Cherreads

Chapter 4 - The Child Who Never Grew Up

Jonah could not move.

For several seconds, he simply stared at Eleanor, waiting for her to take back what she had said. He wanted her to laugh, to explain that she had made a mistake, to tell him that the photograph was misleading and that the little girl behind the door belonged to someone else.

But Eleanor did none of those things.

She only stood there, looking at him with the exhausted expression of someone who had carried a terrible secret for far too long.

"Say that again," Jonah whispered.

"Clara was your daughter."

"And Olivia?"

"Her mother."

Jonah shook his head.

"No. That's impossible."

"Why?"

"Because I would remember having a child."

Eleanor looked at him sadly.

"Would you?"

The question struck him harder than he expected.

He looked toward the stone wall. The door had disappeared, leaving nothing but old stones covered with moss. Yet he could still smell magnolia blossoms.

"How old was she?" he asked.

"Eight."

"And you said she disappeared in 1998?"

"Yes."

"Then how can she still look like that?"

Eleanor lowered her eyes.

"Because Clara never grew older."

Jonah felt a chill.

"What do you mean?"

"I mean that the little girl you saw today was the same age as she was on the night she disappeared. She has never grown up. Not in the way we understand growing up."

"Where is she?"

Eleanor looked toward the river.

"Somewhere between a memory and a place that should not exist."

Jonah stepped closer.

"You're speaking in riddles again."

"I know. But I have spent twenty-eight years trying to find words for something that has no proper name."

She paused.

"Come with me. There is something you need to see."

Eleanor led him away from the river and toward a narrow street behind the park. They walked in silence, passing old houses with faded facades and small gardens. Jonah had never noticed the street before, although he was certain he had walked through this part of the town many times.

At the end stood a modest house with a green wooden gate.

Eleanor took a key from her handbag.

"This is where I live."

Jonah looked at the building.

"Have you lived here for a long time?"

"Since 1998."

She opened the gate.

The garden was carefully maintained. Small white flowers grew beside the pathway, and an old wooden bench stood beneath a pear tree. On the windowsill, Jonah noticed a row of tiny porcelain animals.

One of them was a rabbit.

Something about it made his chest tighten.

He followed Eleanor inside.

The house smelled of old books, tea, and furniture polish. There were photographs on the walls, but most of them had been turned toward the wall or covered with pieces of cloth.

Jonah stopped in the hallway.

"Why are the photographs covered?"

Eleanor took off her coat.

"Because sometimes looking at the past is more painful than remembering it."

She led him into a small room.

It was clearly a child's bedroom.

A narrow bed stood against the wall. Beside it was a wooden desk, a bookshelf, and a little wardrobe painted white. A yellow dress hung from a hook on the back of the door.

Jonah stared at it.

The dress was identical to the one Clara had been wearing behind the stone door.

He approached it slowly.

His fingers touched the fabric.

And something happened.

A sudden warmth spread through his hand.

He heard laughter.

A little girl was running across the room, holding a wooden rabbit.

"Catch me, Daddy!"

Jonah turned instinctively.

There was nobody there.

But he could almost feel the small hand slipping out of his own.

He closed his eyes.

Another image appeared.

He was sitting on the floor, building a wooden house from coloured blocks. A little girl was beside him, carefully placing a red roof on top.

"That's not right," she said.

"Why not?"

"Because houses need windows."

"Why?"

"So people can look outside."

"And what if they don't want to look outside?"

The little girl thought for a moment.

"Then they can look at the stars."

Jonah opened his eyes.

A tear had escaped and was moving down his cheek.

Eleanor watched him.

"You remember something?"

He nodded slowly.

"I think so."

He looked at the wooden desk.

There was a small drawing attached to its side.

Three figures stood beneath a large tree. A man, a woman, and a little girl. Above them, written in uneven letters, were the words:

MY FAMILY FOREVER.

Jonah touched the paper.

The handwriting was childish, but the letters were familiar.

At the bottom of the drawing was a date.

May 17, 1998.

He looked at Eleanor.

"Why is everything connected to tomorrow?"

Eleanor sat on the edge of the bed.

"Because tomorrow was supposed to be the happiest day of your lives."

"What was supposed to happen?"

"You and Olivia were going to get married."

Jonah turned away.

The information seemed too large to absorb. A daughter. A wedding. A life he could not remember.

"Why didn't Olivia tell me?"

"Because she was afraid you would remember everything at once."

"Everything about what?"

Eleanor looked toward the window.

"About the night Clara disappeared."

For a long time, neither of them spoke.

Then Eleanor opened a drawer in the little desk and removed a small notebook.

Its cover was faded pink, with a silver star attached to the corner.

"Clara wrote in this every day," she said.

Jonah took it carefully.

"Can I read it?"

"That's why I brought you here."

He opened the first page.

The writing was large and uneven.

My name is Clara. I am eight years old. I have a mother called Olivia and a father called Jonah. My father says I ask too many questions, but I think questions are important because they help us find things.

Jonah smiled faintly.

He turned the page.

Today Daddy showed me the river. He said that water remembers everything that touches it. I asked him if it remembers people too. He said maybe it remembers their voices.

Another page.

I heard somebody calling me yesterday. Daddy says it was probably the wind. But I know it wasn't the wind because it said my name.

Jonah stopped.

He read the sentence again.

"She heard the same voice?"

Eleanor nodded.

"Yes."

"Did you know?"

"Not at first."

He turned another page.

There is a door under the bridge. Daddy says I must never go near it. But I saw a little girl standing behind it. She looked exactly like me.

Jonah felt his fingers grow cold.

He continued reading.

She said she was lonely. She said she wanted to play with me. I asked her where her mother was. She said she didn't have one.

The next page contained only one sentence.

I think the little girl is waiting for me.

Jonah closed the notebook.

"What happened after she wrote this?"

Eleanor's face tightened.

"Three days later, she disappeared."

"Was it the night of May seventeenth?"

"No. It was the night before your wedding."

Jonah stared at her.

"Then why does the drawing have that date?"

"Because Clara believed the next day would be the beginning of a new life for all three of you."

Eleanor stood and walked toward the window.

"But she never got to see it."

Jonah sat quietly, holding the notebook.

He wanted to ask a thousand questions, but one seemed more important than all the others.

"Why did you say you were her mother?"

Eleanor turned.

"Because I raised her for the first eight years of her life."

"But you just told me she was Olivia's daughter."

"She was. Olivia was her biological mother. But after Clara was born, Olivia became seriously ill. She couldn't take care of her for a while. I was her aunt."

Jonah looked at her.

"Her aunt?"

Eleanor nodded.

"My younger sister was Olivia's mother. When she died, I became the person who helped Olivia raise Clara. I was there almost every day. Clara called me Aunt Eleanor, but sometimes, when she was frightened, she called me Mum."

"Why didn't you tell me that before?"

"Because you were asking about the door, not about my family."

Jonah looked down at the notebook.

"So you weren't lying when you said you were there when Clara disappeared."

"No."

"And you helped me forget?"

Eleanor did not answer immediately.

Then she nodded.

"Yes."

"How?"

She walked back toward him.

"That night, after Clara disappeared, you refused to leave the river. You kept calling her name. Olivia was barely conscious from shock. I tried to bring you home, but you wouldn't listen."

Jonah's breathing became uneven.

"What did I do?"

"You opened the door."

He stared at her.

"What happened?"

"You went through it."

Eleanor's voice trembled.

"For almost an hour, we could hear you speaking to someone on the other side. Sometimes you laughed. Sometimes you cried. And sometimes you begged someone to let you go."

"Who was I speaking to?"

"Clara."

Jonah covered his mouth.

Eleanor continued.

"When you finally came back, you were holding her little silver pendant. But Clara wasn't with you."

"Why didn't you go after her?"

"Because the door closed."

"Then open it again!"

"I tried."

"Try harder!"

Eleanor's eyes filled with tears.

"I spent years trying, Jonah. I tried everything I could think of. But the door never opened for me."

Jonah stood up.

"What happened to me afterward?"

"You collapsed. You had a terrible fever. For days, you barely spoke. When you finally woke up, you didn't recognize Olivia. You didn't recognize me. You didn't remember Clara."

"And then?"

"Then you told us something."

Eleanor swallowed.

"You said there was another version of you behind the door. Someone who had made a promise to stay there forever."

Jonah felt a cold pressure behind his eyes.

"What promise?"

Eleanor looked directly at him.

"You promised Clara you would come back for her."

The room seemed to become smaller.

Jonah walked toward the window and looked outside. The garden was quiet. A bird landed on the pear tree, shook its wings, and flew away.

Everything looked normal.

But nothing was normal anymore.

He turned back to Eleanor.

"Why did I leave Olivia?"

"You didn't leave her willingly."

"What does that mean?"

"After you recovered, you became convinced that staying near Olivia would put her in danger. You believed the door was connected to your family, and that it would keep opening until it had taken everyone you loved."

"So I asked to forget?"

"You begged us to help you."

Jonah sat down again.

"And Olivia agreed?"

Eleanor nodded.

"She didn't want to. But she loved you enough to let you go."

"How did I end up here, living a completely different life?"

"That is something you should ask Olivia."

"She knows?"

"She knows more than I do."

Jonah looked at the notebook.

He had spent his entire life believing that the past was something fixed. Something that happened and could not be changed.

But now he was beginning to understand that his past had not disappeared.

It had been waiting.

And perhaps it had never stopped watching him.

A quiet knock came from the front door.

Eleanor looked toward the hallway.

"Who is it?" Jonah asked.

She did not answer.

The knock came again.

Three slow knocks.

Then a woman's voice spoke from outside.

"Eleanor? I know he's there."

Jonah recognized the voice immediately.

Olivia.

Eleanor closed the notebook and placed it on the desk.

"Don't tell her what you read."

Jonah frowned.

"Why?"

"Because she isn't ready."

"She's the mother of the child we're talking about. She has a right to know what I remember."

Eleanor looked at him with an expression that was almost pleading.

"Jonah, there is one thing you still don't understand."

"What?"

"Clara didn't disappear because she opened the door."

Jonah waited.

"She disappeared because somebody opened it for her."

A silence fell over the room.

Jonah looked toward the hallway.

"Who?"

Eleanor's lips trembled.

"Your daughter didn't go looking for the door by herself."

She lowered her voice.

"Someone called her from the other side."

The front door opened.

Olivia stood in the hallway.

Her eyes immediately found Jonah.

For a moment, she seemed relieved.

Then she noticed the pink notebook on the desk.

All the colour disappeared from her face.

"Where did you find that?"

Jonah stood.

"Eleanor showed it to me."

Olivia looked at Eleanor.

"You promised me you would never let him read it."

"I didn't have a choice," Eleanor replied.

"Of course you had a choice!"

Olivia turned toward Jonah.

"Please tell me you haven't read the last page."

He looked down at the notebook.

"I haven't."

Olivia slowly approached him.

"Then don't."

"Why?"

She reached for his hand.

"Because the last page contains the name of the person who called Clara to the door."

Jonah stared at her.

"And who is it?"

Olivia looked into his eyes.

Her voice was barely audible.

"Your name."

Jonah felt as though the floor had disappeared beneath him.

He looked at Olivia, searching her face for some sign that she was joking.

But she wasn't.

He slowly opened the notebook again.

The final page was folded inward.

He turned it over.

There, written in Clara's childish handwriting, were two lines:

The man behind the door says he is my father.

He looks exactly like Daddy, but he says Daddy is the one who doesn't belong here.

Jonah stopped breathing.

Below the words was a small drawing.

Two men stood on opposite sides of a black door.

They had the same face.

The same eyes.

The same small scar above the left eyebrow.

One was reaching toward the little girl.

The other was standing behind her.

At the bottom of the page, Clara had written one final sentence.

I DON'T KNOW WHICH ONE IS MY REAL DADDY.

Jonah slowly raised his eyes.

Olivia was crying.

Eleanor had turned away.

And somewhere beneath the old stone bridge, a door that should not exist had begun to open again.

More Chapters