Chapter 35: The Candidates
[Beacon Hills High School — Thursday, November 3, 2011, 12:20 PM]
Isaac Lahey sat at the end of a cafeteria table with six inches of empty space between himself and the nearest student. The gap wasn't accidental — it was the buffer zone that abuse survivors maintained, the physical distance that said I know what happens when people get close.
Jackson set his tray down across from him.
The reaction was immediate and telling. Isaac's shoulders drew up — a quarter-inch, involuntary, the defensive posture of a body trained to expect impact from unexpected proximity. His left arm stayed close to his body, the movement restricted in a way that spoke of recent injury and ongoing caution. Long sleeves. Warm day. The same diagnostic flag that every teacher, counselor, and classmate at BHHS should have caught and hadn't.
"Jackson Whittemore." Isaac's voice was quiet. Not shy — careful. The calibrated volume of someone who'd learned that being too loud drew attention and attention drew consequences. "Why are you sitting here?"
"Eating lunch." Jackson unpacked his trays — two, stacked, the chimera's standard fuel load. Three sandwiches, two bags of chips, an apple, a banana, two bottles of water. The quantity drew Isaac's eyes for a fraction of a second before he returned to his own tray — half a sandwich and a milk carton.
"You've never sat here before."
"I'm expanding my social circle."
Isaac studied him. The assessment was sharper than the quiet exterior suggested — a kid who'd spent his life reading his father's moods had developed a sophisticated threat-detection system. He was reading Jackson the way Jackson read everyone else: parsing the gap between words and intent.
"Okay," Isaac said. The acceptance was provisional. He returned to his half-sandwich.
Jackson ate. The silence between them was comfortable — not forced, not awkward. Isaac existed in silence the way some people existed in noise: naturally, without the need to fill it. His body language told the story his words didn't. The way he held the sandwich with his right hand because the left arm's range of motion was limited. The way his eyes tracked movement in his peripheral vision — students walking past, trays dropped, doors opening. The constant environmental scan of a person who lived in a space where danger was domestic.
"Your left arm," Jackson said. Quiet. Direct. No preamble.
Isaac went still. Not the flinch-still of the earlier moment — a deeper stillness, the complete cessation of movement that preceded either fight or flight.
"Lacrosse," Isaac said. The lie was practiced. Smooth. The kind of smooth that came from repetition.
"I'm co-captain. I know what lacrosse injuries look like." Jackson took a bite of his sandwich. Chewed. Swallowed. Kept his voice low and his body language neutral — no threat, no intensity, just two people having a conversation in a loud cafeteria. "That's not lacrosse."
Isaac's eyes went flat. The assessment shifted — Jackson had moved from unexpected visitor to potential threat in the time it took to name the lie. Isaac's right hand moved to his bag strap, preparing to stand, preparing to leave, the exit strategy of a boy who'd learned that people who noticed bruises either pitied him (useless) or reported it (worse — his father found out and the next injury was in a less visible location).
"I'm not going to report anything," Jackson said. "I'm not going to pity you. And I'm not going to pretend I didn't see it."
"Then what are you going to do?"
"Offer you something better."
The word better landed differently than help would have. Help implied rescue — someone doing something for Isaac, positioning him as the victim, the recipient. Better implied a change in Isaac's own circumstances, an upgrade driven by Isaac's choice rather than someone else's mercy. The distinction was deliberate. Jackson had chosen it because the show taught him what Isaac Lahey responded to: not charity, but agency.
"I know someone," Jackson said. "Someone who can fix the arm. Who can fix... the situation. If you're interested."
Isaac stared at him for five seconds. The flat expression didn't change, but underneath it — the wolf in Jackson's enhanced perception could taste the change in Isaac's scent chemistry — something shifted. Not hope. Something more fragile. The recognition that someone had looked at him and seen the truth and hadn't flinched from it.
"I'll think about it," Isaac said.
He finished his half-sandwich. Jackson finished his three. They sat in silence for the remaining twelve minutes of lunch, and the six-inch buffer zone between Isaac and the world contracted by two inches.
---
[BHHS Main Hallway — Friday, November 4, 2011, 10:15 AM]
Erica Reyes seized between second and third period.
Jackson was twenty feet down the hall when it started — the particular commotion that preceded a grand mal, the gasps and shuffling as students cleared space around a body they didn't know how to help. By the time he reached the circle, Erica was on the floor: convulsing, eyes rolled back, her books scattered in a radius around her that mapped the violence of the fall.
Her head was six inches from the tile wall.
Jackson dropped to his knees and slid his hand between her skull and the wall. The impact of her seizure drove her head into his palm three times before the convulsions eased — hard enough to bruise, hard enough to hurt, the kind of repetitive trauma that caused concussions when there wasn't a chimera's regenerating hand absorbing the force.
Thirty seconds. The seizure passed. Erica's eyes focused — brown, confused, the disorientation of returning to a body that had just been hijacked by its own neurology. She looked up at Jackson's face, then at his hand behind her head, and the confusion turned to something harder.
"Get off me." Her voice was rough, post-seizure, but the command was clear. Erica Reyes didn't want to be held. She wanted to be vertical.
Jackson removed his hand and offered it instead. She took it — her grip was stronger than expected, the reflex of a person who'd been getting herself off floors since she was twelve — and stood. Her legs wobbled. She locked her knees and the wobble stopped.
"Thanks," she said. The word cost her. Gratitude was currency Erica didn't like spending.
"Your head was going to hit the wall."
"It usually does." She gathered her books. The motion was practiced — she'd done this collection before, multiple times, the familiar geography of scattered belongings after a public episode. Her jaw was set. Not embarrassed — furious. The anger of someone who'd been betrayed by their own body so many times that the betrayal itself was routine, but the anger never was.
Erica Reyes. Epileptic since childhood. In the show, Derek found her after a seizure and offered the bite as a cure. She took it and transformed — not just physically, but socially. The epilepsy gone, replaced by werewolf confidence and a sexuality she'd been suppressing under the weight of medical vulnerability. She became fierce, loyal, and ultimately brave enough to die fighting.
She also died. Captured by the Alpha Pack. Killed in a bank vault alongside Boyd. Derek found their bodies.
This Erica is sixteen and picking up textbooks off a hallway floor while thirty students watch.
"Jackson Whittemore." She had his name without introduction — of course she did. Everyone at BHHS knew Jackson Whittemore. "Since when do you play catch with the seizure girl?"
"Since today." He handed her the last book — Biology, dog-eared, the cover marked with a coffee stain. "Can I walk you to class?"
"I don't need an escort."
"Didn't say you did. I'm going that direction."
Erica looked at him the way Isaac had — the threat assessment, the gap analysis between words and intent. Her version was different: where Isaac assessed for danger, Erica assessed for mockery. She'd been the subject of too much disguised cruelty to accept kindness without checking it for razors.
"Fine," she said. Walked. Jackson walked beside her. She didn't thank him again, and he didn't expect her to.
---
[BHHS Library — Saturday, November 5, 2011, 11:00 AM]
Boyd ate lunch in the library.
Not the cafeteria — the library. The far corner, behind the reference stacks, at a table designed for four and occupied by one. The table had a view of the door and no view of the windows, positioned with the instinctive geometry of someone who wanted to see who was coming without being seen from outside.
Jackson sat across from him. Set a coffee from the gas station on the table between them — black, large, the same brand he'd brought Danny the day everything fractured.
Boyd looked at the coffee. Looked at Jackson. Said nothing.
Twenty minutes passed.
Boyd drank the coffee at the fourteen-minute mark. Jackson ate a protein bar at the seventeen-minute mark. Neither spoke. The library was quiet — Saturday hours, sparse attendance, the particular Sunday-morning-on-Saturday energy of a public space that most teenagers avoided.
At the twenty-minute mark, Boyd spoke.
"You don't have to pretend."
"I'm not pretending."
"Jackson Whittemore doesn't sit in the library with nobody."
"Jackson Whittemore is sitting in the library with Vernon Boyd. That's not nobody."
Boyd's expression didn't change. The assessment was different from Isaac's caution or Erica's suspicion — Boyd assessed with a stillness that was its own form of intelligence, the processing speed of someone who watched instead of spoke and understood more from observation than most people did from conversation.
"What do you want?" Boyd asked.
"To know if you're interested in something."
"What something?"
"I'll tell you when the time is right." Jackson stood. Left the coffee. "I'll be here next Saturday if you want to talk."
Boyd watched him leave. The coffee was half-finished. Boyd's hand rested on the cup with the careful grip of someone who held objects the way other people held connections — tightly, because letting go meant losing.
---
[School Parking Lot — Saturday, November 5, 2011, 11:30 AM]
Jackson sat in the Porsche with his phone against his ear. Derek picked up on the second ring.
"Isaac first," Jackson said. The words came out harder than intended — the image of the circular burn he'd seen through the gap in Isaac's sleeve, the particular scar tissue of a heated object held against skin for three to four seconds, precise and deliberate. "This weekend. Not next week. This weekend."
"Why the urgency?" Derek's voice was low, controlled. The Alpha hearing the strategist's tone shift and recalibrating.
"Because his arm is broken and there are burns under his sleeves and we don't have the luxury of waiting for a convenient time."
Silence on the line. Five seconds. Derek processing — not the strategic assessment of the adult mind, but the visceral response of a man who understood abuse because he'd been manipulated and controlled by someone who was supposed to love him.
"Sunday," Derek said. "Eight PM. My loft."
"I'll be there."
Jackson ended the call. His right hand gripped the steering wheel. The claws had extended — four sharp points pressing into the leather wrap, the wolf's response to anger that the human mind was still processing.
Burns. Circular burns, deliberate, the size of a quarter — cigarette or heated metal, applied with the particular precision of a parent who knows exactly how much pain to inflict without leaving marks that can't be explained. Isaac Lahey is sixteen years old and his body is a map of his father's cruelty, and the show — the goddamn show — treated it as backstory. As motivation. As the before-picture in a transformation montage.
He's not backstory. He's a kid in a hallway with long sleeves and an arm he can't lift above his shoulder.
The claws retracted. Jackson started the Porsche. The starter caught on the first try — inconsistent, unreliable, the mechanical equivalent of a life that only worked some of the time.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0