Stefan spoke first, his voice carrying the weight of a century spent managing his brother's worst impulses.
"The conditions are reasonable, Damon. We control the opening. We get who we need. We minimize collateral damage." He stepped toward his brother, hands raised in a calming gesture. "This is the only way it works without starting a war."
"I don't care about collateral damage."
"I know. That's why I'm here." Stefan's patience was infinite—practiced over 145 years of cleaning up Damon's messes. "Matt has leverage. He's willing to negotiate. If we walk away from this, he destroys the grimoire and we never open the tomb. Is that what you want?"
Damon's eyes burned with barely contained rage, but beneath the anger, I could see calculation. He wanted Katherine badly enough to swallow his pride. Badly enough to accept terms he hated.
"Fine," he spat. "Your conditions. But I search the entire tomb. Every corner, every vampire, every inch until I find her."
"Agreed."
"And if she's not there?"
The question hung in the frozen air. I knew the answer—Katherine wasn't in the tomb. She'd escaped in 1864, had been free for 145 years while Damon killed and schemed and burned to rescue her from a prison she'd never entered.
But telling him that now would destroy any chance of cooperation. Damon would burn the town rather than accept he'd been played.
"If she's not there," I said carefully, "we reseal the tomb and you have your answer."
Something flickered in Damon's expression—the first hint of doubt I'd ever seen. For a fraction of a second, he looked like a man contemplating the possibility that his entire existence had been built on a lie.
Then the mask returned. "She's there. She has to be there."
"Then we'll find her."
"Additional conditions," I continued, pressing my advantage while Damon was off-balance. "Sheila Bennett approves all spell work. She's the expert on Emily's magic—we need her oversight to make this safe."
"Agreed," Stefan said before Damon could object.
"Alaric Saltzman will be present with weapons. He's experienced with vampire threats."
"The history teacher?" Damon's eyebrows rose. "He's a hunter?"
"He's insurance."
"Agreed," Stefan said again. "Anyone else?"
"Bonnie Bennett participates in the spell with her grandmother. Her powers are developing, and this gives her practical experience under supervision." I glanced at Bonnie, who nodded despite the fear visible in her eyes. She understood—this was how witches learned. Through crisis.
"Fine. Three witches, a hunter, and a blood mage." Damon's voice dripped with contempt. "Quite the party."
"Five days from now." I checked the date mentally—January 11th. "That gives Grams time to prepare the modified spell, Alaric time to gather weapons, and me time to build blood reserves."
"Five days." Damon's impatience was palpable. "Not a day longer."
"Not a day longer."
We stood in the falling snow, four people who trusted each other not at all, bound by an agreement held together with threats and desperation. No handshakes were exchanged—too much bad blood between us for that pretense.
Stefan stepped forward and held out his hand for the grimoire. "I'll keep it safe. Neutral ground."
I hesitated. The grimoire was leverage—giving it up meant trusting Stefan to honor our agreement even if Damon tried to accelerate the timeline. But Stefan had been reliable so far. More reliable than anyone else in his family.
I handed over the book.
Stefan tucked it into his jacket, the ancient leather disappearing into modern fabric. "Five days. The tomb beneath Fell's Church. Midnight."
"Midnight." I turned to Bonnie. "Let's go."
We left the Salvatores standing by their ancestor's violated grave, two brothers united in obsession with a woman who'd been manipulating them both since 1864. The snow covered our footprints as we walked, erasing evidence of our presence.
"Did we just make a deal with the devil?" Bonnie asked, her voice small in the vast silence of the cemetery.
"Yeah." I wrapped my arm around her shoulders—partly for warmth, partly for comfort. "But it's the only deal we had."
"What happens when Damon betrays us?"
"When, not if." I appreciated that she understood. Damon would absolutely try something—his nature didn't allow for genuine cooperation. "We prepare for it. Multiple contingencies. Ways to reseal the tomb if things go wrong. Weapons in case we need to fight."
"And if Katherine isn't in there?"
The question I'd been dreading. Bonnie didn't know about my meta-knowledge, didn't understand how certain I was that the tomb held nothing but starving vampires and bitter disappointment.
"If she's not there, Damon will lose his mind. He'll need something to destroy, someone to blame." I met her eyes in the darkness. "We make sure he doesn't burn the town to do it."
"How?"
"I'm still working on that part."
We walked in silence for a while, the snow continuing to fall, the night deepening around us. My blood sense extended outward automatically now—a habit I'd developed over months of training. I felt the Salvatore brothers still in the cemetery, felt distant heartbeats of sleeping townspeople, felt the cold void where the tomb waited beneath the church.
"Matt?" Bonnie's voice pulled me back to the present.
"Yeah?"
"Thank you. For including me in the spell. Grams has been training me for months, but she's always so protective. She never lets me do anything real." She paused. "This feels real."
"It is real. And it's dangerous. And you might hate me for putting you in this position before it's over."
"I don't think I will." She smiled—tired, scared, but genuine. "I think this is what I'm supposed to do. What all the training was for."
I walked her home and waited until she was safely inside before heading to my trailer. The walk gave me time to think, to plan, to worry about everything that could go wrong in five days.
Damon would betray us—that was certain. The question was how and when.
Anna was still out there, still planning her own approach to freeing Pearl. I hadn't told her about our agreement with the Salvatores. Would she cooperate or complicate things?
Grams would need to modify Emily's spell substantially. That required power, concentration, and trust in abilities that might not be up to the task.
And Katherine. Katherine wasn't in the tomb. When Damon discovered that truth, when 145 years of obsession crumbled to dust, the fallout would be catastrophic.
I set my alarm for five days from now. January 16th. Midnight at the tomb.
The countdown had begun.
I lay in bed staring at the ceiling, running through scenarios, planning contingencies, preparing for a dozen different ways the tomb opening could go wrong. My blood sense stayed active, feeling the rhythm of the sleeping town around me, waiting for cold presences that might approach.
No vampires came that night.
But they would. In five days, the tomb would open, and everything I'd built—the alliances, the preparations, the careful balance of power—would be tested.
I thought about Caroline, asleep in her bed with no idea what I was planning. About Elena, searching for a birth mother who'd become a vampire. About Vicki, buried in the ground because I hadn't been strong enough to save her.
Not this time. This time, I'm ready.
The certainty felt hollow at 3 AM, alone in my trailer, surrounded by evidence of the war I was about to fight. But it was all I had.
Certainty and determination and a countdown to midnight.
Five days until the tomb.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0