The fog came from nowhere.
One moment the cemetery was clear—moonlight illuminating rows of headstones, the old church ruins visible in the distance. The next, white mist rolled between the graves like something alive, swallowing the light, reducing visibility to a few feet in any direction.
Atmospheric manipulation. Damon's showing off.
I moved through the fog with my senses straining, following the faint sound of Vicki's footsteps ahead. The blood bag in my jacket pulsed against my awareness, ready to answer my call.
The church ruins emerged from the mist like a wound in the darkness. And there, standing among the collapsed stones, Damon Salvatore waited.
Vicki stood beside him, docile, her expression blank. The compulsion had her completely—she didn't even look at me when I stepped into the clearing.
"The protective brother." Damon's smile was all teeth. "I wondered when you'd show up."
"Let her go."
"Oh, I will. Eventually." He ran a finger along Vicki's cheek, and she didn't flinch. "But first, we need to talk about your little hobby. Did you really think I wouldn't notice the vervain network you've been building? The sauce at the Grill, the bracelets on Caroline's wrist, the tea your sister's been drinking?"
He knows everything.
"I was wondering," Damon continued, circling Vicki like a shark, "who in this pathetic town had the audacity to interfere with my plans. A Council member, I thought. Maybe the Sheriff. Never in a century would I have guessed it was the busboy."
"Vicki has nothing to do with this. Let her go."
"See, that's where you're wrong." His eyes gleamed red in the darkness. "Your sister is exactly what this is about. You took away my blonde plaything, so I'm taking something of yours. Fair's fair."
He moved.
Vampire speed—faster than human perception, faster than any reaction time I could muster. His hand shot toward my throat, and I had less than a heartbeat to respond.
The blood bag exploded.
I didn't think—I acted. Months of training condensed into a single instinct. The blood shaped itself into a shield, a flat disc of crimson that interposed between Damon's fingers and my neck.
His hand struck the barrier and slowed. Not stopped—nothing human could stop a vampire—but slowed enough that I could throw myself sideways, rolling across grass and grave dirt.
Damon stared at his hand like it had betrayed him. Then he looked at me, and his expression shifted from predatory to... interested.
"Well, well." His voice was almost delighted. "The busboy has tricks."
I scrambled to my feet, forming stakes from the remaining blood. Three of them, hardened to maximum density, orbiting my body like satellites.
"What ARE you?" Damon tilted his head. "Not a witch—I'd smell the magic. Not a vampire—your heart's pounding like a rabbit's. Something new?"
I threw the first stake.
He dodged it easily, the projectile embedding itself in a tree behind him. The second stake he caught—actually caught—between two fingers, examining it with academic curiosity.
"Interesting technique." He dropped the stake. "But let me show you the difference between tricks and power."
He crossed the distance between us in a blur. My third stake launched automatically, aiming for his heart, and he swatted it aside like a gnat. His hand closed around my throat.
"You're creative," he said, lifting me off the ground. "I'll give you that. But creativity doesn't beat a century of experience. Any last words before I—"
Headlights swept across the cemetery.
Damon's head snapped toward the light, his grip loosening fractionally. A car was approaching—Stefan's Porsche, engine roaring as it tore through the cemetery gates.
"Always with the heroic timing." Damon dropped me and grabbed Vicki. "We'll continue this conversation later, Matt Donovan. You've made things interesting."
He vanished into the fog, Vicki with him, leaving nothing but disturbed mist and the echo of his laughter.
Stefan's car skidded to a stop ten feet away. The door flew open, and he emerged with vampire speed, fangs extended, searching for threats.
"Damon was here." I coughed, rubbing my throat. "He took my sister."
Stefan's eyes found me—and then found the blood still hovering around my hands, the remnants of my constructs not yet dissolved.
His expression shifted from concern to something colder. More ancient.
"What ARE you?"
I let the blood splash to the ground, suddenly exhausted. My legs gave out, and I sat down hard on the nearest headstone.
"That's a really long story."
"I have time." Stefan didn't move closer, didn't offer help. He watched me like I was a new species of threat. "You're not a witch. You're not a vampire. I've been alive for 163 years and I've never seen anything like that."
"Join the club." I breathed until my hands stopped shaking. "I woke up with these abilities. I don't know where they came from or what they mean. But right now, none of that matters. Damon has my sister. Are you going to help me get her back, or are you going to keep asking questions?"
Stefan considered me for a long moment.
"He'll take her to the boarding house," he said finally. "It's where he brings his... projects."
"Then that's where we're going."
I stood, legs unsteady, and headed for my truck. Behind me, I heard Stefan following.
The alliance was uneasy. The stakes were impossible.
But Vicki was alive—for now—and I wasn't giving up until she was home.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0