's a more nuanced social model than I typically work with," he said.
"I know," Ethan said.
"I'll attempt it," Sheldon said, which from Sheldon was a significant commitment.
He left them to their Sunday and drove toward the upper west side, and was halfway there when his phone rang.
Ross.
"I need your opinion on something," Ross said.
"Where are you?" Ethan said.
"The jewelry counter at the place on Columbus," Ross said. "The one with the good window display."
Ethan pulled over at the next opportunity and put the car in park. "Tell me."
"It's Rachel's birthday on Friday," Ross said. "May fifth."
"I know," Ethan said.
"I found a brooch," Ross said. "She mentioned once — a long time ago, junior year, she said her grandmother had one she used to wear. Classic setting, good stone. I found one that matches what she described."
Ethan was quiet for a moment.
"Ross," he said.
"It's just a birthday gift," Ross said, in the tone of someone who had said this to himself several times already.
"It's not just a birthday gift," Ethan said. "And you know that."
Ross was quiet.
"Which is fine," Ethan said. "It can be both. A birthday gift that means something more is still a birthday gift. But you need to be honest with yourself about which thing you're doing."
"I just want her to know I was listening," Ross said. "That I remembered."
"She'll know," Ethan said. "That's the point of a gift like that. She'll know you were paying attention." He paused. "The question is whether you're ready for her to know that."
The jewelry counter end of the phone was quiet for a moment with the specific quality of a man standing in front of a glass case making a real decision.
"I'm going to get it," Ross said.
"Okay," Ethan said.
"And I'm going to give it to her," Ross said.
"Okay," Ethan said.
"And when I give it to her," Ross said, slowly, with the careful pace of someone approaching something they've been circling, "I think I might — I want to say something."
Ethan sat in the parked car on Columbus Avenue in the May morning and did not say anything, because this was the moment that needed space rather than commentary.
"Not everything," Ross said. "I know this isn't the moment for everything. But something. Something that's — that tells her I've been here. That I've been paying attention. That she matters to me in a way that's—"
He stopped.
"In a way that's real," Ethan said.
"Yeah," Ross said quietly.
"Then say that," Ethan said. "Not a speech. Just that. The real version, in the fewest words that are honest." He looked at the street outside the window. "You've been carrying this for a year, Ross. It doesn't need to be a big thing. It just needs to be a true thing."
Ross exhaled on the other end of the phone — the exhale of a man who has been building up to something and has finally gotten to the edge of it.
"Friday," he said.
"Friday," Ethan confirmed.
"Will you—" Ross started.
"I'll be there," Ethan said. "Not in the room. But close."
"Okay," Ross said. "Okay."
He bought the brooch. Ethan could tell by the sound of the transaction in the background, the rustling of tissue paper, the specific quiet of a completed purchase.
"It's in a good box," Ross said, when he came back on.
"Good boxes help," Ethan said.
"Ethan," Ross said. "Thank you."
"You did the hard part," Ethan said. "I just stayed on the phone."
He made it to Monica's by noon to find the apartment in the comfortable Sunday configuration — Monica cooking something that didn't need to be cooked yet but that she was cooking anyway because it was Sunday, Chandler on the couch with the legal pad, Rachel with her Madison folder, Phoebe cross-legged on the floor tuning her guitar with the focused precision she brought to the task.
Joey arrived fifteen minutes later with the expression of a man who had done something and was ready to report on it.
"Sandra," Ethan said.
"Sandra," Joey confirmed, sitting down with the settled energy of a man who had resolved something. "We talked. She was completely fine about the study. She made one joke that was actually pretty funny, and then she said we'd have dinner when it was done."
"What was the joke?" Chandler said.
"It was—" Joey paused. "It was about how at least she knows the investment is high quality."
The table processed this.
"She's funny," Rachel said.
"She's genuinely funny," Joey said, with the warmth of a man who had been pleasantly surprised by someone and was still in the warmth of it. "And she said — she said it was decent of me to tell her. That most guys wouldn't."
"Most guys wouldn't," Ethan said.
"I know," Joey said. "But it felt wrong not to." He looked at the table with the slightly wondering expression of a man discovering a thing about himself. "Is that new? Is that me growing?"
"You've always been decent, Joey," Phoebe said. "You just occasionally make choices that obscure it."
"The study didn't obscure it?" Joey said.
"The study was honest work," Phoebe said. "Nothing to be obscured."
Joey considered this. "That's a good way to look at it."
"I have them sometimes," Phoebe said.
Chandler had been writing on and off all afternoon — not continuously, but in the specific rhythm of someone who had found the thing and was learning its pace. He wrote a few lines, looked at them, wrote more, crossed something out, wrote differently.
At four o'clock he put the legal pad face-down on the couch cushion.
Ethan looked at him.
Chandler looked back.
"Are you going to ask?" Chandler said.
"No," Ethan said.
"Good," Chandler said. "Because I'm not ready to say what it is yet."
"I know," Ethan said.
"It might be nothing," Chandler said.
"It's not nothing," Ethan said. "You've been writing for three weeks. Whatever it is, it's not nothing."
Chandler picked up his coffee. "It might be something small," he said.
"Small is fine," Ethan said. "Small is how things start."
Chandler nodded, with the expression of someone accepting a truth that didn't entirely comfort him but that he was choosing to hold anyway.
"The Bermuda thing," Chandler said. "The genome meeting. When you're in that room, are you going to know what to say?"
"I'll have nine months to figure it out," Ethan said.
"But you already know," Chandler said. "You already know what you're going to say. You just have to do the work to make yourself worthy of saying it in that room."
Ethan looked at him. "Yeah," he said. "That's exactly it."
"That's what I'm doing," Chandler said, gesturing at the face-down legal pad. "I know what the thing is. I just have to do the work to be worthy of writing it properly."
"Then you're further along than you think," Ethan said.
Chandler looked at the legal pad. Then he picked it up, turned it back over, and wrote another line.
Monica appeared from the kitchen doorway, leaned against the frame, and looked at the room with the specific expression she wore when she was about to mark something.
"Friday is Rachel's birthday," she said. "I'm making a real dinner. Everybody in, seven o'clock, good clothes."
"What counts as good clothes?" Joey said.
"Better than what you're wearing," Monica said. "That's the standard."
Joey looked at his current outfit. "That's a low bar."
"Joey," Monica said.
"I'll wear the good jacket," Joey said.
"Thank you," Monica said. She looked around the room. "Friday. Seven o'clock. All of us." Her eyes moved briefly to Ethan in the way they moved when she'd registered something she wasn't going to say in the full group.
Ethan gave her the small nod that communicated I know about the brooch, it's in hand, Friday is going to be a thing.
Monica gave him the nod back that communicated good, it's been long enough, it needs to happen.
They had developed, over the course of the year, a fairly complete language.
Next: Friday. Rachel's birthday dinner. The brooch. Ross says the first true thing. Chandler shows one person what's on the legal pad. The Bermuda folder has been read three times and Ethan has started making notes in the margins.
[500 Power Stones → +1 Bonus Chapter]
[10 Reviews → +1 Bonus Chapter]
Enjoyed the chapter? A review helps a lot.
P1treon: Soulforger (20+advance chapters)