Chapter 49: THE HISTORY REVEALED
The Bathsheba Sherman file spread across the Perrons' dining table like a map of Hell.
I'd been compiling this information for months—since before I arrived in Harrisville, since before the letters came, since before any of this became real. Now, with the exorcism team arriving tomorrow, it was time to share everything with the people who needed to know.
"Bathsheba Thayer was born in 1812," I began, pointing to the earliest document. "Married Judson Sherman in 1844. They settled on this property that same year."
Ed leaned over the table, his eyes moving across the faded papers. Lorraine sat beside him, her hand pressed flat against the wood, her psychic senses reaching out to touch the history embedded in these artifacts. Father Callahan stood near the window, his expression grave.
"Four years after the marriage, their first child died." I pulled out the newspaper clipping Margaret had shown us. "Week-old infant. The official cause was listed as natural, but the neighbors knew better. They said Bathsheba sacrificed the child—offered it to darkness in exchange for something she wanted."
"What did she want?" Callahan asked.
"We don't know exactly. Power, probably. Immortality of a kind. Whatever the deal was, it bound her to this land forever." I spread more documents across the table. "After the child's death, the accusations started. Witch. Devil-worshipper. Murderer. But no one could prove anything, and Bathsheba was careful. She had three more children, all of whom survived to adulthood. She lived on this property for another forty years."
"Until 1885," Ed said, reading ahead.
"Until 1885. She hanged herself from the tree in the back yard. Left a note cursing every mother who would ever live in her home." I pulled out the copy of that note—the words that had damned generations. "'What was taken from me, I shall take from them. My children for their children. Forever and always.'"
The room was silent. Even the house seemed to be listening.
"The pattern is consistent," I continued. "Every family that's lived here has experienced the same progression. Strange occurrences building to crisis. Mothers targeted for possession. Children endangered. Some families fled before the worst could happen. Others..." I didn't finish the sentence. Didn't need to.
"How many?" Lorraine asked quietly.
"Lorraine's vision in the basement suggested dozens over two centuries. I've confirmed at least eight families who fled the property after experiencing severe supernatural activity. Three families where the mother died under suspicious circumstances. One case in 1921 where—" I stopped. "It's not relevant. What matters is that we're not just saving the Perrons. We're ending two hundred years of murder."
Father Callahan crossed himself. "And the curse mechanism? How does she choose her victims?"
"Mothers. Always mothers. She enters them gradually—the marking, the visions, the episodes of lost time. Each possession attempt strengthens her hold until the victim can't fight back anymore. Then she takes control completely and—" I glanced toward the living room, where Carolyn sat surrounded by her daughters. "She makes them hurt their children. The horror of that act feeds her, strengthens the curse, prepares the ground for the next family."
"We break the cycle tonight?" Ed asked.
"Tomorrow. When Father Gorman arrives with full authorization. Tonight, we hold the line."
Lorraine gasped mid-sentence.
Her body went rigid, her eyes rolling back, her hands clutching the edge of the table hard enough to turn her knuckles white. I'd seen this before—during the Moreau case, during other investigations—the sudden onset of psychic connection that meant something was happening somewhere she cared about.
"Home," she whispered. "Something's wrong at home."
Ed was already moving toward the phone. I followed, my heart pounding with a fear I hadn't expected. The Warren house. Judy. Drew was there watching her, but if Bathsheba could reach that far—
The phone rang before Ed could pick it up.
"Drew." Ed's voice was sharp. "What's happening?"
I couldn't hear Drew's words, but I could see Ed's face go pale. Could see the way his hand tightened on the receiver until the plastic creaked.
"Is she hurt?" A pause. "Thank God. Keep her in your sight. We'll call back in ten minutes."
He hung up. His eyes met mine.
"Judy saw something in her room. A woman who looked dead. It tried to grab her." His voice was steady, but I could hear the terror underneath. "Drew says it couldn't fully manifest. Something stopped it. The apparition retreated before it could touch her."
The wards. My wards, placed around the Warren property months ago during my "personal training" sessions. I'd never told anyone about them—had never expected they'd be tested like this.
[WARD NETWORK (WARREN HOME): TRIGGERED]
[ENTITY ASSAULT: PARTIALLY BLOCKED]
[STATUS: 70% EFFECTIVENESS]
"She's reaching beyond Harrisville," Lorraine said, her voice strained. "Drawing on power I didn't know she had. This isn't just a local haunting anymore. She's expanding her territory."
"Or she's desperate." Father Callahan's face was grim. "She knows we're coming for her tomorrow. This is her counterstrike—attacking the people we love to weaken our resolve."
I moved toward the phone. "I need to talk to Judy."
Ed nodded, stepping aside. I dialed the familiar number and waited through three rings before Drew answered.
"Paul." Drew's voice was ragged. "She's okay. Shaken, but okay. She wants to talk to you."
A moment of shuffling. Then Judy's voice, small but determined.
"Uncle Paul?"
"I'm here, sweetheart. Are you alright?"
"I prayed like you taught me." Her voice wavered but didn't break. "The Saint Michael prayer. The thing in my room—it screamed when I said the words. Then it went away."
Pride swelled in my chest, mixed with fury at whatever had tried to hurt this child.
"You're stronger than any monster, Judy. You proved that tonight."
"I know." A pause. "But I'm still scared."
"Being scared is okay. Being brave while scared—that's what matters. And you were very, very brave."
"Will you stop the bad thing? The one that sent the monster?"
"Yes." I made the word a promise. "Tomorrow. We're going to stop it for good."
"Okay." Her voice was growing sleepy—the crash after adrenaline, the exhaustion of facing something no child should face. "I love you, Uncle Paul."
"I love you too, Judy. Now get some rest. Drew's there. You're safe."
I hung up and stood in silence for a moment, processing what had just happened.
Bathsheba had reached across a hundred miles to attack a seven-year-old girl. Had tried to hurt Judy Warren—Ed and Lorraine's daughter, the closest thing I had to a niece in this world—as a message. As a warning.
[INTERCEPTED ENTITY MESSAGE: "TELL THE FALSE PROPHET: THIS FAMILY FIRST. THEN YOURS."]
The words appeared in my peripheral vision, the system translating whatever demonic communication had accompanied the attack.
This family first. Then yours.
She was promising to destroy the Perrons, then come for the Warrens. To extend her curse beyond Harrisville, to follow us wherever we went, to keep killing until someone stopped her.
"The attack had a message," I said, turning to face the others. "Bathsheba wants us to know—if we fail here, she's coming for our families next."
Ed's jaw tightened. Lorraine's eyes went dark with something that might have been fear or might have been fury.
"Then we don't fail," Ed said. "Simple as that."
Night fell with the weight of inevitability.
I sat with Carolyn in the safe zone, watching the shadows lengthen across the floor. The other family members had found what sleep they could—the children huddled together on mattresses, Roger collapsed in a chair with one hand still reaching toward his wife. But Carolyn couldn't rest. Her eyes flickered between clarity and something else, her hands trembling in her lap, her body fighting a battle no one else could see.
"She shows me things," Carolyn whispered. Her voice was barely audible, the words coming in fragments. "What I'll do to my children. I can see it. The knife in my hand. The way they'll look at me before—" She stopped. Tears streamed down her face.
I took her hand. It was cold, colder than it should be, as if Bathsheba's presence was leeching warmth from her body.
"That future doesn't exist," I said. "I won't let it."
"How can you be sure?" Her eyes met mine—Carolyn's eyes, still Carolyn, fighting to stay herself. "She's so strong. I can feel her inside me, Paul. Pressing against the walls of who I am. Every hour, she gets deeper."
"Tomorrow. Father Gorman is bringing everything we need. The full rite, the full authority, everything the Church can throw at her."
"And if it's not enough?"
I thought about the anchor stone in the basement. About the curse that had been building for two centuries. About Bathsheba's words during our first confrontation—I see what sent you—and the knowledge that she understood something about me that even I didn't fully comprehend.
"It will be enough," I said. "Because it has to be."
Carolyn's grip tightened on my hand. For a moment, she looked almost peaceful.
Then her eyes went wrong.
"The anomaly thinks he can save them," Bathsheba's voice emerged from Carolyn's throat—rougher, older, dripping with contempt. "Such arrogance. Such beautiful, delicious arrogance." A smile that didn't belong on Carolyn's face. "I've been killing mothers for longer than your nation has existed. What makes you think you're different?"
I didn't flinch. Didn't let go of Carolyn's hand.
"Because I am different," I said quietly. "And you know it. That's why you're scared."
The smile faltered. Just for a moment.
Then Carolyn gasped, slumping forward, her body shuddering as control returned to its rightful owner. She looked at me with horror in her eyes.
"She was here. Just now. She was—"
"I know. It's okay. You're back."
"I can't hold her much longer, Paul. She's getting stronger."
"You don't have to hold her much longer. Just until tomorrow. Just until dawn."
I stayed with her through the night, holding her hand, praying silently, watching the clock tick toward morning.
Tomorrow. Everything would be decided tomorrow.
MORE POWER STONES And REVIEWS== MORE CHAPTERS
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes like [ In The Witcher With Avatar Powers,In The Vikings With Deja Vu System,Stranger Things Demogorgon Tamer ...].
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!