Seeing that all the girls wanted to hear her embarrassing story — the only failure in her long list of conquests, excluding Lala and the others — Haruka could only stay silent. The girls seemed very interested in hearing Ami's story, and trying to avoid it would only provoke everyone's anger, so she simply couldn't refuse.
"Fine, but first I want to know everyone's names. I need to know how to address all of you," Ami nodded.
She didn't mind telling her story, but she should at least know the names of the girls first so she could address them properly from now on if they had any questions or anything like that.
"Alright, my name is Momo, Lala's little sister. Nice to meet you," Momo said.
One by one, the girls introduced themselves. After Momo came Lala, followed by Nana, Kari, Yami, Dita, Haruna, Nemesis, and finally Run.
"Mikan and Mikado are also part of the group. Mikan is Kari's classmate and Mikado is the school nurse, but they were busy today and couldn't come," Lala said.
"Nice to meet all of you. Now let's sit down and enjoy the story," Ami said.
The introductions were quick, so the story didn't take long to begin.
The girls quickly sat on the sofa with Ami in the center, and those who didn't fit on the sofa sat on the floor, forming a semicircle in front of it.
"Well, it all started when…" Ami began.
Let's start from the beginning. Ami was, as commonly known, the idol of her school. Ami wasn't the smartest nor the best at sports, but her beauty and lively personality attracted boys like bees to honey, receiving dozens of confessions every day.
Ami attended a different school from Haruka, so they had never met before and neither knew about the other, at least until that fateful day.
The old Haruka was a playboy who not only went around nearby towns and cities looking for beautiful girls, but also frequently wandered through different schools in Tokyo searching for beautiful women with her childhood friend, Souta.
Haruka liked all types: lolis, middle school students, high school students, college students, and even beautiful milfs. Whether they had boyfriends or not didn't matter to them. As long as the girl met their beauty standards, they would definitely go after her. They always used the same modus operandi. With their wealth and influence, Haruka, with just one photo, would send people to investigate everything about the girl — full name, address, age, everything — and then they would stage "casual" encounters to use in their favor. Of course, this was just one of their many strategies. Sometimes there was no need to investigate the girl; sometimes she fell easily and there was no need to chase her for days or investigate her using their contacts. Sometimes it was as simple as pretending to be new in Tokyo and needing someone to give them a little tour of the area. In short, they used a large number of methods and tricks that will not be mentioned.
{Note: I could use AI, but I prefer not to because listing them wouldn't add anything to the story. By the way. Does the last method I mentioned ring any bells?}
But back to the topic, during one of their many visits to other schools, Haruka caught sight of Ami and they tried to conquer her immediately. Obviously they first approached her, trying to become her friend, but Souta was mercilessly rejected, all because Ami quickly guessed Souta's intentions. After all, many men had used exactly the same trick as Souta to hit on her only to be cruelly rejected and ignored. But with Haruka it was different. They connected immediately and didn't take long to become friends.
At first it was just friendship, but little by little Haruka started getting closer to her and one day confessed. At first Ami didn't want to accept, but then she remembered something. She had never been interested in romance. There had never been a man who caught her attention, not at her school, not outside it, not even on television. Could it be that the reason was simply that she wasn't interested in men but in women? It was possible, but Ami still hesitated to accept, so she told Haruka she needed to think about it carefully, to which Haruka immediately agreed. After all, it wasn't the first time she had been in that situation. Many girls had doubted only to eventually fall into her grasp.
A few days passed and after thinking about it, Ami decided to accept Haruka's confession. The reason was that she wanted to check if she really liked women. Besides, even if she didn't, at least she could say she had tried it. Trying new things, as long as they weren't harmful, was never a bad idea. That's why she accepted.
Haruka was delighted. She had once again conquered another beautiful girl, and this was one of the most beautiful she had ever conquered.
Time passed and during that time many things happened. Ami found out that Haruka had a harem, but she didn't mind too much. That way she could also experience what it was like to be in a harem. It was simply new experiences. Surprisingly, being in a harem didn't bother her, but… she couldn't say the same about the sex. Yes, like any couple they had sex, a lot of sex, and yes, it felt good, but Ami noticed something was missing. That pleasure… simply wasn't enough. But everything changed a year later.
That day marked one year of her relationship with Haruka, but they couldn't celebrate it today because Haruka was having a good time with two other girls. Since she didn't really like threesomes and even less foursomes, she simply refused and let Haruka have fun alone. Since she was bored and had nothing to do, she started browsing the internet. Thinking that Haruka was having fun while she wasn't made her feel unsatisfied, so she decided to try watching porn for the first time and masturbate. As I just mentioned, it was the first time she had ever watched porn in her life, but since finding porn on the internet was extremely easy, she simply entered a random site and clicked on a video without thinking. At first she wanted to close it and put on another, but when the video started playing, she froze completely. What she saw left her speechless and her hand simply wouldn't move.
What she saw in the video… a cock. A huge cock. In the video, a man with a huge cock was fucking a woman who was moaning uncontrollably. That scene sent a kind of electric current through her entire body and… she started masturbating. But it wasn't a normal masturbation session. It was as if she had completely lost control. She started masturbating non-stop, cumming several times, feeling a pleasure she had never felt with Haruka. Video after video, and in all of them muscular men with huge cocks fucked a woman or several at the same time. Creampies, SM, facials — Ami spent the entire day watching videos like that and masturbating to all of them until she fell asleep from exhaustion. Yes, she masturbated until she passed out. From that moment everything changed for her and she understood what that something was that she had been missing when she had sex with Haruka. She was missing a cock, a huge cock! Her lack of interest in romance had simply made her misinterpret her own tastes.
The next day, Ami decided to break up with Haruka. Now that she definitely knew what she had been missing, she couldn't continue in a lesbian relationship, especially knowing she wasn't a lesbian. She had simply confused her tastes.
Of course Haruka tried to stop her, but it was in vain. Ami didn't regret her decision and broke up with Haruka. That was her first and only failure, and the worst part was that to prevent Souta from making fun of her, she lied and said she was the one who left Ami and not the other way around, all to avoid her childhood friend's mockery.
"That was it," Ami said.
Ami finished telling the story after a long while.
"Wasn't it a low blow to lie just to prevent your friend from laughing at you?" Nana asked with a frown.
"Ahem, back then our competition was… very heated and we were very proud and competitive, so if he had found out… he would have made fun of me for months," Haruka replied.
"But isn't that what you tried to do a few days ago when you asked us to pretend to be part of your harem to trick your friend?" Momo asked.
"Ugg… I'm sorry," Haruka said.
It was true that she had asked them, but now Haruka had changed and there was no competition between her and Souta. She just didn't want him, who didn't know about her big change, to find out.
"… Pretend? Can someone explain what you mean by that?" Ami asked curiously.
Now it was her turn to ask questions. Why had she asked those girls to pretend to be part of her harem? And why did this Haruka seem so different from the one she remembered? She seemed a bit shy and that aura full of pride she used to have… had disappeared without a trace. Ami was full of doubts, doubts that would be resolved little by little.
"I'll explain it to you. You see…" Lala said.
A story we all already know followed…
"I see. Souta-kun has no idea about your surprising change and you want to pretend you haven't changed so he doesn't make fun of you… then I'll give you a secret weapon so that doesn't happen," Ami said.
Putting aside their previous relationship, they were now friends and it seemed Haruka had changed, so she would give her a wildcard that would help her in case things with Akira didn't work out.
"What do you mean?" Haruka asked, not understanding.
All the girls also expressed curiosity about Ami's words.
"You see, to give you context I'll have to start by saying my ideal type of man," Ami said.
"And what does that do for us?" Haruka asked.
"It's actually more important than you think and it has to do with that secret weapon I mentioned. Just listen to me, you'll see it's a good idea," Ami replied.
The girls nodded. Although they already had Akira's plan, having an extra wildcard was also good. Of course none of them believed it would be necessary since Akira would take care of her problem, but listening wouldn't hurt.
Seeing everyone attentive, focused, and curious about what she was going to say, Ami continued.
"When I broke up with Haruka and understood what my sexual orientation was and that I was attracted to men, I started reflecting on the type of men I like, and that's when I realized why none of the boys in my class interested me," Ami said.
"Why?" Lala asked curiously.
"Because my tastes are different. I like tall, muscular, strong, handsome men with good personalities and, above all, with a huge cock," Ami answered.
Faced with Ami's frankness, all the girls were left speechless, simply not knowing what to say.