Marcus caught him between classes on the third-floor landing, in the tone of someone delivering information they'd been holding since morning.
"Hey — you know that detective who was around last week? She came back Thursday. I saw her leaving Kaplan's office."
Elijah kept walking at the same pace down the stairs. "Which detective."
"Didn't get a name. City credentials, not campus security. She had a folder."
The stairwell opened into the history building's ground floor lobby, where the afternoon light came through the frosted windows and lay across the institutional tile in long pale strips. Two other grad students were at the mailboxes on the left wall. Normal Monday traffic.
"Probably unrelated," Elijah said. It was the third time in two days he'd said that.
Marcus shrugged and peeled off toward the library. Elijah walked out the front door and kept walking until he reached the concrete bench at the quad's east edge, which faced away from the building and had a clean sight line in four directions. He sat.
Montoya had been in Kaplan's office.
Six weeks ago Montoya had been a woman in a leather jacket showing security stills to a campus gate guard. Then she'd been drawing circles on a map in a room he'd never seen. Then she'd been a car parked on Millard Street that he'd broken contact with in under thirty seconds. Then she'd walked through his building with a visitor credential and a description composite. And now she'd been inside a specific room — his advisor's office — with a folder.
He did the math on what that folder contained. Kaplan had been with him in Robinson Hall the night of the Crane attack, guided out without knowing it was him. Kaplan had seen him absorbed in the Pale Rider thesis for six weeks. Kaplan had found the colonial land deed, had personally connected him to primary source material about a figure that Montoya was currently investigating. Kaplan had been enthusiastically, loudly, visibly mentoring the specific grad student whose thesis was about the exact legend Montoya was tracking.
He pressed the heel of his hand against his jaw and thought very carefully about what Kaplan would and wouldn't say.
Kaplan was not naive. She was sharp and warm and impatient and she paid attention. She'd noticed his presence quality in the drama workshop and he'd never taken a single formal class there. She'd tracked him through a fear toxin event and sent a welfare email two days later. She would tell a detective exactly what she observed: a capable, unusual student with genuine instincts for this specific subject matter.
That was not good.
That was, specifically, the thing that Montoya would write in her file with an underline.
He ran the options. The thesis was the most obvious connection, but pulling it now — the week after Kaplan had restructured the entire project around the archive discovery — would look suspicious. He couldn't control what Kaplan had already told her. The only card he had left was behavioral: be unremarkable, be visible, be exactly what a normal grad student looked like from the outside, and give Montoya nothing in his civilian life that would narrow the gap between his face and the figure in the security still.
Three days of that, then the Pale Rider had to move again — five miles from campus, different borough, nothing that confirmed the geographic pattern.
He pulled his phone out and checked the map's blank face — he'd deleted the tactical overlay after the campus visit, but the city was still there, visible, with its neighborhoods and its distances. The Narrows. Six miles southwest. Not Falcone-heavy on the western edge where it met the Gotham River. Bad enough to generate witnesses. Far enough from campus to break the radius.
Tonight, then.
The Narrows' western blocks ran along an old industrial waterfront where the river smell was strongest and the streetlights had the highest per-capita failure rate in the city. He'd checked the statistics in the city maintenance records, which were public, because the kind of person he was studying for a doctoral dissertation in history checked primary sources.
He ran the Pale Rider clean tonight — single persona, no Ghost bleeding through, the cold register fully present. AGI at 15.1 without the dual-active bonus, which was still objectively faster than any human baseline, and MIG at 15.2, and the Dread Presence at a range and intensity he'd calibrated through six weeks of field use.
He'd thought, the first time he activated the persona in a drama classroom, that presence was something you performed for an audience. Patterson had noticed it in the Prospero monologue — had asked where'd you train — and he'd had no good answer because the answer was I haven't, I've been here three weeks and I'm running on a dead man's body and a colonial witch-hunter's myth. The persona wasn't performance anymore. It had settled into him in the way prolonged embodiment settled things: not adopted, absorbed.
He was in the Narrows for forty minutes before the BRE reading changed.
The ambient thread from the paranormal forum was its usual cool blue, the Bowery witnesses their warmth to the north. The Narrows witnesses registered as they should: small, developing, the accumulation of six weeks of consistent presence in the city's mythology. The thread from the specific alley where he was handling a situation — two men blocking a bike path at the river's edge, the kind of low-level intimidation that preceded a mugging — was building toward something.
Then: a new reading.
Not new. Familiar. The five-times multiplier.
He'd read this quality once before — two weeks ago, briefly, from a rooftop three blocks away. He'd filed it and moved on, noting it as something to understand later.
This time it was closer.
[WITNESS — POWERED INDIVIDUAL. CONVICTION TIER: 3. BELIEF MULTIPLIER: ×5.0. DISTANCE: ~220M.]
Pointed ears. Cape. Stillness on the water tower's catwalk that went beyond stillness into deliberate invisibility — the art of a person who understood that the best place to watch from was the place the eye learned to skip over. Elijah had been studying exactly that art for six weeks. He recognized a master of it immediately.
He finished the mugging intervention.
Not because Batman was watching — or not only because. Because the two men were still there and the Pale Rider's job was to finish what it started. He displaced them with Dread Presence at range and the quiet authority of a voice that had been in the cold long enough to stop being warm, and the two men made the correct choice, and Elijah filed the performance grade in the back of his mind — A+, the system confirmed, because being observed by something of actual mythological weight sharpened everything about the work — and walked to the river's edge with his hands at his sides.
[+15 BP. Performance Grade: A+. Witness boost: ×5.0 multiplier active for duration.]
He didn't look at the water tower. He looked at the river.
The BRE tracked the ×5.0 reading through his peripheral awareness — present, steady, not moving. Batman had been watching long enough to see the beginning and end of the intervention. Long enough to build an assessment. The reading stayed at Conviction Tier 3, which meant Batman was not merely looking — he was looking and deciding what he was looking at.
Elijah turned and walked north along the waterfront, not toward the water tower, not away from it. Toward the next block, the next thing the Narrows needed at midnight. The reading shifted as he moved: following, maintaining distance, the specific patience of a predator that wasn't yet sure whether it had found prey or a mirror.
He worked for another twenty minutes.
The reading was still there when he reached the Narrows' north end and turned toward the subway. He didn't acknowledge it. He didn't run, didn't alter his pace, didn't do any of the things that confirmed surveillance. He rode the subway back to campus and walked the last six blocks in the cold and came inside and sat at his desk.
His hands were perfectly steady.
That surprised him. Every other encounter with a real threat — Montoya's car on Millard, the textile mill with Vincent Marlo and two professionals in a room with no other exits, the five-mile run through Robinson Hall — had ended with something physical needing to drain off before he could think. Tonight he'd worked in the presence of the most capable non-powered human being in the DC universe and the only thing his body had to say about it was: good.
The performance had consumed the fear.
He turned his desk lamp on and opened the thesis document. The archive work this week had been producing primary sources faster than he could incorporate them. The revised draft was two-thirds done and already better than anything the original Elijah had written.
Somewhere in Gotham, Batman was filing something new.
He wrote until two AM and went to sleep with both threats still in his mind: the detective below, working up through his department, building the case from the evidence side; the bat above, working down through the observable facts, building the case from the myth side.
They were converging on the same point. His face.
He had, at optimistic estimate, two weeks.
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes.
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!