Alaric's apartment was dark except for the lamp on his desk, casting shadows that made the room feel smaller than it was. He didn't offer me a drink this time. Didn't make small talk. Just stood by the window with his arms crossed, waiting for me to explain why I'd invoked his dead wife's name.
"Elena Gilbert is adopted," I said, deciding not to soften the blow. There was no gentle way to say it. "Her birth mother's name was Isobel Flemming."
The silence stretched long enough that I thought he might not have heard me. Then he moved—slowly, deliberately—to the chair behind his desk and sat down heavily, like his legs had stopped working.
"Isobel had a daughter?"
"Before you met her. She gave Elena up at birth. The Gilberts adopted her, raised her as their own." I stayed by the door, giving him space to process. "Elena found out recently. She's been researching, trying to understand what happened to her birth mother."
Alaric's face cycled through emotions too fast to track—shock, denial, pain, confusion, and finally something that looked like the beginning of grief. "She never told me. We were married for two years, and she never mentioned having a child."
"Would you have treated her differently if you'd known?"
"I don't know. Maybe. I don't know." He rubbed his face with both hands. "This doesn't make sense. Isobel was obsessed with her research, yes, but she was... I thought I knew her. I thought I understood who she was."
"What was she researching?"
"Vampires." The word came out bitter. "Folklore, supposedly. Historical accounts of creatures that drained blood. She spent hours in archives, tracking down obscure journals, corresponding with researchers all over the world. I thought it was academic interest. I thought—" He stopped, breathed. "I thought she was just a scholar who liked scary stories."
"She wasn't."
"No." Alaric reached for the bourbon bottle he kept on his desk. This time, he poured two glasses without asking. "About a year before she disappeared, she started getting secretive. Late nights. Locked files. Phone calls she'd take in the other room. I thought she was having an affair."
I took the glass he offered but didn't drink. "Was she?"
"I don't know what she was doing. But the night she disappeared, I came home and found this." He pulled open a drawer and produced a photograph—a woman with dark hair and intelligent eyes, smiling at the camera with an expression that made her look simultaneously warm and unknowable. "And a note that said: 'I'm sorry. Don't look for me.'"
"But you looked anyway."
"I spent a year following dead ends. Then I got a tip—anonymous email—that the man who killed her was in Mystic Falls. I came here expecting to find a monster. Instead, I found..." He gestured vaguely at the room, at me, at everything. "This."
"The tip was about Damon, wasn't it?"
Alaric nodded slowly. "He was seen with her the week before she disappeared. They were photographed together at a conference in North Carolina. I thought he'd killed her. Drained her. Left her body somewhere I'd never find."
"What if he didn't kill her?"
"What do you mean?"
I chose my next words very carefully. "Isobel was researching vampires. Actively seeking them out. What if she found one and decided she didn't want to be human anymore?"
The implication landed like a bomb. Alaric's face went pale.
"You're saying my wife became a vampire. Voluntarily."
"I'm saying it's possible. She left a note asking you not to look for her. If she'd been kidnapped or killed, she wouldn't have had time to write anything. She planned her disappearance. She chose to leave."
"That's..." He stopped, unable to finish the sentence. Unable to deny the logic.
We sat in silence while he processed. The bourbon remained untouched on the desk between us. Outside, a car passed, headlights briefly illuminating the window before darkness returned.
"Elena doesn't know any of this," I said finally. "She thinks her birth mother was just a woman who gave her up for adoption, lived a normal life, and then mysteriously disappeared. She doesn't know about the vampire research. She doesn't know about you."
"And you want to keep it that way?"
"For now. Until we understand more." I met his eyes. "If Isobel is alive—if she's out there, a vampire, doing whatever vampires do—then she's connected to Elena. Which means she's connected to the doppelganger line. Which means she's connected to Katherine."
Alaric's hunter instincts kicked in despite his personal turmoil. "Everything circles back to Katherine."
"Everything circles back to the doppelgangers. Elena looks exactly like Katherine. Isobel researched vampires obsessively before becoming one. There's a pattern here, but I don't understand it yet."
"What do you want to do?"
"I want to find Isobel. I want to understand why she did what she did. And I want to keep Elena protected until we know whether her birth mother is a friend or a threat."
"And if she's a threat?"
The question hung between us, heavy with implications.
"Then we deal with her the same way we'd deal with any vampire threat." I hated saying it, but it was true. "Isobel gave up her humanity when she turned. If she's working against us, her history with Elena—her history with you—won't change what needs to be done."
Alaric was quiet for a long time. When he finally spoke, his voice was rougher than I'd ever heard it.
"I came to Mystic Falls to avenge my wife. Now I find out she might have chosen this life, abandoned me on purpose, and has a daughter I never knew about who happens to be dating a vampire." He laughed bitterly. "My life was simpler when I just thought she was dead."
"Simpler isn't better."
"You said that before." He picked up his bourbon glass and finally drank. "You keep saying that."
"Because I keep needing to hear it."
We talked for another hour, working through the implications. If Isobel was alive and a vampire, where had she been for two years? Who turned her, and why? What was her connection to Katherine beyond the obvious doppelganger angle? The questions multiplied faster than we could answer them.
By the time I left, we'd agreed on a plan: Alaric would dig deeper into Isobel's research, looking for clues about what she'd discovered before her transformation. I would continue monitoring Elena, protecting her from threats she didn't know existed. Neither of us would reveal the connection until we understood more.
"Matt." Alaric's voice stopped me at the door. "Thank you. For telling me."
"You deserved to know."
"A lot of people would have kept that information to themselves. Used it as leverage."
"I'm not trying to build leverage. I'm trying to build an alliance." I turned back to face him. "We're stronger together than apart. That's been true since the first day we met. It's still true now."
He nodded slowly, something like respect in his eyes. "Get home safe. The roads are icy."
"I will."
I drove home through the cold January night, my mind spinning with connections and implications. Isobel and Elena. Alaric and vampires. Katherine and doppelgangers. The tomb and the comet and the Bennett witches.
Every thread led somewhere. Every answer spawned new questions. The web of supernatural politics in Mystic Falls grew more tangled by the day.
But somewhere in that tangle was the truth. About what was coming. About who I could trust. About how to survive long enough to see the end.
Alaric's bourbon still burned in my throat as I pulled into my driveway. Behind me, in a drawer in his apartment, a photograph of Isobel Flemming smiled her unknowable smile.
Somewhere out there, Elena's birth mother walked the night. A vampire with secrets. A player in a game I didn't fully understand.
And eventually, she would come home.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0